BirdForum (
-   Information Wanted (
-   -   Black-backed Gulls Puzzle for an Aussie (

Seashore Thursday 30th July 2020 07:38

Black-backed Gulls Puzzle for an Aussie
To continue the theme of black-backed gulls I have moved on from the down under species to those I have seen in the UK and other places north of the equator. The problem is I seem to be at a loss in identifying them. I've included some photos I took a Dungeness several years ago and would appreciate help identifying what species they are.

Thanks in advance....

opisska Thursday 30th July 2020 10:23

I think this would have more success in the Bird ID subforum - which is dedicated exactly to such questions.

I think that on the first question, the focused adult and the immature in front if it are both Greater BBG while the second photo of adult could be Lesser BBG (definitely not a Herring), just based on bill sizes - but I am insecure about big gulls and always like to see all parts of the bird. UK people will be much better at this.

THE_FERN Thursday 30th July 2020 10:35

Suspect you'd do better posting this to the ID q&a forum. I'm not brilliant at gulls, partly because I'm not a believer in some of the taxa, but in your first pic you've a couple of adult great black-backed gulls (real hefty bills if not up to Pacific standards, very dark backs, broad white tertial "step"), the front bird is an immature of the same species (quite white-looking face, hefty bill). In the background is what I think is a herring gull (pale grey mantle, "mirror" pattern. Appears dainty so probably a female). The other brown bird we can see is either a juvenile herring or lesser black backed gull. I think the latter based on cool plumage tones, all-dark bill and what I can see of the feathering. Apart from those, there's one in the background which is obscured and out of focus. Wouldn't want to id that...

Later on the page you have adult great black-backed gull and I think the immature-something-or-other's the same.

James Lowther Thursday 30th July 2020 11:48

can't help with the gulls beyond what's been said already but your "wader" a few blog posts down is some sort of passerine, i guess a Horsfield's Bushlark
also you have australian reed warblers further down

Seashore Friday 31st July 2020 01:02

Hi, thanks for the reply's. I haven't used Birdforum for a while so yes I realised later the Q&A forum would have been best just after posting it LOL... the wader is definitely a passerine and yes it is a Horsfield's Bushlark, the wrong photo went in, LOL... but people saw through my mistake and identified it anyway.

All times are GMT. The time now is 23:41.

Powered by vBulletin®, copyright ©2000 - 2020 vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
BirdForum Ltd 2002 - 2018