BirdForum

BirdForum (http://www.birdforum.net/index.php)
-   Yorkshire (http://www.birdforum.net/forumdisplay.php?f=171)
-   -   Yorkshire Birding (http://www.birdforum.net/showthread.php?t=61534)

Keith Dickinson Monday 5th January 2009 17:56

Michael,
I like the idea of the online resource but rather than taking it on yourself to host it completely, why not add pages to Opus for the relevant sites.
I've created a couple, one for Rodley and one for Potteric Carr and also added a bit to a page that already exists for Eccup Reservoir.
This is the Rodley page I created.

SteveClifton Monday 5th January 2009 18:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by scodger (Post 1372254)
Hi

Experienced birder, but lacking in gull ID other than usual basic stuff as have been busy with work and kids for many years so neglected it a bit. Have bought the Helm book, now lots more to look for so now looking for inland gatherings of gulls within 20 miles of Harrogate to watch and film with pro-video camera over next couple of months, the idea being to take time to review footage and start to learn full variations of plumage.

Can any gull-mad birders offer any easily accessible locations or anyone interested in meeting up now and again to check out sites, exchange notes, photograph and film, and generally get a bit more experience? Might even turn up some goodies, who knows?


Cheers

Scodger


Many of the best inland gull sites over the past few years are now past their best as a bye-product of the trend for recycling instead of sending waste to landfill. Nosterfield used to be excellent (was a working tip there until about 3-4 years ago), and quite close to you, but many of the large gulls are gone now (lucky to get 40-50 in the roost these days). It's interesting though, that even with only small numbers of larger gulls, the odd Iceland Gull is occasionally still recorded (Glaucous seem much scarcer these days away from the coast), especially when they start to move back north in the late winter.

I understand that Farnham GP can also be quite good too, but I've never done it other than to see the Pacific Diver last year. Perhaps it too is a mere shadow of its former self? Bolton-on-Swale GP is another site long past its prime.

Nosterfield is the nearest decent place to me (and you), and still quite good for the smaller gulls, mainly BHG and Common. I spend quite a few sessions there late on Saturday or Sunday afternoons in the months after Christmas. The Lingham viewing screen just down the road from Nosterfield village is one of the best places to view, as is Flasks lake (site of the recent 'Canvasback'). Many people seem to think that your best chance of finding something good is amongst the large gulls (they are certainly the most challenging to ID!) but I'm convinced that decent small gulls are probably overlooked amongst the thousands of BH gulls too. Finding your own Ring-billed, Bonaparte's, or even a Laughing or Franklin's has got to be one of your best chances of finding a rarity locally. It seems that most birders just don't look at gulls-too difficult/boring? They certainly seem to divide opinion like no other birds. Personally I love them, but don't claim to be an expert. Always something new to learn though, and they are genuinely accessible to most people without having to visit a 'proper reserve'.

It won't have escaped your notice that Teeside (Cowpen Bewley tip) is probably the best gull site within 40-50 miles of you, particularly after this past weekend's Glaucous-winged Gull, with literally thousands of big gulls present at any one time. There is another tip just down the road (can't remember its name), and the gulls have plenty of fresh water sites nearby to bathe and loaf about when not feeding. This place could keep you busy for hours!

Cheers,

Steve

John Bullfinch Monday 5th January 2009 19:27

Wintersett area
 
Had an extra day off work and went for my new year walk at Wintersett-Haw Wood-Anglers. None of the lakes were frozen which I was surprised at and there was a covering of snow. Saw most of the birds i was hoping for including Snipe, GS Woodpecker, Willow Tits, Jay, Treecreeper, Grey Wagtail, & Lesser Redpolls 8 near cold Hiendley Res. Also saw a female brambling at the feeder station in the car park. Many thanks to the gent who gave me information about the Waxwings that had moved into the village of Cold Hiendley - in the trees viewable from the green triangle in the middle of the village (you parked your car next to mine and were taking photos at the feeding station) - if your reading this I did find them - about 18 birds :t:

Cheers

John

bitterntwisted Monday 5th January 2009 21:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by scodger (Post 1372254)
Can any gull-mad birders offer any easily accessible locations or anyone interested in meeting up now and again to check out sites, exchange notes, photograph and film, and generally get a bit more experience? Might even turn up some goodies, who knows?

