• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Monoculars (1 Viewer)

Arbu

Well-known member
An odd one this. Does anyone have any experience of using a monocular?

My planned trip to Mauritania has been blown out because of the deteriorating security situation there, so I'll be going to southern Algeria instead. The only problem is that the tour operator tells me that binoculars (jumelles) are forbidden. Ridiculous. We'll be out in the desert, what are we going to look at that's of concern to them? So I had the idea of taking a monocular instead. If they take it off me at immigration at least I can say I complied with the instructions I was given. So I was thinking of buying a monocular. Some of them don't even look like half a pair of binoculars (http://www.scopesnskies.com/prod/255.html). And it seems they aren't too expensive - are they OK to use?
 
Any optic is going to be better than no optic so; if a monocular is your only choice, then go with it. I would recommend you look at the little Zeiss monoculars as a first choice rather than some ultra-cheapie that is sure to dissapoint. First however, I would verify the information you recieved from the tour operator - something about it just doesn't sound right.

Secondly, (assuming you can be reasonably confident you can have one) I would think an ultra-small, low-mid power spotting scope (Leupold 10-20x40 Gold Ring Compact, Kowa TS500 series, Nikon ED 50, etc.) would prove far superior to any cheap monocular. They can even be used (at low mags) handheld.

Finally, if the binocular ban is in fact true and a small spotting scope is also not possible, I would argue that you should get a fairly long telephoto lens for your DSLR camera (assuming you have one) instead of/in addition to the monocular.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, I'll have a look at your suggestions. In the meantime here's what I've been told by a tour operator (hope you understand French, but if not, I can tell you she's saying it's a very bad idea to take them):

"Bonjour

Les jumelles sont effectivement toujours interdites en Algérie.
Si vous souhaitez les emmener sur place et que les autorités locales s'en rendent compte, elles vous seront confisqués et vous serez soumis à la loi locale.

Je reste à votre disposition

Cordialement"

My own tour operator has also said that they're forbidden, although another one says that only night vision binoculars are forbidden.

I spoke to someone at the Algerian Consulate in London today and he said that as long as I declared them on arrival and took them out again, he thought there would be no problem.

So who knows? I could spend £15 on a monocular and if it gets confiscated I don't mind too much and if I get soumis a la loi locale I'll just say that a monocular isn't a jumelle and if it is (which I don't admit) the man at the consulate said it would be OK.

Alternatively I have an SLR with a 300mm image stabilisation lens which I could fall back on and just look through that.
 
I checked on the US State Departments Individual Country List and found the following.

"SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES: Algeria maintains restrictions on the import and export of local currency. Foreign currency must be exchanged only at banks or authorized currency exchange locations, such as major hotels. Photography of military and government installations is prohibited. It is also illegal to import weapons, body armor, handcuffs or binoculars." [emphasis added]

So, while completely silly, it does appear that taking a binocular to the country would in in fact, be a crime.

The US State Department's Travel Warning is also fairly interesting. Obviously it is targeted towards US Citizens but, I would imagine it would be fairly applicable to any "Westerner."


ALGERIA
December 23, 2007

This Travel Warning is being updated to alert U.S. citizens to recent terrorist attacks in Algeria . The threat from terrorism in many areas of the country continues to pose a significant security risk. This supersedes the Travel Warning issued on September 14, 2007.

The Department of State urges U.S. citizens who travel to Algeria to evaluate carefully the risk posed to their personal safety. Sustained small-scale terrorist attacks including bombings, false roadblocks, kidnappings, ambushes, and assassinations occur regularly, particularly in northeastern Algeria . A roadside bomb targeted a bus transporting foreign workers of a U.S. company in the western part of Algiers in December 2006. In April 2007 three suicide bombers detonated vehicle-borne explosives outside of government buildings in central Algiers . Three more suicide bomb attacks in July and September 2007 in Lakhdaria, Batna and Dellys killed more than 80 Algerians. On December 11, 2007, two vehicle-borne explosive devices were detonated at the UN headquarters and the Algerian Constitutional Council in Algiers . The attacks occurred in residential areas where many diplomatic missions are located. The group that claimed credit for the December 11 attacks has pledged more attacks against foreign targets, and specifically American targets.

The U.S. Government considers the potential threat to U.S. Embassy personnel assigned to Algiers sufficiently serious to require them to live and work under significant security restrictions. These practices limit, and may occasionally prevent, the movement of U.S. Embassy officials in certain areas of the country. The Government of Algeria requires U.S. Embassy personnel traveling outside the province of Algiers or to the Casbah within Algiers to seek permission and to have a security escort. Travel to the military zone established around the Hassi Messaoud oil center requires Government of Algeria authorization. Daily movement of Embassy personnel in Algiers is limited, and prudent security practices are required at all times. Travel by personnel to areas of the city outside the center requires prior coordination with the Embassy's Regional Security Office. American visitors are encouraged to contact the Embassy's Consular Section for the most recent safety and security information concerning travel in the city of Algiers .

The Department of State recommends that U.S. citizens avoid overland travel in the mountainous northern part of the country, and particularly in the area stretching from Algiers east to the Tunisian border.

The Department of State cautions Americans who reside or travel in Algeria to take prudent security measures while in the country, including making provisions for reliable and experienced logistical support. This support should include being met upon arrival and accompanied for the duration of the visit. Visitors should ensure that tour operators and host organizations perform all notifications and coordination with Algerian police and security officials during their stay. Visitors to Algeria are advised to stay only in hotels where adequate security is provided. Avoid places where Westerners are known to congregate or visit, including bars and restaurants, places of worship, or schools. All visitors to Algeria should remain alert and adhere to prudent security practices such as avoiding predictable travel patterns and maintaining a low profile.
 
Thanks, yes, I was aware of this page. We will have reliable and experienced logistical support the whole time we're there, and we won't be anywhere near where the recent bombings have been.
 
Monocular in Algeria

Hello, I am not sure about replying, how to do this...

Did you try the monocular in Algeria?
I did to go Mauritania in January of 2008, all was OK for my group (French). Now I will be going to Algeria. I always carry a monocular with me, even around home. Did you manage to use one in Algeria?? Did you declare it?
Thanks,
Birder in PA

An odd one this. Does anyone have any experience of using a monocular?

My planned trip to Mauritania has been blown out because of the deteriorating security situation there, so I'll be going to southern Algeria instead. The only problem is that the tour operator tells me that binoculars (jumelles) are forbidden. Ridiculous. We'll be out in the desert, what are we going to look at that's of concern to them? So I had the idea of taking a monocular instead. If they take it off me at immigration at least I can say I complied with the instructions I was given. So I was thinking of buying a monocular. Some of them don't even look like half a pair of binoculars (http://www.scopesnskies.com/prod/255.html). And it seems they aren't too expensive - are they OK to use?
 
Hello, I am not sure about replying, how to do this...

Did you try the monocular in Algeria?
I did to go Mauritania in January of 2008, all was OK for my group (French). Now I will be going to Algeria. I always carry a monocular with me, even around home. Did you manage to use one in Algeria?? Did you declare it?
Thanks,
Birder in PA

Hi Lucy

From what I recall there wasn't any opportunity to declare things. They just put our bags through an X-Ray machine and stopped us if they found anything. They found my binoculars and I had to leave them at the airport but they didn't find the monocular. Here's my trip report: http://www.birdforum.net/showthread.php?t=107337&highlight=algeria
 
Warning! This thread is more than 15 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top