Several more warblers, Winnipeg, Canada (1 Viewer)

khustochka

Well-known member

• Sep 19, 2014

• #1

Could you please help identify (seen September 13 in Winnipeg, MB):

1) Blackpoll Warbler ?
2) Palm Warbler ?
3) Theoretically I think about Nashville, but cannot be sure, never seen it.
4) ??
5) ??

 

Attachments

• 
  IMG_3937.JPG

  214.8 KB · Views: 58
• 
  IMG_4445.JPG

  143.9 KB · Views: 75
• 
  IMG_4019.JPG

  82.7 KB · Views: 71
• 
  IMG_3824.jpg

  122.9 KB · Views: 67
• 
  IMG_3985.JPG

  149.7 KB · Views: 83

K

Kratter

Well-known member

• Sep 19, 2014

• #2

1) yes, Blackpoll
2) Orange-crowned Warbler
3) Maybe a Yellow Warbler?
4) Palm Warbler
5) not sure, maybe Yellow-rumped Warbler
Andy

 

JWN Andrewes

Poor Judge of Pasta.

• Sep 19, 2014

• #3

Kratter said:

1) yes, Blackpoll
2) Orange-crowned Warbler
3) Maybe a Yellow Warbler?
4) Palm Warbler
5) not sure, maybe Yellow-rumped Warbler
Andy

Click to expand...

I'd agree with 1 - 4, but suggest another Palm for 5

Cheers

James

Ps - Really racking up the warblers there khustochka!

 

khustochka

Well-known member

• Sep 19, 2014

• #4

JWN Andrewes said:

Ps - Really racking up the warblers there khustochka!

Click to expand...

I am feeling guilty for asking so many questions, but I am really puzzled and not confident with identifying them by myself with a field guide only. There are so many warblers and variations make them look so similar. This is the last batch, I promise!

 

A

Andy1979

Well-known member

• Sep 19, 2014

• #5

So long as you've given it a go, please don't feel you can't keep asking. It's how we birders learn.

Andy M

 

Larry Sweetland

Formerly 'Larry Wheatland'

• Sep 19, 2014

• #6

agree with Palm for #5

 

Tiraya

San Diego CA

• Sep 19, 2014

• #7

Hmm...yellow warbler has an eye ring but that seems quite distinct and too brightly white for me. Only Virginia's and Nashville tend to have an eye ring like that. I've seen photographic conditions that highlight a yellow warbler's eye ring but even accounting for that the rest of the bird doesn't feel right. The bill is also a little on the long side, in favour of Nashville.

The apparent grey hood bothers me as well. It isn't lighting because you can see contrast between that and the yellow underparts. So I'm pushing Nashville at the moment.

 

Larry Sweetland

Formerly 'Larry Wheatland'

• Sep 19, 2014

• #8

Silverwolf said:

Hmm...yellow warbler has an eye ring but that seems quite distinct and too brightly white for me. Only Virginia's and Nashville tend to have an eye ring like that. I've seen photographic conditions that highlight a yellow warbler's eye ring but even accounting for that the rest of the bird doesn't feel right. The bill is also a little on the long side, in favour of Nashville.

The apparent grey hood bothers me as well. It isn't lighting because you can see contrast between that and the yellow underparts. So I'm pushing Nashville at the moment.

Click to expand...

I was also thinking this, but far from sure with this pic.

 

khustochka

Well-known member

• Sep 22, 2014

• #9

Many thanks to everyone for you help, I appreciate it!

 

JANJ

Well-known member

• Sep 23, 2014

• #10

Note the pointed bill in bird nr 3 - "Vermivora (Now Oreothlypis) pointed" together with complete pale eye-ring say´s Nashville.

http://www.symbolicmessengers.com/Warblers_L-O.htm

http://www.giffbeaton.com/warblers.htm

JanJ

 

khustochka

Well-known member

• Sep 26, 2014

• #11

JANJ said:

Note the pointed bill in bird nr 3 - "Vermivora (Now Oreothlypis) pointed" together with complete pale eye-ring say´s Nashville.

http://www.symbolicmessengers.com/Warblers_L-O.htm

http://www.giffbeaton.com/warblers.htm

JanJ

Click to expand...

Thank you, Jan. I was judging by those features too when I decided it could be Nashville.