Swillington has several thousand gulls in the roost, often including white-winged and yellow-legged with caspian also recorded. Up to half a dozen enthusiasts watch the causeway on St. Aidan's from http://www.streetmap.co.uk/idl.srf?x...p=ids.srf&lm=1 )(Note this OS map badly needs updating as it's missing several million gallons of water north of that point)

The group's web site is http://se3828.wordpress.com/, and they have a hide at http://www.streetmap.co.uk/idl.srf?x...p=ids.srf&lm=1.

Graham

Daniel Martin Monday 5th January 2009 21:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daniel Martin (Post 1372340)
Hi all, just a word of warning re Poolsbrook as its 2 miles from my office and I do cover it. Yes there is a cafe! However, the birds rely upon the local tip and land being cleared for building at J29a of M1.
First of all the land around Markham pit yard has now been developed meaning the roost the gulls had day time is no more (last yeras Thayers was here).
And second someone is flying falcons at the Erin Tip to drive the gulls away. The results have been hugely disappointing for those of us used to such a good site - few large gulls at all. There has been an Iceland so far, but even the reliable Ogston roost is now badly affected with very few large gulls. No idea where they have gone.
Last year there was the putative Thayers, Kumliens, Iceland (6+) Glaucs (3+) but so far this year very little.

The Poolsbrook Country Park is worth a visit just in case - easy viewing and facilities on site. But, its certainly not producing the goods like last year. I would never discourage anyone from trying as "you never know", but also its worth knowing the latest if a big trip is involved. Its easily reached off J29a M1.

Cheers, Dan.

..............typical..........one of the regulars has found an adult Caspian there this afternoon........so maybe some quality to come after all........

garry1366 Tuesday 6th January 2009 00:43

Scodger,
I'd avoid evening Gull roosts if I were you. Gulls invariably come in just as it's getting too dark, they sit on the water and you can't see their legs and their structure is very different than normal and its cold(er).

What you need to find is a tip with some fresh water nearby where the birds will bathe and loaf, there will be regular interchange of birds and the views can be excellent. This is the way all serious Gull addicts do it.

You are very unlikely to get access to the tip itself in these days of health and safety nonsense but if you can many have areas of freshwater that can be viewed.

Remember big Gulls are sort as Sh*te and flush very easily whilst the smaller ones are much more approachable, although wearing a hi-viz jacket actually helps you get closer as the birds are used to the tip staff wearing them and without one you stand out as something different!

Oh and learn about moult its a prerequisite and its easy to see in the field, on such big birds. All the skills you learn are transferrable to other birds too so Gulling really does improve your birding

G

BirdFlower Tuesday 6th January 2009 05:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Keith Dickinson (Post 1372634)
Michael,
I like the idea of the online resource but rather than taking it on yourself to host it completely, why not add pages to Opus for the relevant sites.
I've created a couple, one for Rodley and one for Potteric Carr and also added a bit to a page that already exists for Eccup Reservoir.
This is the Rodley page I created.

Hi Keith,

I can see where you are coming from, but it would seem a little perverse to put "my sites" on Opus when most of the more well-known East Yorks sites featured by Mather aren't on there either! How long has Opus been operating? There seem to be an awful lot of gaps, eg no Tophill Low.

It would certainly be cheaper for me to add articles to Opus, rather than for paying for 4 new websites, one for each county.

I was thinking of articles which captured a more personal approach of contributors really intimate with a site, that wouldn't be possible, or even appropriate, in a more clinical, encyclopedic entry.

I know its probably only a computer program, but I'm sure I would find it rather annoying if I wrote an exhaustive article on one of my sites, and put it on Opus, only for their format to say this article was "incomplete" & asking for other hands to finish it!

I've not yet been overwhelmed with potential contributors from other counties of Yorkshire, so will probably just work on a "Neglected/Forgotten Birding Sites of East Yorkshire" website.

Cheers

Pete Mella Tuesday 6th January 2009 07:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by BirdFlower (Post 1373014)
Hi Keith,
I've not yet been overwhelmed with potential contributors from other counties of Yorkshire, so will probably just work on a "Neglected/Forgotten Birding Sites of East Yorkshire" website.

