• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Hirundo swallows (1 Viewer)

Barn Swallow

The descriptions of the groups identified within the Asian-American clade of H rustica are a little confusing...

The abstract gives:
  1. an E Asian ssp
  2. SE Asian, American & NW Asian sspp
But the paper itself gives:
  1. "SE Asian" gutturalis (but includes NE Asian saturata/mandschurica)
  2. American erythrogaster & NW Asian tytleri
Richard
 
Last edited:
So Richard,
how well separated are European/middle east birds from US/Asian birds (of H. rustica)?

thanks
Niels
 
how well separated are European/middle east birds from US/Asian birds (of H. rustica)?
"An early divergence between the Asian-American and the European-Mediterranean subspecies was highly supported. The intraspecific haplotype network suggests a minimum of 24 nucleotide changes between those clades (H. r. savignii to H. r. erythrogaster). ...
This division of the Barn Swallow into two major groups is further supported by a conspicuous plumage trait, the extent of the dark breast band; this band is broad and complete in all subspecies within the Europe-Middle East clade, and it is narrow and sometimes incomplete in the subspecies within the Asia-America clade."

Richard
 
Thanks for this Richard, and for letting me read the paper. I wonder if the authors chickened out or if reviewers forced them to delete some discussion, because there is an interesting nugget in there:
Distance (in uncorrected mitochondrial nucleotide difference):
White-tailed Swallow/Pearl-breasted Swallow 0.7%
Amerasian clade/Euro-Middle East clade 1.3-1.5%
Other species pairs 2-11%.
If their implied conclusion that the two Barn Swallow clades are not yet species is correct ("Therefore, the morphologically differentiated H. rustica subspecies may represent a radiation in the early stages of differentiation and potential later speciation", based on "Genetic distances among mtDNA sequences of H. rustica taxa were very low"), then I am missing a discussion of why the first pair are good species. I do not disagree that nucleotide differences does not tell it all, but would have liked a deeper discussion of these results.

Niels
 
Migration syndromes

Teplitsky, Mouawad, Balbontin, de Lope & Møller 2011. Quantitative genetics of migration syndromes: a study of two barn swallow populations. J Evol Biol: in press. abstract
 
Hirundo rustica rustica and H. r. transitiva

Dor R., Safran R.J., Vortman Y., Lotem A., McGowan A., Evans M.R., and Lovette I.J. 2011. Population Genetics and Morphological Comparisons of Migratory European (Hirundo rustica rustica) and Sedentary East-Mediterranean (Hirundo rustica transitiva) Barn Swallows. Journal of Heredity doi:10.1093/jhered/esr114
abstract
 
Barn Swallow

Dor, Lovette, Safran, Billerman, Huber, Vortman, Lotem, McGowan, Evans, Cooper & Winkler 2011. Low variation in the polymorphic Clock gene poly-Q region despite population genetic structure across Barn Swallow (Hirundo rustica) populations. PLoS ONE 6(12): e28843. [pdf]
 
Barn Swallow in Argentina

Garcia-Perez, Hobson, Powell, Still & Huber 2013. Switching hemispheres: a new migration strategy for the disjunct Argentinean breeding population of Barn Swallow (Hirundo rustica). PLOS ONE 8(1): e55654. [article] [pdf].
 
Last edited:
Garcia-Perez, Hobson, Powell, Still & Huber 2013. Switching hemispheres: a new migration strategy for the disjunct Argentinean breeding population of Barn Swallow (Hirundo rustica). PLOS ONE 8(1): e55654. [article] [pdf].

They cite Les Underhill et al 2002 re Leach's Petrel in Southern Africa, but am I mistaken (mis-remembering?) in thinking that Barn Swallow has also been recorded as being an austral breeder there? Les would know!
MJB
 
Barn Swallow

Guerrini, Gennai, Panayides, Crabtree, Zuberogoitia, Copland, Babushkina, Politi, Giunchi & Barbanera 2014. Large-scale patterns of genetic variation in a female-biased dispersing passerine: the importance of sex-based analyses. PLoS ONE 9(6): e98574. [article] [pdf]
 
Barn Swallow

Dor, Safran, Sheldon, Winkler & Lovette 2010. Phylogeny of the genus Hirundo and the Barn Swallow subspecies complex. Mol Phyl Evol: in press.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=400f14f8050d95e1a76976ec498f2f30
Dor et al 2010. Mol Phylogenet Evol 56(1): 409–418. [pdf]

Scordato & Safran (in press). Geographic variation in sexual selection and implications for speciation in the Barn Swallow. Avian Res 5(9). [abstract] [pdf]

Turner 2004 (HBW 9).
 
