These are all beer drinking arguments, with various rationales that each have some degree of purpose, perhaps even merit!
I think of the phrase "capo di tutti capo", 'Father of all fathers"... Does that apply?
In regards to this topic, perhaps it should be "Splitting hairs of the already splitted hair"...
One opinion on this thread implies that if a binocular 'is' an Alpha, if the same manufacturer makes a different model with some incremental improvements, then the old one is, by default, out of the club. It can only be the best one by that manufacturer. This position promotes the idea that one must be compelled to upgrade every time this happens, otherwise, YOU JUST CANT BE IN THE CLUB... end of story. Otherwise, whatever optics you've got, it just isn't the best. Sorry brother...go big or go home....
Of course, imho, this is complete and utter hooey, but it does jive very well with Alexis Powell's insightful comments in the 'other' alpha thread.
Speaking of fathers, I spent about 5 hours sitting with my father today. He's 99 years old, on hospice, in a care facility in the town I live in. As his 2nd floor room is next to an open field, and there's a row of Maple trees alongside the building, I opened the blinds and pulled open the window to let some light, fresh air, and bird song into the room. While he was sleeping, in between a few, semi-lucid chats I had with him... I listened and watched the birds that came around. I could hear Crows, Scrub Jays, Bewick's Wrens, and Chickadees from time to time.
I know you're all thinking... 'What binocular did you use?' ;-)
Well, I used a Nikon MHG 8x30 that I happen to prefer to the Swarovski CL 8x30, even though it was not as well reviewed on Allbinos. Oops. I studied a few crows that landed in the tree, before gliding across the field to join their noisy compatriots, and went squawking off en masse. Also a female House Finch that stayed awhile amongst the large, browning leaves, which at first glance, I thought might be a Pine Siskin, until I got a clear view of the beak.
I have to say that at no time did I wish I had brought an 'alpha' binocular, and that the view would have been so much better, and worth the extra cost, if I had. It just didn't cross my mind.
-Bill