I have seen birds that looked "pleasantly plump", but these were usually simply birds that had their feathers ruffled either because of weather or they were trying to make themselves appear larger than they actually were IMHO. I wonder if this is not what Robert was seeing? When I see hummingbirds with fat visible through the skin, that requires blowing the feathers on the breast out of the way. I am sure that is when Curtis is seeing the "rolls of fat" on the birds as well. I think, if I am not mistaken, that Mr Rubythroat caught a HUGE Black-chinned in Christoval TX this past summer. This guy weighed in at nearly twice normal weight and he LOOKED big. This is very unusual though (they banded more than 500 birds that weekend and how many have they banded through the years and that is the ONLY one that sticks in my mind!)
Mark
Bastrop, TX