Cheers

I'll bung you a few South Yorks sites when you get the project off the ground.

BirdFlower Tuesday 6th January 2009 09:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete Mella (Post 1373054)
I'll bung you a few South Yorks sites when you get the project off the ground.

Cheers Pete

liverpool_bob Tuesday 6th January 2009 13:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by garry1366 (Post 1372975)
Remember big Gulls are sort as Sh*te and flush very easily

Some of the residents big gulls in the city centre of liverpool are so bold they've taken to wearing track suits... perhaps they're a separate (sub)species - Lacoste's Gull :eek!:

Hotspur Tuesday 6th January 2009 14:26

I propose a small competition for those Yorkshire Birders that come on the meets - a biannual (not biennial) ie spring and autumn finds competition. Nothing too serious, perhaps a fiver a piece for the best find of each season. Obviously that would give the coastal birders the advantage so i was thinking location should be taken into account. Plus it HAS to be in the county. I was really bored when communting today and came up with a potential system for deciding the winner - 2 rounds of voting. Firstly everyone taking part votes for the best find of each individual so a single bird by each competitor is forwarded to the final and then the a vote for the top find (obviously you cant vote for yourself). Prize to be awarded at the next meet after each period. Is anyone interested or have better propositions? Id suggest a new thread to put your top finds and locations on but wont start it until some declare interest.

Pete Mella Tuesday 6th January 2009 15:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hotspur (Post 1373318)
I propose a small competition for those Yorkshire Birders that come on the meets - a biannual (not biennial) ie spring and autumn finds competition. Nothing too serious, perhaps a fiver a piece for the best find of each season. Obviously that would give the coastal birders the advantage so i was thinking location should be taken into account. Plus it HAS to be in the county. I was really bored when communting today and came up with a potential system for deciding the winner - 2 rounds of voting. Firstly everyone taking part votes for the best find of each individual so a single bird by each competitor is forwarded to the final and then the a vote for the top find (obviously you cant vote for yourself). Prize to be awarded at the next meet after each period. Is anyone interested or have better propositions? Id suggest a new thread to put your top finds and locations on but wont start it until some declare interest.

Nice idea, but as a non-driving Sheffielder I may have to sit this one out!

skink1978 Tuesday 6th January 2009 16:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hotspur (Post 1373318)
I propose a small competition for those Yorkshire Birders that come on the meets - a biannual (not biennial) ie spring and autumn finds competition. Nothing too serious, perhaps a fiver a piece for the best find of each season. Obviously that would give the coastal birders the advantage so i was thinking location should be taken into account. Plus it HAS to be in the county. I was really bored when communting today and came up with a potential system for deciding the winner - 2 rounds of voting. Firstly everyone taking part votes for the best find of each individual so a single bird by each competitor is forwarded to the final and then the a vote for the top find (obviously you cant vote for yourself). Prize to be awarded at the next meet after each period. Is anyone interested or have better propositions? Id suggest a new thread to put your top finds and locations on but wont start it until some declare interest.

Great idea but a sure way for me to loose money. It would be a great incentive to get out in the field.

James Thomas Tuesday 6th January 2009 16:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hotspur (Post 1373318)
I propose a small competition for those Yorkshire Birders that come on the meets - a biannual (not biennial) ie spring and autumn finds competition. Nothing too serious, perhaps a fiver a piece for the best find of each season.


:choke: Thought this was the Yorkshire forum?

geoff dobbs Tuesday 6th January 2009 16:42

Mike

I may be able to give you some help with the East Yorks sites

geoff dobbs Tuesday 6th January 2009 16:52

Michael Clegg Memorial Yorkshire Bird race
 
Hi

As I haven't seen anything on the thread, just thought I'd mention that last Sunday, 4th January, the above mentioned annual bird race took place, with teams from Barnsley, Scarborough, Flamborough, Spurn, Hull Valley, Harrogate and maybe elsewhere.

The Hull Valley team broke Scarborough's 10-year grip, with a fairly respectable 101 species for the day within the Hull Valley recording area.

