I probably didn't say enough good things about this lens in pros. I absolutely love this lens, and would recommend it to everyone.
As I said in the cons, the focus motor seems to have gotten louder after 7 months of use. I don't find it to be annoying, as it is still very quiet. It's something to consider though.
I have taken about 20,000 shots with it thus far, and haven't really found a problem with it. You can't set a minimum focus for BIF images, but again, that's not a huge problem.
If you check out my flickr, most of the shots on it recently were taken with that lens on the Nikon D5100. I have gotten tons of fantastic shots with it, and even got over 6,000 views on one of them.