• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Search results

  1. S

    Sparrow Audio for ID - Illinois, USA - Nov 2023

    Yes, with location, and neither Merlin nor Birdnet suggested Song Sparrow. Weird.
  2. S

    Merlin? Tehran. IR

    +1 for Merlin. Wrong face pattern for Kestrel.
  3. S

    Sparrow Audio for ID - Illinois, USA - Nov 2023

    Need ID help on this sparrow call. Bird net is suggesting Golden-crowned Sparrow, which would be rare but not completely absurd here. Any thoughts please? ML612606580 - new world sparrow sp. - Macaulay Library
  4. S

    Shrike for ID - West Bengal, India - Oct 2022

    Thanks Grahame. The Brown Shrikes I see in West Bengal are usually less rich in colour.
  5. S

    Shrike for ID - West Bengal, India - Oct 2022

    Wondering if this Brown Shrike could be the Japanese ssp (Lanius cristatus superciliosus)?
  6. S

    Phylloscopus Call for ID - Eastern Himalayas, India

    Nope, does not sound/look like that either.
  7. S

    Phylloscopus Call for ID - Eastern Himalayas, India

    Please review this call on eBird and suggest if this is a Two-barred Warbler or some subspecies of Greenish Warbler. I did not see this bird at all but its call is not matching with the P. trochiloides calls that I am familiar with in Eastern India. https://macaulaylibrary.org/asset/578385741
  8. S

    Reed Warbler - Kolkata, India

    I got these images reviewed by Lars Svensson. He opined this is "most probably" a Large-billed Reed Warbler.
  9. S

    Chang May Thailand 01.02.2023

    #3: Yellow-bellied Warbler Rest are good.
  10. S

    Krabi Thailand 05,02,23 Raptors

    #1: Oriental/Crested Honey Buzzard. Pigeon-ish head and underwings patterns are distinct. #2: Crested Serpent Eagle. Large yellow lore and underwing patterns are distinct.
  11. S

    Hume's Leaf Warbler or Yellow-browed Warbler? 29/4/21, Eocheongdo - South Korea

    Agreed on Hume's. Yellow-browed will be a much brighter bird with prominent double wingbars.
  12. S

    Prinias - Nalsarovar, Gujarat, India

    1 and 2 are Plain Prinias. 3 and 4 are Delicate Prinias.
  13. S

    Id Request - Gulls, Akshi Beach, Maharashtra, India - 2

    The immatures are barabensis based on moult stage, time of the year and likelihood at Indian coasts.
  14. S

    Id Request - Gulls, Akshi Beach, Maharashtra, India - 2

    A cach would be extremely rare for the region. We probably need a wing view to confirm that.
  15. S

    ID help for a locustella warbler - India

    Re-opening this old thread upon the recent discovery of West Himalayan Bush Warbler from the state of West Bengal. A recent study of song analysis of multiple assumed Spotted Bush Warblers were found to be actually West Himalayan, and they seem to be not uncommon wintering migrants in this...
  16. S

    Locustella for ID - West Bengal, India, March 2023

    We are debating whether this is a Spotted or a Baikal Bush Warbler. The bird emerged from dry grass upon Spotted and Baikal's call playback from Merlin. The song audible in the video is a Baikal call playback from Merlin.
  17. S

    Reed Warbler - Kolkata, India

    True, but the size comparison was done against the leaves of the acacia. This bird gave out a chk-chk call similar to Blyth's. Clamorous gives a hard chuck call and it has a more prominent, longer supercilium, often with a peaked crown. This bill looks weaker for a Clamorous to me. Field...
  18. S

    Reed Warbler - Kolkata, India

    About the same size as Blyth's. The streaking is unusual but it did not remind me of an Oriental (which I have seen only once). Its call was similar to Blyth's and undertail covert looked large (visible in photo). The odd bill caught my eye. It looked heavy for a Blyth's RW.
  19. S

    Reed Warbler - Kolkata, India

    It was smaller than a Clamorous. Call was like a Blyth's and a large undertail covert is visible.
  20. S

    Reed Warbler - Kolkata, India

    @Grahame Walbridge @andyb39 - may I ask?
  21. S

    Reed Warbler - Kolkata, India

    I know it is a tough ask, but is there any possibility that this could be a Large-billed Reed Warbler, and not a Blyth's? It was foraging rather openly at mid-level on an Acacia (usually, the wintering Blyth's here keep themselves within bushes and undergrowths) and the bill looked larger than...
  22. S

    Harrier for ID - West Bengal, India

    How to eliminate an immature Eurasian MH?
  23. S

    Harrier for ID - West Bengal, India

    Need an ID on this raptor. It is either an Eurasian or an Eastern Marsh Harrier, but I am unable to deduce beyond that. Clicked in Jan 2023 at a marshland near the Himalayan foothills.
  24. S

    Raptor ID pls at Kagoshimi, Japan.

    A buteo. Underpart colours, white necklace and distribution suggest Eastern Buzzard.
  25. S

    Snipe for ID - Southern West Bengal, Eastern India, Dec 2022

    Bird #1: North 24 Parganas district, West Bengal, India, 30/12/2022 More photos: https://ebird.org/india/checklist/S124872472 Bird #2: Hooghly district, West Bengal, India, 26/12/2022 More photos: https://ebird.org/checklist/S124609334 All records from semi-dry grassland habitats. Bird #1 has...