PDA

View Full Version : Who knows their bits?


Jos Stratford
Friday 3rd June 2005, 15:45
A bit genius? Cropped to tax, not too tricky (bar one perhaps) ...no clues as to where at this stage

Blackstart
Friday 3rd June 2005, 16:15
Last one White Stork, Jos?

-Adam

Andrew
Friday 3rd June 2005, 17:20
Second one Crane?

Third one a tern of some sort?

Dimitris
Friday 3rd June 2005, 19:50
1)Looks like a Kite.I'll try Red Kite
2)Crane (I thought of Great Egret but toes look long...Wicked claws too...*ouch*)
3)I think terns have webbed legs and have forked tails(most do).This one dosen't seem to do.I'll say white Feral Pigeon.
4)I'll agree with Blackstart and say Stork

jurek
Friday 3rd June 2005, 20:04
(midsize raptor) marsh harrier, (large scolopacidae) blackwit, (commic tern) common tern, white stork.

Jos Stratford
Friday 3rd June 2005, 20:57
So far,
photo no.1 - no one has correctly named
photo no.2 - out of the two guesses, one is correct
photo no.3 - no one has correctly named
photo no.4 - congratulations to Blackstart, Dimitris and Jurek - it is a White Stork. Attached is the full size photo, taken this week.

Stewart J.
Friday 3rd June 2005, 21:22
1 - Long-legged Buzzard, 2 Blackwit, 3 Squacco

Stewart

Blackstart
Friday 3rd June 2005, 21:39
No. 1 - Crane

Reader
Friday 3rd June 2005, 22:32
1. Crane
2. Blackwit

moose1991
Saturday 4th June 2005, 08:55
1 Stork (again)
3 White winged Tern

Ghostly Vision
Saturday 4th June 2005, 11:02
Go on then I'll make a parus of myself (no books to check - that's my excuse)

1 Lesser Spotted eagle
2 Black tailed godwit
3 Black tern
4 Hybrid domestic duck?? (Or white stork)

GV

Jos Stratford
Saturday 4th June 2005, 13:09
Between you, you've got them all ...anyone want to put them together?

Harry Hussey
Saturday 4th June 2005, 14:26
1)Lesser Spotted Eagle
2)Black-tailed Godwit
3)White-winged Black Tern
4)White Stork

Harry

Clouseau
Saturday 4th June 2005, 15:07
White StorkB
Blackwit
Black Tern
White Stork

Jos Stratford
Saturday 4th June 2005, 15:28
1)Lesser Spotted Eagle
2)Black-tailed Godwit
3)White-winged Black Tern
4)White Stork

Harry

Very close, answer this evening, plus a couple more

Clouseau
Saturday 4th June 2005, 15:53
Lesser Spotted Eagle
Blackwit
Black Tern
White Stork

Clouseau
Sunday 5th June 2005, 08:44
So where's the answer??????????? LOL!

moose1991
Sunday 5th June 2005, 08:55
Maybe Jos is out Birding,wish I was.

Jos Stratford
Sunday 5th June 2005, 20:55
Maybe Jos is out Birding,wish I was.


Ha, got it one, out birding I was! Light and sunny til well past 10 p.m. these days and it sure makes up for the many months of snow and minus 25! Few Phalaropes, calling Corncrakes and etc this weekend,

So, for the answers ...

Not all that's big in the wing is a raptor - photo one was the one that caught most people out, so congratulations to Blackstart and Reader in identifying this one, snapped on my land, it is one of the Cranes breeding on my land!

All photos taken in the last couple of weeks,

1. Crane
2. Black-tailed Godwit
3. White-winged Black Tern
4. White Stork

Stewart J.
Sunday 5th June 2005, 21:03
Thanks Jos really enjoyed that even though my guesses were well out.

Stewart

B (:

Jos Stratford
Sunday 5th June 2005, 21:06
And the final round, just three photos, all taken on my land or local patch. I reckon there is an easy one in this lot, plus a moderate one and one a bit trickier ...but then of course I already know the answer!

Andrew
Sunday 5th June 2005, 21:12
1 - Yellow Wag? (the brown feathers and yellow on the undertail throws me)
2 - Hawfinch
3 - Dunnock

Stewart J.
Sunday 5th June 2005, 21:17
1 Yell Wag
2 Greenfinch
3 Crane?

