Hi there.....i used the XF zoom for a while and although image quality was ok at the low end of magnification,it degraded quite a lot when going up to 60X(that zoom delivered 20x-60x,while other zooms will grant you likely 18-51x or so)..the ER was lame ,as you said,and made very hard to enjoy using it.I then used the Swarovski astronomy style7.7-23.1 zoom,i believe this to be the foundation eyepiece for most zooms .really nice coatings ,amazingly SHARP,all the way and beyond the edges.the image at 7.7(52X)was incredible .the field of view was narrow ,maybe less than 50˚ AFOV,probably 45˚...and it didnt reach infinity at the lower magnification setting either(on the pentax 65),but,its mistique and sharpness made for the problems.Now i use the Vixen zoom. In the very beggining i missed the contrast and sharpness or the swaro,but i discovered that such contrast was at the price of a bit of a yellowish cast.The Vixen has a more neutral feeling,and is a bit brighter.I was looking at Seagulls and felt a somehow more subtil ,detailed COLOUR rendering .image seems as sharp to me now.maybe the feeling of "sharp beyond the edge "is not there,but image is good mostly all the way to the edge.it also helds power pretty well,maybe loosing at its very few mm,while the swaro kept going all the way to 7.7. FOW still being narrow BUT,maybe a few aparent degrees wider,maybe 50,52˚?at 24MM ?..I think i measured the Swaro real field at 1.8˚(dont even remember the equation),sure the vixen is more than 2˚...All in all ,a very good eyepiece...AND IT CAN BE FOUND AT 129$ NEW!!!!! someplaces!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! very good deal....hope this helps...