Suggests that it might be reasonable to recognise Ural Black-throated Accentor Prunella (a) atrogularis and Turkestan Black-throated Accentor P (a) huttoni as distinct species.
Thankfully I've seen huttoni on its breeding grounds in Kazakhstan, but I doubt that I'll ever make it to the Urals for atrogularis! Perhaps they're reliably diagnosable on the wintering grounds (eg, presence/absence of white gorget), but I suppose there's been little incentive to study wintering birds particularly closely...Thanks Richard although a bit gruesome for those who have only seen BTA on the wintering grounds? :-C
David Callahan, Birdwatch Listcheck, 26 Feb 2014: Regional accentors.Drovetski, S. V., Semenov, G., Drovetskaya, S. S., Fadeev, I. V., Red'kin, Y. A. and Voelker, G. (2013), Geographic mode of speciation in a mountain specialist Avian family endemic to the Palearctic. Ecology and Evolution. doi: 10.1002/ece3.539
Abstract and PDF (Open) here
Xiaonan Sun, Zhonglou Sun, Dingzhen Liu & Wenliang Zhou. Phylogenetic studies of Prunella strophiata (Passeridae: Prunella) based on complete mitochondrial DNA sequences. Mitochondrial DNA Part B: Resources, Volume 1, Issue 1 (pp 450-451), 2016.
[pdf]
Explosive radiation and spatial expansion across the cold environments of the Old World in an avian family
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ece3.3136/abstract
Explosive radiation and spatial expansion across the cold environments of the Old World in an avian family
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ece3.3136/abstract
P. m. hebridiumMeinertzhagen, R, 1934Ireland and the Hebrides (w of Scotland)
P. m. occidentalis(Hartert, 1910)Scotland (except the Hebrides), England and w France
P. m. modularis(Linnaeus, 1758)n and c Europe
P. m. mabbottiHarper, 1919Iberian Pen., sc France and Italy
P. m. meinertzhageniHarrison, JM & Pateff, 1937the Balkans
P. m. fuscataMauersberger, 1971s Crimean Pen. (n coast of the Black Sea)
P. m. euxinaWatson, 1961nw and n Turkey
P. m. obscura(Hablizl, 1783)ne Turkey, the Caucasus and n Iran
I had the same kind of comment on my Facebook group 🤣🤣Another example of finding the most minimal unrelated differences to achieve two new birds to tick that you have already seen...
It needs to be read in conjunction with the earlier paper in post 15 - the genetic difference between "Caucasian Dunnock" and nominate modularis is similar to the difference between raddes and black-throated (and way more than the difference between brown and Kozlov's). Haven't been to the Caucasus (so no field experience) but the song and plumage differences are well described in the paper (and the plumage difference was covered in BWP).Another example of finding the most minimal unrelated differences to achieve two new birds to tick that you have already seen...