Stewart

:h?:

dan pointon
Sunday 5th June 2005, 23:15
1. Yellow Wag
2. Greenfinch
3. Dunnock

Am i even close???

Dan

jurek
Monday 6th June 2005, 00:18
Tawny pipit, house sparrow, blackcap?

Jos Stratford
Monday 6th June 2005, 10:07
Photo 1 and 2 have been named by someone above, but nobody's within a million miles of photo 3 :)

Dimitris
Monday 6th June 2005, 12:21
I'll change my reply to...

Baillon's Crake..

the bird
Monday 6th June 2005, 12:32
Tawny pipit, house sparrow, blackcap?


Picture one - feels like wagtail sp.

Picture two - Greenfinch

Picture three - Blackcap I would say as well

The Bird - John

Andrew Whitehouse
Monday 6th June 2005, 13:23
1. Yellow Wagtail
2. Hawfinch
3. Little Crake

the bird
Monday 6th June 2005, 16:30
sora crake

jurek
Monday 6th June 2005, 16:47
third - corncrake?

mini-colster
Monday 6th June 2005, 20:38
1. Yellow Wagtail
2. Greenfinch
3. Chaffinch (female)

moose1991
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 00:01
I'm going to go for Thrush Nightingale for number 3.
Been looking at Jos's other thread on Eastern Europe.

harr1y
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 04:09
yellow wag
greenfinch
water rail
???????????

Jos Stratford
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 08:26
Congratulations to many, photos 1 and 2 have been named by quite a few.

Photo 1 is Yellow Wagtail (Grey-headed Wagtail)

Photo 2 is Greenfinch

Photo 3 ...noboby is close yet!

jacana
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 09:19
grey partridge

Reader
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 10:08
No 3. Rock Dove / Feral Pigeon

Vick2903
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 11:25
Redshank?

Runcorn Birder
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 13:35
3 is the eye of a tornado, viewed from the sky.

Or a Goldcrest

Jos Stratford
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 22:00
Still nobody is close! Could I point out the obvious and suggest to look at the colour of the face! :)

PS just noticed - you can even see me reflected in the eye if you look close enough!!!

Andrew
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 22:49
A young Black-winged Stilt?

Jos Stratford
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 22:51
A young Black-winged Stilt?

No records of this species in Lithuania, so I should be so lucky ;)

Andrew
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 23:01
Back to the Collins and searching all red eyed birds!!! ;)

Andrew
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 23:02
Got a sniff of a "clue" now!

Andrew
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 23:04
And the final round, just three photos, all taken on my land or local patch. I reckon there is an easy one in this lot, plus a moderate one and one a bit trickier ...but then of course I already know the answer!
Lesser or Middle Spotted Woody?

Stewart J.
Tuesday 7th June 2005, 23:47
This is dementing me, on reflection eye size in relation to cheek etc would suggest its not a passerine! Jos you sure do pick em.

Stewart

jacana
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 15:00
gadwall?

Runcorn Birder
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 16:16
Got it...

Ural owl ?!?!?!

jacana
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 16:29
no, the eye is on the side of the head, and not big enough, urals have all black eyes anyway, with a red/pink rim.

Runcorn Birder
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 16:33
On my screen the eye is black, and it also looks like the eye could be photographed from front on too. The feathering looks about right.

If it's a red eye then I need a new monitor...

Reader
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 17:13
On my screen the eye is black, and it also looks like the eye could be photographed from front on too. The feathering looks about right.

If it's a red eye then I need a new monitor...

You need a new monitor. lol ;)

jacana
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 18:19
and this is a native of Lithuania?

Jos Stratford
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 18:21
and this is a native of Lithuania?


All birds posted to date have been on my land, garden or local patch, so native, yes.

However, we do have a winner ...almost! :)

jacana
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 18:32
who? is it a gadwall or a woodpecker?

Jos Stratford
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 18:37
who? is it a gadwall or a woodpecker?



Does this help? I think Andrew well and truely deserves the :clap:


Another round?

jacana
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 18:38
ah, well done!

Andrew
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 21:01
It was a combination of the fact that the species had not been mentioned and that you see them regularly in your garden.

Jos Stratford
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 21:29
It was a combination of the fact that the species had not been mentioned and that you see them regularly in your garden.

Deduction is all part of the game!

