• BirdForum is the net's largest birding community dedicated to wild birds and birding, and is absolutely FREE!

    Register for an account to take part in lively discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.

Another Licence to Control Buzzards (1 Viewer)

John S. Armitage

Well-known member
I'm more than worried by this as a precedent. Natural England it appears no longer occupies the position of strength it did formerly as the Govt''s adviser on wildlife matters, but simply has to toe the line to the self serving, unsympathetic policies the Tories take when it comes to matters affecting our natural heritage. I've put out a Blog on this on my own site
(http://www.birdingodyssey.blogspot.com/ ) but see also the Blog which Martin Harper (RSPB) has put out on the same subject.
 

string boozel

Well-known member
So yet another victory for the recreational killing fraternity in their quest to rid the countryside of pesky raptors. The subject of Buzzard control is becoming an annual issue much like the unofficial harrier cull and is no less acceptable. I'm not sure why they are going to the trouble of issuing licenses though as even those who break the law don't appear to suffer unduly. How long before the pigeon racers get their Peregrine control licenses? Probably when somebody in government takes up the hobby. I'm going to register my disgust at the decision as always and hope others are going to do the same, I just wish we didn't have to do it on such a regular basis.

James.
 

Simon Wates

Well-known member
Still thinking about this :C

Wait for those folk that want to shoot raptors to take the attitude that if they did, they would only be breaking the law in respect to not having a license. "You see - it sometimes legal now". :C:C:C:C:C
 

JoanT

Well-known member
Still thinking about this :C

Wait for those folk that want to shoot raptors to take the attitude that if they did, they would only be breaking the law in respect to not having a license. "You see - it sometimes legal now". :C:C:C:C:C

There is now a petition on the uk gov petition site which could be signed was around 4500 odd when I signed
 
I mean I hate the thought of having to kill something, but if the number of raptors out numbers the amount of food then the food will all be eaten plus most of the raptors will die with out a food source, so what they should do is like what they do in the U.S for deer is make a season for killing. Only have a certain number of licenses, and each person with a license can only kill a number of raptors to protect the ecosystem that each of the birds live in.
 

string boozel

Well-known member
Thanks for highlighting the petition Joan, I've just signed it.

Hi Allthetimebirder, one of the main problems with this control issue is that Buzzards are a native, protected species which are only just regaining their former population levels after centuries of human induced decline. To sacrifice their recovery merely to benefit a small group of individuals seems wrong. As for who a would actually conduct the cull would they have to have a witness present to ensure that only ten birds are destroyed? Would they have to prove a good knowledge of raptor I.D so that only Common Buzzards are controlled. I certainly wouldn't want any Goshawks or Honey Buzzards killed by accident. Would the gamekeeper do the dirty deed themselves or would a third party be involved?

I can only voice my opinion and that is that no native species should ever be sacrificed to protect a non native alien species and certainly not one that only serves as a living target. Natural England is supposed to protect the nature of England (there's a clue in the name) and should not be appeasing an industry for whom the law is something to be ignored as and when it suits them.

James.
 

kb57

Well-known member
Europe
I mean I hate the thought of having to kill something, but if the number of raptors out numbers the amount of food then the food will all be eaten plus most of the raptors will die with out a food source, so what they should do is like what they do in the U.S for deer is make a season for killing. Only have a certain number of licenses, and each person with a license can only kill a number of raptors to protect the ecosystem that each of the birds live in.
Before you get jumped on by a lot of other birders (this is a VERY emotive issue in UK, and with good reason...) I'll start by saying you are right that in some circumstances predators will be limited by food supply...what ecologists call 'donor control'...an example would be snowy owls and lemmings, where predator populations follow cycles in prey populations. But except in very simple ecosystems, it is very rare for a predator to deplete a prey species to such an extent that both die out...for one thing, predators generally switch to a more abundant food source which takes less energy to forage for. So killing predators is hardly ever necessary to protect ecosystems, and usually has sometimes unforeseen negative consequences. In the specific case of raptors in England, their populations have not historically been limited by food supply, but by the depredations of tweed (plaid)-clad landowners and their lackeys, who consider themselves not only to be above the law, but also to know more about ecology than scientists, because they've lived in the countryside for generations, and really know best. In the case of common buzzards they introduce so many hand-reared pheasants into the countryside every year with few innate predator avoidance responses, that some buzzards allegedly find it more energy efficient to prey-switch from roadkill rabbits (and roadkill pheasants, of which there are many) to preying on live pheasants. Our ecosystems will not collapse because of this, buzzards will not die for lack of food, but the landowners feel that people who give them a lot of money to come and shoot the pheasants may not be able to shoot quite so many.
 