Notable omissions were Grey Partridge, Sparrowhawk, Red Kite, Redpoll, Knot, Kingfisher and Brambling as we ran out of time or just missed these at known stake-outs.

In the last 15 minutes of daylight at Tophill, Common Buzzard and three Little Egrets, all flying across D Res, were unexpected.

BirdFlower Tuesday 6th January 2009 17:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by jtw521 (Post 1373461)
:choke: Thought this was the Yorkshire forum?

I could throw in one of my 2009 Wildlife Calendars. As long as the first one takes place fairly soon, it won't be a complete non-prize!

Cheers

BirdFlower Tuesday 6th January 2009 17:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by geoff dobbs (Post 1373467)
Mike

I may be able to give you some help with the East Yorks sites

Thanks Geoff

BirdFlower Tuesday 6th January 2009 20:11

Rough-legged Buzzards
 
I may have once last chance to try & see the R.L. Buzzards tomorrow & would just like to check if you saw it as you walked from the car park past the pool & kept on going in the same direction? Some of the birdguide reports have implied it's best to head up the steep hill back the way you've just come in your car.

Thanks in advance

chris3871 Tuesday 6th January 2009 20:23

Just spent a good hour or so putting together an Opus page on North Cave Wetlands only to watch the bloody thing disappear into thin air. Damn it.

Marcus Conway - ebirder Tuesday 6th January 2009 20:40

Will write more stuff shortly. Firstly thanks to Lawts and James for the Text/VM alerts. Dipped Penduline for the fourth time, but had a great day at Rainham and then Rossi.

Michael, I will be back in touch by email shortly, but for now the RLB was at the far end as previously.

If anyone wants to come to Gwynedd tomorrow or Thursday please PM. Last two days with a car.

Hotspur Tuesday 6th January 2009 21:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by BirdFlower (Post 1373777)
I may have once last chance to try & see the R.L. Buzzards tomorrow & would just like to check if you saw it as you walked from the car park past the pool & kept on going in the same direction? Some of the birdguide reports have implied it's best to head up the steep hill back the way you've just come in your car.

Thanks in advance

Keep heading along the road until you enter the next valley from the pool. There is a footpasth headed up and left from the road halfway down the valley. Scale this and we had the bird over the escarpment at the head of the valley. This is the same place id seen both the female and the juv previously. At the same time as the RLB we had up to 10 Common Buzzards up at the same time at all points of the compass from this point as well as 3+ Red Kites.

Ben M Tuesday 6th January 2009 23:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by chris3871 (Post 1373793)
Just spent a good hour or so putting together an Opus page on North Cave Wetlands only to watch the bloody thing disappear into thin air. Damn it.

Any idea what went wrong?
Did you save any of it on your machine or online?

I tend to write my articles on my PC in a text editor, and save them frequently. When I'm done I copy and paste to the Opus site.

BirdFlower Wednesday 7th January 2009 06:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hotspur (Post 1373849)
Keep heading along the road until you enter the next valley from the pool. There is a footpasth headed up and left from the road halfway down the valley. Scale this and we had the bird over the escarpment at the head of the valley. This is the same place id seen both the female and the juv previously. At the same time as the RLB we had up to 10 Common Buzzards up at the same time at all points of the compass from this point as well as 3+ Red Kites.


Thanks Marcus & James (& for your PM) I know exactly where you mean
Weather now looks better for Friday, so thay may be a better bet
Cheers

Ingsbirder Wednesday 7th January 2009 08:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by BirdFlower (Post 1374070)
Thanks Marcus & James (& for your PM) I know exactly where you mean
Weather now looks better for Friday, so thay may be a better bet
Cheers

I've always had the Roughleg(s) from the head of the valley just as you enter after passing Millington. There are 4 wooden posts on the left which spell out 'GAIT'. From there you get a good over the valley, though the views may be more distant. In the valley bottom you have a very restricted view. The RLB(s) seem(s) to be ranging more widely now than when they were first discovered so perhaps better to use a viewpoint that covers more of the skyline.

Today is obviously not a good day for raptors......


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:43.

Powered by vBulletin®, copyright ©2000 - 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
© BirdForum Ltd 2002 - 2011