-
Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.
Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Difficult thrush? Costa Rica (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Coati
- Start date
birdboybowley
Well-known member.....apparently so ;)
White-throated Thrush (or Robin as they're still wrongly referred to)
Motmot
Eduardo Amengual
I guess the conspicuous eyering of a White-throated Thrush should be discernible in this image. I wonder if it's just a Clay-coloured Thrush like the one below:
http://www.birdfinders.co.uk/images/clay-colored-robin.jpg
Any more pics?
http://www.birdfinders.co.uk/images/clay-colored-robin.jpg
Any more pics?
colonelboris
Right way up again
I saw the title and thought "canesten"...
birdboybowley
Well-known member.....apparently so ;)
Could well be M...uppers just looked a little cold in colour and I did wonder about the eyering...
tomjenner
Well-known member
My gut feeling was White-throated Thrush, based on the upperpart colouration and heavy throat streaking (Cley-coloured Thrush would be paler and warmer above and have slightly thinner streaks). However, individuals do vary and could well be a Cley-coloured. White-throated Thrush can be seen down to nearly sea level. I would expect White-throated Thrush in forest, while Cley-coloured would be in more open country (with some overlap in the middle).
Tom
Tom
birdboybowley
Well-known member.....apparently so ;)
Rich, where did you take this photo?
screaming piha
Well-known member
Isn't that one a Norfolk endemic?
Motmot
Eduardo Amengual
Not saying it can't be a W-t Thrush but that would be a (very) rare bird on location. I lived there for 6 months and also have birded the whole south caribbean area many times and never found this species. C-c Thrush would be much more likely.
Edit: you mean Puerto Viejo de Sarapiquí (NE caribbean lowlands) or P.Viejo de Talamanca (SE caribbean lowlands/coast)? A classical crican question...
Last edited:
Not to sound rude, but I find it weird that you're ruling out Clay-colored based on chunkiness, yet originally considered Swainson's Thrush to be an option.
My vote is for Clay-colored, for what it's worth.
Coati
Yo Vi Quetzales!
Swainsons was a poor idea
I don't know what possessed me lol
As a beginner I must learn to take ALL factors into consideration when making ID.s
Rich
tomjenner
Well-known member
It could well be a Clay-coloured Thrush. Looking through my photos I see that they tend to be much paler brown than this bird, but it could be affected by shade. In any case, there is a lot of variation. I have attached a picture (second photo) of one that is at the duller end of the spectrum and similar to the Costa Rican bird. I was also looking at the throat markings and many Clay-coloured Thrushes have streaking that is similar to the Costa Rican bird.
Nearly all the White-throated Thrush photos in my collection show a very clear yellow orbital, but the one attached (first photo, taken in January, so not a juv) does not seem to show it (assuming I did not make a mistake in the identification of this bird, which I am starting to think is a real possibility). The eye of the Costa Rican bird is a bit covered over, but clearly does not show the distinctive eye ring seen on most White-throated thrushes (see third photo).
I'm coming round to Clay-coloured, but still not 100% sure.
Tom
All photos taken in El Salvador - 1 by John Jackson, 2 by me, and 3 by Leti Andino
Nearly all the White-throated Thrush photos in my collection show a very clear yellow orbital, but the one attached (first photo, taken in January, so not a juv) does not seem to show it (assuming I did not make a mistake in the identification of this bird, which I am starting to think is a real possibility). The eye of the Costa Rican bird is a bit covered over, but clearly does not show the distinctive eye ring seen on most White-throated thrushes (see third photo).
I'm coming round to Clay-coloured, but still not 100% sure.
Tom
All photos taken in El Salvador - 1 by John Jackson, 2 by me, and 3 by Leti Andino
Attachments
screaming piha
Well-known member
Hi Tom
You did make a mistake with that first thrush: it is a Rufous-collared (Turdus rufitorques). It was on the volcano (Santa Ana?) near San Salvador.
John
You did make a mistake with that first thrush: it is a Rufous-collared (Turdus rufitorques). It was on the volcano (Santa Ana?) near San Salvador.
John
tomjenner
Well-known member
You are absolutely correct. Here is a second shot of the same bird showing the white streaking to the undertail coverts, which Howell and Webb describes as distinctive. I haven't looked at one of these all dark immatures before and I guess I may well have been missing them in the past. As you guessed, the photo was taken at Cerro Verde, which is beside Santa Ana.
With that one cleared up I am also now pretty convinced that my guess of White-throated Thrush for the Costa Rican bird was also in error. It seems that it must have been a Clay-coloured Thrush.
For the record, Rufous-collared Thrush is not found much further south than El Salvador and certainly has never been seen near Costa Rica.
Tom