Nutcracker

Stop Brexit!

Nice idea, but by the time the petition gets noticed, it'll be far too late.

What's needed is an urgent court injunction to prevent the killing going ahead, and a judicial review of the case, with investigation of the judge who OK'd the killing - does he have any interests in shooting, perhaps? Is he a good friend of the owner of the land for which the license has been applied?

Unfortunately I don't have the faintest clue how to set about this . . .
 

Jos Stratford

Beast from the East
I can only voice my opinion and that is that no native species should ever be sacrificed to protect a non native alien species.

I agree with all the sentiments regarding the unacceptable proposal to cull Buzzards, but one very minor point regarding this above sentence - is it not already fairly widespread to cull native species to protect aliens? Are quite a number of crop species originally non-natives and stocked fish too? If so, all species controlled under the guise of crop protection, be insects being sprayed or crows, etc, would be natives being culled.

As said, even if valid, this is a minor point, and not intended to justify in any way the culling of Buzzards.
 

JoanT

Well-known member
Nice idea, but by the time the petition gets noticed, it'll be far too late.

What's needed is an urgent court injunction to prevent the killing going ahead, and a judicial review of the case, with investigation of the judge who OK'd the killing - does he have any interests in shooting, perhaps? Is he a good friend of the owner of the land for which the license has been applied?

Unfortunately I don't have the faintest clue how to set about this . . .

Only needs to get to 10000 to get govt response so about 4000 to go shouldn't take long
 

kb57

Well-known member
Europe
Nice idea, but by the time the petition gets noticed, it'll be far too late.
.
Agree, but I've just signed anyway, no. 6,137 this morning so looking like a good chance of getting to 10,000.
The last time this was considered public pressure did force them to reconsider - the problem is I guess this has already been granted.
I've dealt with Natural England and their predecessor organisations a lot over the years, and their expertise has become more and more stifled, the 'best' (most committed, knowledgeable) people have tended to leave, and they've become increasingly toothless,increasingly controlled by landowning / hunting interests, and their budgets / staff numbers slashed.
Of course now we have Andrea Leadsom in charge we can expect to see 'upland farmers paid for helping butterflies, while the ones with big fields grow the cattle and sheep' (approximate quote)...the optimists could read into that a commitment to rewilding the uplands - I'm not so confident!
 

Nutcracker

Stop Brexit!
Only needs to get to 10000 to get govt response so about 4000 to go shouldn't take long

It'll take a week or two, and then another 2-3 weeks of Govt. procrastination to issue a spineless response. By then, the Buzzards will have been shot - if they haven't already been shot last week, within a day or two of the licence being signed :-C
 
Last edited:

Andy Adcock

Well-known member
England
What's the RSPB stance, a block vote should raise a million!

It's a matter of awareness, needs to appear in mainstream publications, perhaps a higher profile message somewhere on Birdforum with a direct appeal for votes?

Nutty 'licence'......:t:



Andy
 
Last edited:

string boozel

Well-known member
Hi Jos,

You are making a valid point, it's just that I feel whereas food crops or domestic livestock are providing an essential resource pheasants are providing a nice target for people to have a bit of a bang at. Recreation is all well and good (it's why most of us are on the forum when all's said and done) but I don't like to think that anything should have to die to guarantee a bit of fun.

James.
 

John Cantelo

Well-known member
Natural England claimed that the licence would be "time-limited with stringent conditions" and that "only buzzards in and immediately around the animal pens" would be killed, "not on passing birds". It now transpires that this is to be 'enforced' by asking the applicant to fill in a form (see attached screen grab taken from Twitter of a FoI request by Steve Harris, a former PWCO)! Not exactly hard to work out a potential problem here is it?
 

Attachments

  • Buzzards.jpg
    Buzzards.jpg
    58.2 KB · Views: 42

Sangahyando

Well-known member
Natural England claimed that the licence would be "time-limited with stringent conditions" and that "only buzzards in and immediately around the animal pens" would be killed, "not on passing birds". It now transpires that this is to be 'enforced' by asking the applicant to fill in a form (see attached screen grab taken from Twitter of a FoI request by Steve Harris, a former PWCO)! Not exactly hard to work out a potential problem here is it?
Have they any provided proof yet for their theory that buzzards take live pheasants?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top