Because the observer who came back in reply to my post, has submitted records in the past to BBRC only to withdraw them. Brunnich's Guillemot I think.
However the ones I referred to were those on the Point, which were re-identified by well known Point birders as Arctic Skua's.
Norfolk Birder, your jump from someone confirming a sighting of Pomarine Skua to personal slurs is mystifying.
You will have probably realised that the fact that Pomarine Skua was clearly recorded in N Norfolk on the day of your arrogant 'silly season' comment (unless you are still calling into question what now appears to be at least 8 observers and the supporting photos?) weakens your original comment.
You seem to happily believe the word of 'well known Point birders', no photo evidence or names supplied of course, yet call into question other experienced birders with clearly identifiable photos, who simply pointed out that Pomarine Skua WAS recorded in N Norfolk despite the strong inference from your comment that this was highly unlikely.
Rather than just accept this, you continued to back yourself into a corner with the frankly childish argument of 'you can't tell it's Titchwell'. You say 'I didn't say I don't believe you' but that's the only conclusion that can be drawn and was likely your exact intention.
Your argument then becomes personal, completely out of context with the discussion. You also use the words 'records' and 'them' in your attack, suggesting that there are plural claims then withdrawals. Is this the case or merely a result of your poor grammar? (The plural of skua is skuas by the way, not skua's).
I have had the pleasure of birding in the company of Stuart White over three decades, in many countries, and can assure people that he is highly skilled in his art, highly credible, reliable and reflective. He has found many scarce and rare species, subsequently enjoyed by many others. The fact that he withdrew a record, for me, only adds to his integrity, as there are plenty out there that would do otherwise to try to save face.
So, Norfolk birder, rather than try to tarnish other peoples reputations, why not come out from your cowardly cloak of anonymity and tell us who you are so that we can judge yours?..........No, thought not.