PDA

View Full Version : Wader ID


Grousemore
Friday 7th November 2003, 12:45
Can anyone ID this bird?

Michael Frankis
Friday 7th November 2003, 12:55
European Golden Plover

Michael

Jane Turner
Friday 7th November 2003, 13:15
First look it was more of a juv Grey to me...

Michael Frankis
Friday 7th November 2003, 13:19
Could be, I didn't think the bill was quite heavy enough.

Joern Lehmhus
Friday 7th November 2003, 13:25
I`d also vote for Grey Plover

Jane Turner
Friday 7th November 2003, 13:27
It pretty long billed and long legged.

Alastair Rae
Friday 7th November 2003, 13:40
I think it's that low, red sunlight that's confusing, causing the warmish tones that suggest Golden rather than Grey.

Larry Lade
Friday 7th November 2003, 15:05
I would vote for European Golden Plover.

Larry

Jane Turner
Friday 7th November 2003, 16:49
Also its a juv, which can get surpisingly golden and warm

CJW
Friday 7th November 2003, 16:58
Grey Plover.

Andrew Whitehouse
Friday 7th November 2003, 18:09
Just to be different I'm going to say American Golden Plover.

Grousemore
Friday 7th November 2003, 19:42
Thanks all for taking part;it is a Grey Plover,taken at Titchwell RSPB last Wednesday.
As Alastair suggested,I took it as the sun was setting,which introduced a 'buffy' tone to the colouration.

Tim Allwood
Friday 7th November 2003, 23:31
ooops - way too late - too much work I'm afraid
woulda gone for GP tho honest! hooge bill and super

Michael Frankis
Saturday 8th November 2003, 00:11
woulda gone for GP tho honest!
GP - that's a safe bet! A bit like saying B T Godwit . . . ;)

Tim Allwood
Saturday 8th November 2003, 01:26
aaarrgghh rumbled
so many GPs AGPs EGPs PGPs etc lately I thought GP was now code for Grey!

btw what's the significance of conehead if it aint to personal a question?

Michael Frankis
Saturday 8th November 2003, 02:04
Hi Tim,

Check out here - this will explain it
http://www.pinetum.org/cones/mpfcones.htm
This is far from complete as yet . . . only about a quarter or a third of the pics done

Michael

CJW
Saturday 8th November 2003, 07:56
GP - that's a safe bet! A bit like saying B T Godwit . . . ;)

Certainly safer than jumping in with both feet and getting it wrong.......