• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Brent Goose (1 Viewer)

Richard Klim

-------------------------
Lewis, Ward, Sedinger, Reed & Derksen 2013. Brant (Branta bernicla). BNA Online.

(Species account updated, 15 Nov 2013.)

Provisionally uses the name orientalis for Black Brant, restricting nigricans to Gray-bellied Brant (Parry Is).
Systematics: Subspecies
Four subspecies, following Delacour and Zimmer (1952); see also Carboneras (1992). A more conservative, and traditional, treatment is to recognize three subspecies (e.g., Dickinson and Remsen 2013), but to do so ignores a distinct population that breeds in the high Arctic of w. Canada for which a name is available (Buckley and Mitra 2002). Yet even the treatment below is provisional, as it accepts Buckley and Mitra's (2002) position that the type specimen of B. b. nigricans—from New Jersey even though the name was applied to Pacific birds—can be equated with otherwise unnamed breeders in the high Arctic of w. Canada. Moreover, this taxonomy better jibes with geographic and genetic divisions of breeding and wintering populations (Boyd and Maltby 1979, Reed et al. 1989a, Sedinger et al. 1993).

B. b. hrota (Müller, 1776), the Atlantic Brant, Light-bellied Brant, or Pale-bellied Brent Goose. ...

B. b. bernicla (Linnaeus, 1758), the Dark-bellied Brant or Dark-bellied Brent Goose. ...

B. b. orientalis Tugarinov, 1941, the Black Brant. Includes B. torquata (Blakiston and Pryer, 1878), and B. b. orientalis Tugarinov, 1941. Breeds from low Arctic of w. North America to high Arctic of e. Russia [type locality = e. Siberia]; winters along the Pacific Coast, from se. Alaska to central Baja California (Bellrose 1980, Subcommittee on Pacific Brant 1992, Sedinger et al. 1993). Broadly similar to B. b. bernicla, but belly blackish (contrasting little with breast and extending past legs), white fringes on flanks broad but restricted to rear flanks to form a distinct white patch, dorsum fuscous (i.e., blacker brown), and necklace wider and typically complete.

B. b. nigricans (Lawrence, 1846), the Gray-bellied or Lawrence's Brant. Includes B. torquata (Blakiston and Pryer, 1878). Breeds on the Parry Islands (Melville, Prince Patrick, and Borden) in the high Arctic of w. Canada and winters chiefly on Puget Sound (Boyd and Maltby 1979, Reed et al. 1989a), although a few winter records are from the Atlantic Coast (Delcour and Zimmer 1952, Buckley and Mitra 2002) [type locality = Egg Harbor, New Jersey]. Similar to B. b. orientalis, but belly dark gray (contrasting more with black breast) and less extensive (terminating at legs), upper breast and flanks "scaly" (like on B. b. hrota), and white fringes on flanks broad and more extensive, and necklace wider and typically complete.
 
Last edited:
Mike Earp has noted: "How can orientalis and nigricans both include torquata? And if orientalis rather than nigricans does, wouldn't that name have date precedence?"

John Penhallurick: World Bird Info.

Comments...?
 
Last edited:
It makes also little sense to note that B. b. orientalis Tugarinov, 1941 "includes" B. b. orientalis Tugarinov, 1941...
To me this suggests that a previous version must have said: "B. b. nigricans (Lawrence, 1846), the Black Brant. Includes B. torquata (Blakiston and Pryer, 1878), and B. b. orientalis Tugarinov, 1941."; then the nomenclature was modified, but the texts were incompletely changed.

I'm quite unclear why this "B. torquata (Blakiston and Pryer, 1878)" appears here at all, actually.
Blakiston and Pryer, 1878 is a catalogue of birds occurring in Japan. Therein they did not propose any new name, they just applied a name to the brant, that is credited to Jenyns. Jenyns did not propose any new name either, he used a name taken from Frisch, that he applied to British birds. Frisch (see also plate here) was describing German birds. Frisch was not binominal, hence names are not available from his work, and it might be possible to see Jenyns as having made Frisch's name available; however, this name had been used in available works quite few times before Jenyns used it, so there is no real point in doing this. The earliest use cited by John Penhallurick is by Bechstein, 1809, in application to German birds.
Thus, all in all, I see no point in considering that any name was made available by Blakiston and Pryer, 1878, and if I try to trace back the name they used, it seems clear that this name does not apply to any Japanese population.

Anyway, "torquata" could not be applied to the brant because it is preoccupied in the genus Branta by Anas torquata S.G. Gmelin, 1774, which is a junior synonym of Anser ruficollis Pallas, 1769.

L -
 
Last edited:
Laurent, your suggestion of an editing oversight seems likely, and if the name is anyway not available then there's obviously no potential conflict of priority with orientalis.

The reference for equating the type specimen of nigricans with the localised Gray-bellied Brant is:
 
Last edited:
Brent goose taxonomy

Hello all.

Tyler Lewis here, one of the authors of the recently revised Brant BNA. Thank you for pointing out the confusion regarding systematics in the new account, especially regarding use of 'Torquata'. We are currently in the process of revising and editing this section to reflect your comments.

Regards,
Tyler Lewis
 
Hello all.

Tyler Lewis here, one of the authors of the recently revised Brant BNA. Thank you for pointing out the confusion regarding systematics in the new account, especially regarding use of 'Torquata'. We are currently in the process of revising and editing this section to reflect your comments.

Regards,
Tyler Lewis

What a top chap. Now if he will only recommend splitting the b*****s he will be in line for a knighthood.

John
 
Birding Frontiers

Lewis, Ward, Sedinger, Reed & Derksen 2013. Brant (Branta bernicla). BNA Online.
(Species account updated, 15 Nov 2013.)

Provisionally uses the name orientalis for Black Brant, restricting nigricans to Gray-bellied Brant (Parry Is).

Poole, Woods, Iliff, Silk & Garner, Birding Frontiers, 9 Jan 2014: Grey-bellied Brant.

Includes links to...
  • Lewis et al 2013. Brant (Branta bernicla). BNA Online. [free access]
  • Garner 2008. Brent Geese of four kinds: Dark-bellied Brent, Pale-bellied Brent, Black Brant and Grey-bellied Brant, in Frontiers in Birding.
 
Last edited:
Wildfowl Special Issue

Rees (Ed) 2013. Proceedings of the Fifteenth Conference of the Goose Specialist Group, Arcachon, France: 8–11 January 2013. Wildfowl Special Issue 3.

Includes...
  • Boyd, Ward, Kraege & Gerick 2013. Migration patterns of Western High Arctic (Grey-belly) Brant Branta bernicla. Wildfowl Special Issue 3: 3–25. [abstract] [pdf]
 
Last edited:
Warning! This thread is more than 11 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top