Roy C
Occasional bird snapper
David,the trouble with a thread like this on these small point and shoot cameras is that most of the contributors tend to fall into two categories. One is the fairly experienced DSLR bird photographer who buys this little Cam as a lightweight alternative to the heavy gear and the other is the novice bird photographer who has had little or no experience with bird photography.I'll post this as an example of a poor picture, but only because I'm being unrealistic about the range where one can get a reasonable picture. Incidentally this is a target, apart from the individual bird, that I've taken at a variety of settings with all my cameras, just to see what they will do ETA it is certainly the best I have taken.
This one is taken at superfine, it will have been subject to photobucket compression, it's got good light, it was not taken with a tripod, but supported by a metal railing, it has not been cropped, and it has had nothing done in any editor. It was at full zoom with the in camera 2x widget.
To the closest 10 feet, as measured on Google Earth, it was 1150 feet from where it was taken, and I think it as good as I can do. Certainly good enough to tell what bird it is, but it's not a difficult one.
I'd say, and I wonder if I will have any dissenting voices, that to do significantly better with this camera is unrealistic.
OTOH, it is, I think, remarkable enough.
http://i419.photobucket.com/albums/pp275/dble_photo/IMG_2252_zps29053fd9.jpg
To put it in perspective, it was taken from the railings near the bandstand in this pic from wiki, and is of the top of the larger rock at the back of the island pictured (not the one a mile and a half away)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:St._Catherine's_Island_-_geograph.org.uk_-_1455808.jpg
David
For the DSLR shooter it is mostly about image quality and getting the best out of the Camera, it is difficult not to judge a shot on its technical merit, be it sharpness, noise, composition or whatever.
The novice point and shoot users themselves tend to fall into two distinct categories as far as I can see, those that genuinely want to improve and are looking for constructive criticism and those that are just interested in getting the shot no matter what the IQ is like.
There is no doubting that a little cam like this is a great asset to a birder who may be after a record shot perhaps for ID purposes, for a birder who normally uses a scope and tripod set-up it is great to whip out this little cam instead of connecting all the digiscoping kit.
We all have different standards and objectives but at the end of the day the main thing is that if you are happy with a shot then that is all that matters.


