• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Field Guides (1 Viewer)

whomes

whomes

Well-known member
Being fairly new to all this I'm quickly learning how important a good field guide is.

Using my RSBP pocket book I tried to confirm some ducks today. I was pretty sure they were Teal, but going on my past misidentificatons (Dartford Warbler for Stonechat, Peregrine for Sparrowhawk, the list increases) I thought I'd check in the book. Everything fitted except the yellow patch on side of tail, which wasn't mentioned anywhere!

Back home to the RSPB Handbook of British Birds and the obvious confirmation was obtained. Can anyone recommend a definitive guide for the hard of thinking?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2752zx.jpg
    IMG_2752zx.jpg
    117.7 KB · Views: 207
whomes said:
Being fairly new to all this I'm quickly learning how important a good field guide is.

Using my RSBP pocket book I tried to confirm some ducks today. I was pretty sure they were Teal, but going on my past misidentificatons (Dartford Warbler for Stonechat, Peregrine for Sparrowhawk, the list increases) I thought I'd check in the book. Everything fitted except the yellow patch on side of tail, which wasn't mentioned anywhere!

Back home to the RSPB Handbook of British Birds and the obvious confirmation was obtained. Can anyone recommend a definitive guide for the hard of thinking?
Click to expand...
Best european field guide is the Collins Bird Guide (Mullarney, Svensson, Zetterstrom and Grant), or some prefer Birds of Europe (Jonsson). A bigger ID guide that is worth getting is the Handbook of Bird Identification (Beaman and Madge). A useful lightweight pocket guide is Birds of Britain and North-West Europe (Knightley, Madge and Nurney).
 
Last edited:
Hi Whomes,
The Collins Guide to Birds of Britain & Europe (Fitter et al.) tends to be the commonest. There are several others - you could try Amazon- some websites let you browse the contents of the books.
Halftwo
 
whomes said:
Thanks all - Collins guide for Xmas then (£11.21 from Amazon apparently!)
Click to expand...
There's a Best Bird Book thread in the Tips For New Birders section. I recently posted about getting the Hardback Collin's for £12.49 (1/2 RRP) at Waterstones. Maybe it works out better than Amazon, if you take into account postage and the fact that you can look through it first. Also, the Amazon one at 11.21 might be paperback (which you might prefer?!).

In all cases, a great book.
 
whomes said:
Thanks all - Collins guide for Xmas then (£11.21 from Amazon apparently!)
Click to expand...

I should be on commission here, but endorse the choice completely. The only criticism I think has legs is that it has too many species for the beginner, and is also therefore bulkier than you might want.

Well, it ain't small but I can just stuff it in one of my pockets. It has many birds you'll never see but it clearly codes which occur in the UK, when, and in what numbers so you should be able to assess relative likelihood. Plus it therefore covers any european advnetures you go on.

Oh, and it doesn't cover auks of the Pacific, so you risk mis-identifying one. But what are the chances, eh?

Graham
 
Birds of Britain and North-West Europe (Knightley, Madge and Nurney). This lives in my car.
The Collins guide is great but there is sometimes too much in it, hardly ever take it out with me.
 
pduxon said:
which is brilliant but even bulkier.
Click to expand...

'Tis fair comment. I'm pretty bulky myself so it suits me. Ultimately it has to be a question of personal taste. Very very few people would dispute the excellence of Collins, and I don't think there is much reason not to own one, but you may find that you want something smaller to carry around.

Graham
 
Be careful: there are two guides published by Collins, both priced £11.21 on Amazon!

The one (I'd suggest) you want is by Grant, Mullarney & Zetterstrom - it's relatively recently produced, and the artwork is fantastically accurate.

The other, by Heinzel, Fitter and Parslow, is a reprint of a much older book. It's not at all bad (was very highly rated in its day), but by comparison is rather dated.
 
No harm in having a few guides, to compare and contrast - especially when you're starting out. No one artist can capture every bird just as you see it. Even a decent photoguide to go alongside can help.
 
I have Collins & the quick index that someone here made for it - the Collins index isn't the greatest.
However the book I take everywhere with me is the Hamlyn guide, Birds of Britain & Europe - £3.99 from National Trust shop when there's a sale on (pretty much all the time).
I like it for many reasons....
It's easier to find the birds
Covers rare migrants & vagrants
Has a good intro of bird topography & birdwatching info
The descriptions are concise and easily readable
The call descriptions are often more understandable than Collins
It weighs a lot less.

Having a book is one thing - not much good if you can't see the birds - Geoff Sample's Bird Songs & Calls from Collins (2 x CDs) is excellent - when you know the call you can consult the book to find out where you should be looking.
 
bitterntwisted said:
I should be on commission here, but endorse the choice completely. The only criticism I think has legs is that it has too many species for the beginner, and is also therefore bulkier than you might want.

Well, it ain't small but I can just stuff it in one of my pockets. It has many birds you'll never see but it clearly codes which occur in the UK, when, and in what numbers so you should be able to assess relative likelihood. Plus it therefore covers any european advnetures you go on.

Oh, and it doesn't cover auks of the Pacific, so you risk mis-identifying one. But what are the chances, eh?

Graham
Click to expand...

I've never been so insulted! The pic on the left is the Marbled Murrulet, and the one on the right is clearly a Little Auk.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0388abb.jpg
    IMG_0388abb.jpg
    28 KB · Views: 97
  • IMG_0341cbb.jpg
    IMG_0341cbb.jpg
    27.9 KB · Views: 123
Mike Johnston said:
or some prefer Birds of Europe (Jonsson).
Click to expand...
I have got L.Jonsson "Birds of Europe" and it is great :t:
I don't see "Collins", but have listened a lot of positive opinions |;|
 
Chris Oates said:
I have Collins & the quick index that someone here made for it - the Collins index isn't the greatest.
Click to expand...

This may be a fair comment but tragically I don't know as I pretty much had Voous order memorised when I was seven - at least to the level of families and most genera. But I can see that for the less geeky a poor index could be a problem.

My parents have an RSPB guide that they like because it has all the little birds at the front! What a travesty - utterly unusable.

With the whole thing getting shifted about, Anatidae moving up to the top etc. are future guides going to reflect this? Not looking forward to being an old dog learning new books.

Graham
 
Warning! This thread is more than 18 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Similar threads

S
Attenborough nature reserve Nottinghamshire, Uk today (12/1/24)
Replies
8
Views
629
Butty
B
killik
NZ Field Guide
Replies
12
Views
1K
njlarsen
njlarsen
SteveClark
6 weeks in the UK - which field guide book to get
2
Replies
27
Views
2K
Stu57
Stu57
D
Field guides Nepal (birds and mammals)
Replies
5
Views
1K
MiddleRiver
MiddleRiver
C
Pocket field guide for Ohio song birds
Replies
10
Views
832
Mike Earp
M

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top