So, a last little group - since eyes proved so popular (!), a couple more, along with a tail

Alan henry
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 21:37
Long time since I did any birding up the top part of the world but go for


White Wagtail
Blackbird (just to put a name to it)
Long Tailed tit

Alan

Andrew Rowlands
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 21:48
Lesser Grey Shrike, Nightjar and - an owl?

Andy.

Andrew
Wednesday 8th June 2005, 22:19
Collared Fly (hunch)
Nightjar
Crested Tit

the bird
Thursday 9th June 2005, 10:27
second bird - Woodcock???

dbradnum
Thursday 9th June 2005, 10:34
Great Grey Shrike
Woodcock
Crested Tit

Stewart J.
Thursday 9th June 2005, 10:45
Second bird Nightjar!!

Stewart

:h?:

Andrew Whitehouse
Thursday 9th June 2005, 13:33
Red-backed Shrike
Tawny Owl
Crested Tit

jurek
Thursday 9th June 2005, 14:10
GG shrike, woodcock, bluetit

lou salomon
Thursday 9th June 2005, 15:31
can i bump in here, sorry lost touch of this thread - interesting, very different guesses yet.
GG shrike (???)
nightjar
dunnock - naa, it's not. allright, crested tit then!

Jos Stratford
Thursday 9th June 2005, 21:44
All have been named, but noboby has got all three - two have named two correctly though

lou salomon
Thursday 9th June 2005, 23:23
lesser grey shrike
nightjar
crested tit

Clouseau
Thursday 9th June 2005, 23:45
Great Grey Shrike
Tawny Owl
Crested Tit

the bird
Friday 10th June 2005, 10:29
great grey shrike
Woodcock
crested tit

dbradnum
Friday 10th June 2005, 10:58
Red-backed Shrike
Woodcock
Crested Tit

lou salomon
Friday 10th June 2005, 13:23
maybe:
red-backed shrike
nightjar
crested tit

Clouseau
Saturday 11th June 2005, 21:04
Do we get the answer at any time? LOL!

Jos Stratford
Saturday 11th June 2005, 22:50
maybe:
red-backed shrike
nightjar
crested tit


Don't need the maybe there Lou, spot on. Congratulations.

So here's the three at full size...

Jos Stratford
Saturday 11th June 2005, 22:52
There is a sting in the tail of this quiz! All pictures were taken on my land or local patch ...except one! The Nightjar pictured above is not European Nightjar! Identify the species.

Jurij Hanžel
Sunday 12th June 2005, 02:39
Red-necked???

jacana
Sunday 12th June 2005, 10:15
has to be red necked (if it was in europe)

Clouseau
Sunday 12th June 2005, 10:38
Here! What's the bird in your avatar? Is it a Nutcracker? A cat? Wottizit? LOL!

alcedo.atthis
Sunday 12th June 2005, 12:06
"The Nightjar pictured above is not European Nightjar! Identify the species."

Just to be different "Square-tailed Nightjar Caprimulgus fossii"

Regards

Malky

lou salomon
Sunday 12th June 2005, 13:25
ok, red necked then - it has a red neck! (you won't have expected us to id r-n. nightjar from that eye!)
but thanks to andrew whitehouse for his red backed shrike...

Jos Stratford
Sunday 12th June 2005, 18:06
ok, red necked then - it has a red neck! (you won't have expected us to id r-n. nightjar from that eye!)


From the eye, I was happy to accept 'Nightjar' as the correct answer ;) . In reality it's not a European species!

Jos Stratford
Sunday 12th June 2005, 18:08
Here! What's the bird in your avatar? Is it a Nutcracker? A cat? Wottizit? LOL!


She could well be looking at a Nutcracker - get them flitting over occasionally in late summer or winter

lou salomon
Sunday 12th June 2005, 23:20
From the eye, I was happy to accept 'Nightjar' as the correct answer ;) . In reality it's not a European species!

i give up. anyone else with eyes on tropical/nearctic/oriental etc. nightjars - i don't look'em up all, now. or tell at least a continent to look for. :h?:

jacana
Monday 13th June 2005, 14:51
neschiar nightjar?? :D

Jurij Hanžel
Monday 13th June 2005, 16:07
neschiar nightjar?? :D

LOL! o:)

I would hazard a guess that this nightjar is from Asia.

Jos Stratford
Tuesday 14th June 2005, 09:52
I would hazard a guess that this nightjar is from Asia.