Hirundo rustica tytleri & gutturalis

Назаренко А.А., Павленко М.В., Крюков А.П. 2016. Интрогрессия генов популяции Hirundo rustica tytleri в популяцию H. r. gutturalis на юго-западе Уссурийского края (на примере Владивостока): отголоски былых и текущих историкобиогеографических событий. Русск. орнитол. журн. 25(1249):523-536.
Nazarenko A.A., Pavlenko M.V., Kryukov A.P. 2016. Introgression of the genes of the Hirundo rustica tytleri population in the H. r. gutturalis population in the south-west of the Ussuri region (upon the example of Vladivostok): echoes of past and current historical-biogeographical events. Russk. ornitol. zhurn. 25(1249):523-536.
[pdf]
 
Wilkins M.R., Scordato E.S.C., Semenov G.A., Karaardiç, Shizuka D., Rubtsov A., Pap P.L., Shen S.-F. & Safran R.J., in press. Global song divergence in Barn Swallows (Hirundo rustica): exploring the roles of genetic, geographical and climatic distance in sympatry and allopatry. Biol. J. Linn. Soc.

Abstract - Divergence in acoustic signals plays an important role in the production and maintenance of biodiversity in numerous taxa. In this study, we assess patterns of acoustic divergence in geographically isolated and sympatric subspecies of barn swallows (Hirundo rustica), including analyses of whether song differentiation varies with geographical isolation, genetic distance and climatic distance. We provide the first description of geographical variation in song among five of six currently recognized barn swallow subspecies. Temporal traits describing terminal trills were the most distinct song traits among subspecies, adding to growing evidence that trills are important in speciation among many birds, insects and fish. Across a ~6000 km transect of Russia, acoustic distance was predicted by genetic and geographical distance, but not climatic distance. We also found no reproductive character displacement of song traits in a contact zone between H. r. rustica and H. r. tytleri. Based on patterns discovered in this study, we infer an important role of sexual selection, genetic and/or cultural drift in the gradual build-up of acoustic divergence, which is accelerated in small populations.
 
Smith CCR, Flaxman SM, Scordato ESC, Kane NC, Hund AK, Sheta BM, Safran RJ. [in press.] Demographic inference in barn swallows using whole genome data shows signal for bottleneck and subspecies differentiation during the Holocene. Mol. Ecol.
[abstract & supp. info.]

Abstract
Accounting for historical demographic features is vital for many types of evolutionary inferences, including the estimation of divergence times between closely related populations. In barn swallow, Hirundo rustica, inferring historical population sizes and subspecies divergence times can shed light on the recent co‐evolution of this species with humans. PSMC uncovered population growth beginning on the order of one million years ago – which may reflect the radiation of the broader Hirundo genus – and a more recent population decline. Additionally, we used approximate Bayesian computation to evaluate hypotheses about recent‐timescale barn swallow demography, including population growth due to human commensalism, and a potential founder event associated with the onset of nesting on human structures. We found signal for a bottleneck event approximately 7,700 ya, near the time that humans began building substantial structures, although there was considerable uncertainty associated with this estimate. Subspecies differentiation and subsequent growth occurred after the bottleneck in the best supported model, an order of magnitude more recently than previous estimates in this system. We also compared results obtained from whole genome sequencing versus reduced representation sequencing, finding many similar results despite substantial allelic dropout in the reduced representation data, which may have affected estimates of some parameters. This study presents the first genetic evidence of a potential barn swallow founder effect and subspecies divergence coinciding with the Holocene, which is an important step in analyzing the biogeographic history of a well‐known human commensal species.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 6 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top