juv Song Thrush or Mistle Thrush | Groningen, aug 2013 (1 Viewer)

[HouseCrow]

This (unfortunately out of focus) young bird is tucked in my archive as juv Mistle Thrush, also admin confirmed at waarneming.nl*. Inaturalist-users don't buy that and at least the main reviewer of thrushes there says it is Song Thrush... I remember having studied it quite closely (at my pc) and deciding that it could well be Mistle (Song is common, Mistle is less common, not rare).
It looks a bit dumpy (contra Mistle), light edges to secondaries seem ok, longish bill fits Mistle, pale face also seems to favor Mistle...
On the other hand: the fact that it stood there not too far off, not very wary, is almost proof it is Song Thrush...

Zanglijster - Turdus philomelos 2013-08-25 | Waarneming.nl

Waarneming.nl - Alle waarnemingen uit de natuur online

old.waarneming.nl

Song Thrush (Turdus philomelos)

Song Thrush from Stadsparkwijk, Groningen, Nederland on August 25, 2013 at 11:40 AM by Gerben ter Haar

www.inaturalist.org

Hope to hear from you,
cheers,
G

 

[Butty]

Song thrush.

• It's brown.
• No white on tail-tip.

 

[Ratal]

Your bird is a Juv Song Thrush - as Juv Mistle Thrush are heavily, heavily marked.

 

[HouseCrow]

Thanks Butty and Ratal, I was leaning left and right over time. I will put it to rest now.. Would the shape not be more elongated too (even though the bird might be puffed up a bit)

cheers,
G

 

[Butty]

You can't make a worthwhile judgement of the shape from this angle.

 

[HouseCrow]

ok, probably not
cheers
G