Variegated Flycatcher in Panama? (1 Viewer)

SueO · Feb 27, 2011

Hi All,
Do I have a Very Rare bird here, or am I just not seeing things right?? I think I have a Variegated Flycatcher, but they are not supposed to be in Panama.
I have been organizing my photographs and sending them to my Picassa Web site and I came across a bird I saw here a year ago: January 18, 2010.
We had not been in Panama long and most birds were still new to me. I was confused by this bird and finally thought it must be a Streaked Flycatcher, but an insolens race, because of the unmarked undertail coverts. Maybe, it was a young bird? I didn’t have illustrations or images that allowed me a positive ID., and I filed it away. I looked in on that bird many times for afterward and remained confused.
A year later, I am more comfortable with the Flycatchers and when I went to transfer this photo, I realized that the bill was not big enough for a Streaked.
I am not going to go into detail here about my thoughts and my searching process here. If I’m right, I will post the long winded version on my blog. If I’m wrong, I still have a Lifer.

My reasons for my thinking in terms of Variegated:
1. Bill seems too long for Piratic.
2. Pale base on bill.
3. Prominent edging on wing coverts.
4. Rufous on tail. (arrow on image)
5. Throat is not white.
Sue

Birdingcraft · Feb 27, 2011

It sure looks like a Variegated for the reasons you mention.

SueO · Feb 27, 2011

Thanks for your input Patrick. I had to question this even though I thought I was right. I have googled and found no posts at all about a Variegated in Panama. I did find a record for Washington State.
Sue

Motmot · Feb 27, 2011

Are you 100% sure these pics were taken in Panama?

SueO · Feb 27, 2011

Motmot said:
Are you 100% sure these pics were taken in Panama?

Hi Eduardo,
I am 110% sure these were taken in Panama. I know the exact tree he was in. He was on the 'Kennedy Loop' walk. It has been a mystery bird for me and I am not mistaken. I have a date on my camera and a passport.

Also, I don't think I've been in any of the countries the bird is in (I will have to look at the range again to be sure about that.) Here is the google map for the Kenedy Loop. I have marked an X where the bird was.
Sue
EDIT: Funny you should ask. This morning, when I was saying, "I have a Real Rarity!" and was congratulating myself and doubting myself at the same time, my husband looked at the photo and said he thought I was right. Then he said, "The problem is, how do you prove the photo came from here?"

SueO · Feb 27, 2011

These are the countries the bird is listed in (excludes the US):

Guyana,Peru,Argentina,Brazil,Paraguay,Ecuador,French Guiana,Uruguay,Trinidad and Tobago,Suriname,Bolivia,Canada,Colombia,Venezuela,

I have been to Canada, but not since I was 10 years old, and I have never been to any of the other countries.
Sue

EDIT: Oops, I just realized I have been to Canada as an adult. Gene and I bought Peregrine in Seattle and we did a 'shake-down' sail to Victoria before sailing her down the coast to California. However, I didn't find this bird there.

Motmot · Feb 27, 2011

Well that's great news then!! It seems you've actually found a rarity/poss 1st for Panama. I also think this bird looks best for Variegated. I'd recommend sending the pics and report to George Angehr angehrg'at'si.org and also to the Xenornis website for spreading the info. Unless some actual expert sees this as a Piratic of some sort I guess you've done it! :t:
Congrats Sue

SueO · Feb 27, 2011

Motmot said:
Well that's great news then!! It seems you've actually found a rarity/poss 1st for Panama. I also think this bird looks best for Variegated. I'd recommend sending the pics and report to George Angehr angehrg'at'si.org and also to the Xenornis website for spreading the info. Unless some actual expert sees this as a Piratic of some sort I guess you've done it! :t:
Congrats Sue

Thanks Eduardo. I'm really excited about this. I've had this unidentified bird hanging around since last January and I found the ID by luck. Part of my blog post today:

.....I was thinking it was too bad my Sibley’s didn’t have an illustration of this bird for comparison and I suddenly remembered seeing a Piratic Flycatcher illustration in my National Geographic Field Guide to the Birds of North America. I dug it out. I was even more convinced my bird was not a Piratic. The Piratic's bill was too small and the wing coverts were not edged. However, the bird illustrated next to the Piratic sure looked like my bird: Variegated Flycatcher (Empidonomus varius). I found the ID to my bird serendipitously. Why had I not seen this bird before? Surely, if that bird had been in my Ridgley guide I would have seen it? ....

halftwo · Feb 27, 2011

Well done, Sue!

I've PMed you too.

Cimperialis · Feb 27, 2011

I'm pretty sure there's at least one record for Maine, and maybe some other northeast states, demonstrating the species' ability to vagrate.

SueO · Feb 27, 2011

Motmot said:
I'd recommend sending the pics and report to George Angehr angehrg'at'si.org and also to the Xenornis website for spreading the info. Unless some actual expert sees this as a Piratic of some sort I guess you've done it! :t:
Congrats Sue

Eduardo
I've sent emails and photos to both.
Sue
EDIT: Got a mailer daemon back on the George Angehr's address.

njlarsen · Feb 27, 2011

Sue, Congratulations!
Try contact Panama Audubon, http://www.panamaaudubon.org/. They are co-publishers on one of George Angerh's books.

Niels

SueO · Feb 28, 2011

Thanks Niels. I will try that.
Sue

Chris Benesh · Feb 28, 2011

Hi Sue,

Thanks for the PM. I agree that this is a Variegated Flycatcher. Looks like a first for Panama. Congratulations.

Chris

james holdsworth · Feb 28, 2011

Cimperialis said:
I'm pretty sure there's at least one record for Maine, and maybe some other northeast states, demonstrating the species' ability to vagrate.

One spent a month near Toronto, Ontario quite a few years back.

Lisa W · Feb 28, 2011

Sue, what a great find! Congratulations.

Andrew Rowlands · Feb 28, 2011

Nice find and good detective work, congrats Sue

Regards,

Andy.

SueO · Feb 28, 2011

Chris Benesh said:
Hi Sue,

Thanks for the PM. I agree that this is a Variegated Flycatcher. Looks like a first for Panama. Congratulations.

Chris

Thanks Chris, for the congrats and your help.
Sue

SueO · Feb 28, 2011

Lisa W said:
Sue, what a great find! Congratulations.

Thanks, Lisa. It's been a weird day for me. I was really thrilled last night (morning) at 1:00a.m. when I saw the Variegated illustration and realized that was my bird, but by noon today, after being on the net trying to verify, I thought I had to be wrong. Mixed emotions had me going!
Sue

SueO · Feb 28, 2011

Andrew Rowlands said:
Nice find and good detective work, congrats Sue

Regards,

Andy.

Thanks Andy! Glad to see you pop in.
Sue

Variegated Flycatcher in Panama? (1 Viewer)

Well-known member

Attachments

Well-known member

Well-known member

Eduardo Amengual

Well-known member

Attachments

Well-known member

Eduardo Amengual

Well-known member

Wird Batcher

Member

Well-known member

Gallery Moderator

Well-known member

So much work, so little time...so let's go birding

Consulting Biologist

I really need to get out and bird more

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Similar threads

Users who are viewing this thread