Join for FREE
It only takes a minute!
||Thread Tools||Rate Thread|
|Tuesday 19th February 2019, 16:16||#1|
Join Date: Jan 2009
An odd 1w Common Gull
Whilst grilling the Gullage near Skegness on Friday I bumped into this small and dusky 1w and honestly convinced myself i was looking at a brachyrhynchus(!)
After sleeping on it i have since lost a bit of faith and think that a dark canus could actually look like this but there are a couple of things that would still seem a bit odd for that..... firstly the size of the thing - It was only present about 2 minutes so i couldn't snap it alongside any other Common Gulls but you can compare it in size to the BHG in the first shot to get an impression - it was about the same size as a BHG and looked tiny next to Herring Gulls, It wasn't only the small size that was eye-catching either, even on a 'normal' sized CG the dark markings on the head and underparts were striking.... far darker than any other 1w canus present.... the last shot i fluked as the bird flew off (never to be seen again) shows a very dark/messy underwing with a dirty grey ground colour which is obviously darker than the uppertail covs, this is quite different to the pale/whitish looking underwing usually seen on canus? also the brown stretches right down past the legs/lower belly which i also think is unusual in canus? and the final thing that niggles is that even on dark and well streaked 1w canus they usually show an unmarked whitish throat/chin area.....
The upper and undertail coverts are certainly streaked but enough for brachyrhynchus? there are certainly some birds on GRO and other sites from America which show a similar amount of streaking but it's not too difficult to find dark end canus with similar either.... and i can't really see enough of the tail to comment.
I also think the finely fringed upper tertials are also a better fit for brachyrhynchus and i won't even go into that oddly small head and bill...
Throughout the rest of the session i payed particular attention to other 1w birds present and struggled to find any with obvious streaking to under-tail coverts or even with any underpart streaking below the upper breast sides, the underwings in flight also appeared much whiter than the subject bird too, often appearing similar to a 1w Casp.
Comments more than welcome if only to tell me i'm looking too hard!
|Rate This Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Possible Vagrant Ring-billed Gull or Common Gull? Warsaw, Poland.||LaughingDove||Bird Identification Q&A||13||Monday 20th February 2017 21:55|
|Ring Billed Gull or Common Gull?||alex berryman||Bird Identification Q&A||4||Wednesday 23rd February 2011 17:52|
|New Video: MEDITERRANEAN GULL AND COMMON GULL (added by Andy T)||BirdForum TV||BirdForum TV Discussion||0||Monday 24th November 2008 18:45|
|common gull, mew gull or short billed gull||thenorthernmonkey||Bird Identification Q&A||3||Tuesday 8th January 2008 12:08|
|Common Gull ?||albatross02||Bird Identification Q&A||16||Tuesday 13th March 2007 21:49|