Steve Gantlett
Norfolk Birder
Well, I know and have spoken to the two birders who saw it on Saturday morning. They are extremely experienced, knowledgable and not at all trigger happy. I know that several birders who weren't even there have rubbished the record. That doesn't exactly encourage two people who were actually out in the field to call their finds in in future.
I think they must have made a genuine mistake. I was in the field in the area both before and after all three reports and saw a single Greenshank on all three occasions. We all make mistakes, of course. And, who knows, I may have just made another, but on this occasion I doubt it As for possibles and probables, I would encourage everyone to phone them in as such without delay. No shame in making a mistake and much better that than to miss a good bird.