Correct ...not sure I'd be able to identify from head only without knowing locality either ;)

Jurij Hanžel
Tuesday 14th June 2005, 12:58
Hmm, you've been to Sri Lanka, right?

Jos Stratford
Tuesday 14th June 2005, 21:31
Hmm, you've been to Sri Lanka, right?

Correct, this narrows it down quite a bit :) ...but I have also been to India and Nepal too.

Jurij Hanžel
Wednesday 15th June 2005, 01:27
The possibilities are:
Great Eared-Nightjar Eurostopodus macrotis
Gray Nightjar Caprimulgus indicus
Sykes's Nightjar Caprimulgus mahrattensis
Large-tailed Nightjar Caprimulgus macrurus
Jerdon's Nightjar Caprimulgus atripennis
Indian Nightjar Caprimulgus asiaticus
Savanna Nightjar Caprimulgus affinis

It is one of those, right??

jacana
Wednesday 15th June 2005, 09:24
jerdon's nightjar

Jos Stratford
Wednesday 15th June 2005, 16:31
The possibilities are:
Great Eared-Nightjar Eurostopodus macrotis
Gray Nightjar Caprimulgus indicus
Sykes's Nightjar Caprimulgus mahrattensis
Large-tailed Nightjar Caprimulgus macrurus
Jerdon's Nightjar Caprimulgus atripennis
Indian Nightjar Caprimulgus asiaticus
Savanna Nightjar Caprimulgus affinis

It is one of those, right??


Yes it is!

Jurij Hanžel
Wednesday 15th June 2005, 18:40
OK, I can't get any further than this because I don't have the books and don't like using Google for bird ID.

alcedo.atthis
Wednesday 15th June 2005, 23:41
"OK, I can't get any further than this because I don't have the books and don't like using Google for bird ID."

Will this help :-

Birds of India

http://www.kolkatabirds.com/birdsind.htm

Scroll down the list and you will find photos of them.

Regards

Malky

Jurij Hanžel
Thursday 16th June 2005, 05:32
Thanks so much, Malky!!

Jurij Hanžel
Thursday 16th June 2005, 05:46
I had a look at the photos there, the closest I could find was a Savanna Nightjar. I couldn't see the white moustachial stripe (is this the right term?) on the photo at Birds of India, though.

Jos Stratford
Thursday 16th June 2005, 20:38
Photographed by lying on my stomach and wiggling up to one in the middle of the night just outside Yala National Park in Sri Lanka. Had a rather big (not seemingly too happy) Elephant blocking off my walk back to my motorbike afterwards!

Allen S. Moore
Friday 17th June 2005, 01:25
Photographed by lying on my stomach and wiggling up to one in the middle of the night just outside Yala National Park in Sri Lanka. Had a rather big (not seemingly too happy) Elephant blocking off my walk back to my motorbike afterwards!

Lying on your stomach in the middle of the night, it is as well that the Elephant did not have somewhere to go at that time!
It sort of reminds me of a potentially dangerous time watching choughs here in the Isle of Man. I had spotted a small flock of choughs from the road, and climbed over a gate into the next field to peer over the hedge. After a while, I heard the noise of a liquid running behind me, and there was a bull urinating as it stood about 10-20 metres away from me in the same field that I was in. Fortunately, he was standing contentedly with a harem of cows, and did not go for me. I suppose that he was happy enough to be surrounded by a bevy of beauties, in his eyes, obviously, not mine!
Allen

Ghostly Vision
Friday 17th June 2005, 13:37
Can't decide whether this has been identified yet, but if it was Yala, and you were on your belly, I guess it is Indian Nightjar then.

Elephants kill more people in SL than tarantulas don't they?

GV

jacana
Friday 17th June 2005, 14:52
i would say so, very few people die from tarantula bites, especially now when there are anti-serums on the market

Jurij Hanžel
Friday 17th June 2005, 15:12
Well, if it's SL, then it can't be a Savanna.

alcedo.atthis
Friday 17th June 2005, 20:45
"Photographed by lying on my stomach and wiggling up to one in the middle of the night just outside Yala National Park in Sri Lanka."

Take your pick :-
Caprimulgus indicus Grey Nightjar
Caprimulgus atripennis Jerdon's Nightjar
Caprimulgus asiaticus Indian Nightjar



Regards

Malky

Jos Stratford
Friday 17th June 2005, 20:48
Tis indeed an Indian Nightjar, thanks for all who contributed to this thread. :)