• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Better quality with Opt. or Dig. zoom? (1 Viewer)

samdennis1675

New member
I just got a Kodak z915 camera with 10X optical zoom and 5X Digital zoom. Obviously for wildlife I want the closest view. My question is is it better to use the 10X optical zoom and crop the photo, or will final quality probably be better using the digital zoom? Is there a rule of thumb for that? I have lots of experience with film (35mm) cameras, but this is my first digital camera. Thanks.
 
I found with my Fuji s5600 I got better image quality cropping the optical zoom shot rather than using the digital zoom.
So I would say don't digi-zoom just crop.
 
Optical zoom is real magnification, achieved with glass (the lens) that does project a larger image onto the sensor. Optical zoom is good.

Speaking in general terms, without reference to any camera in particular, digital zoom is a faked magnification, with the camera doing a crop internally and then (possibly) buggering up your file to try to invent enough pixels to give you a file as large (in total pixels) as one without the digital zoom. At its best, digital zoom will probably accomplish nothing that you cannot do for yourself in editing software. At its worst it will do things to your file that you would really wish it hadn't. Almost certainly you should avoid digital zoom like the plague.
 
I agree with the others, that a crop done afterwards will be better. As a rule, save a copy of the edited image: if you later get better at processing images, you can go back and improve the edited version if the original still exists.

Niels
 
I agree with the others, I've never actually seen the point of digital zoom, anyone any ideas? maybe just a marketing ploy, personally I think its fairly useless!
 
There are two types of digital zoom.

The first, often called smart zoom, uses a smaller part of the sensor to make an image of smaller pixel dimensions but with more of the subject in. Often you first have to pick a smaller image size to access it. This is exactly the same as taking a larger image and cropping it on the computer which is fine if you have a computer, I know folk with digital cameras that just take the card into Boots and get printouts. One advantage of doing it on camera rather than in computer is that the image will be focused and exposed for the zoomed in area rather than the total zoomed out area.

The second sort of digital zoom is where the centre of the sensor is used but the image is increased in size back up to the original pixel dimensions. This increase is done by interpolating, guessing!, the extra pixels. It works OK for a few % but after that it looks awful. It is mainly used in video cameras, where the final pixel dimensions are fixed, but can be seen in phone cameras and some cheaper digital cameras.

I can see the point of the first type if you don't like playing about with your pictures on a computer. The second type is hard to justify but for a lot of folk the content is all that matters, they would rather have a bigger but worse image of whatever than a smaller but better one.

If you don't like it you can turn it off.
 
There are two types of digital zoom.

The first, often called smart zoom, uses a smaller part of the sensor to make an image of smaller pixel dimensions but with more of the subject in. Often you first have to pick a smaller image size to access it. This is exactly the same as taking a larger image and cropping it on the computer which is fine if you have a computer, I know folk with digital cameras that just take the card into Boots and get printouts. One advantage of doing it on camera rather than in computer is that the image will be focused and exposed for the zoomed in area rather than the total zoomed out area.

The second sort of digital zoom is where the centre of the sensor is used but the image is increased in size back up to the original pixel dimensions. This increase is done by interpolating, guessing!, the extra pixels. It works OK for a few % but after that it looks awful. It is mainly used in video cameras, where the final pixel dimensions are fixed, but can be seen in phone cameras and some cheaper digital cameras.

I can see the point of the first type if you don't like playing about with your pictures on a computer. The second type is hard to justify but for a lot of folk the content is all that matters, they would rather have a bigger but worse image of whatever than a smaller but better one.

If you don't like it you can turn it off.

I have only seen the first type in Panasonic, but agree that it can be usefull to some extent. For the second type, only useful for someone without a computer to do the work afterwards.

Niels
 
Warning! This thread is more than 14 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top