• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Emerald Dove Chalcophaps longirostris/indica (1 Viewer)

martin_WA

Active member
Those following the putative Common/Pacific Emerald Dove split might be interested in this paper with some new material documenting the intergrade through the Lesser Sundas:

Johnstone R, Hidayat O, Darnell J, Trainor (2014). The avifauna of Semau Island, Lesser Sundas, Indonesia: ecology, taxonomy and conservation. Western Australian Naturalist 29(3): 162-221
http://www.academia.edu/7521703/Johnstone_R._E._Hidayat_O_._Darnell_J._and_Trainor_C._R._2014_The_avifauna_of_Semau_Island_Lesser_Sundas_Indonesia_taxonomy_conservation_and_ecology._Western_Australian_Naturalist._29_3_162-221

Our material from Semau and Timor consistently differs from birds from north-west Australia, Kimberley and Northern Territory (= longirostris) in being slightly smaller and in having the nape, centre of mantle and upper back tinged with bluish grey (Johnstone 1981). On the nearby island of Roti, however, the birds are very similar to the Kimberley birds having little or no trace of grey. Birds from the more westerly island of Sabu vary considerably, with some having the crown and mantle very distinctly grey, whereas on others these areas have only a weak greyish tinge. The populations from still further west and to the north (Sumba, Alor and Lembata) are more like the nominate form, having the forehead whitish and grey on crown and centre of mantle, but they are still intermediate in a number of characters (Figure 11). There is, therefore a broad intergrade zone between the two Wallacean taxa. Furthermore, contrary to Rasmussen and Anderton (2005) we noted very little difference between the calls of birds from either northern Australia or any population across the Lesser Sundas. A detailed study of the variant, island based, intergrade forms, including their long-term stability etc. is needed in order to clarify their taxonomic status.
The material held in the Western Australian Museum clearly indicates an intergrade zone between the taxa C.i. indica and C.i. longirostris and we would treat the two forms as conspecific.
 
Those following the putative Common/Pacific Emerald Dove split might be interested in this paper with some new material documenting the intergrade through the Lesser Sundas:

Johnstone R, Hidayat O, Darnell J, Trainor (2014). The avifauna of Semau Island, Lesser Sundas, Indonesia: ecology, taxonomy and conservation. Western Australian Naturalist 29(3): 162-221
http://www.academia.edu/7521703/Johnstone_R._E._Hidayat_O_._Darnell_J._and_Trainor_C._R._2014_The_avifauna_of_Semau_Island_Lesser_Sundas_Indonesia_taxonomy_conservation_and_ecology._Western_Australian_Naturalist._29_3_162-221

Doubtless my comparison can be dismissed as not being a true parallel, but Yellowhammer Emberiza citrinella and Pine Bunting E. leucocephalos show a similar cline of intermediates across a similar geographical distance but on a continuous landmass, yet they are treated as full species...
MJB
 
Further to uncertainty about the intergrade zone...

HBW/BirdLife and IOC treat timorensis (incl Timor/Semau) as a ssp of Chalcophaps (indica) longirostris; and minima as a ssp of C (i) indica.

But H&M4 treats timorensis as a member of the indica group; and minima as a member of the longirostris group.
 
Last edited:
Warning! This thread is more than 10 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top