rokermartin
Well-known member
Went to Hurworth Burn this afternoon and saw a Hobby chasing hirundines also there 4 Green Sands and Greenshank.
Osprey showed well for 30mins at Hurworth Burn this afternoon.It attempted to catch a fish five times but failed to do so it give up in the end and few off north.Certainly my best views of a Osprey i have had in the county.Couple of local birders i was talking to said it has been in the area since Tuesday.Also they were saying that they were'nt happy about the news of the Osprey being put out by a DBC member.
Hi Mark i was chatting to couple of birders when i was at Hurworth Burn and i mentioned that there had been a Osprey seen recently they already knew about it and they asked how i got to know.I told them that JO put the sighting on the DBC sightings page i have to say they were'nt pleased at all with JO putting it on.I said there is no harm by doing so but they said they did'nt want loads of birders there.Also one of the birders mentioned about some Quails not far from Hurworth Burn and he told me not to tell anyone about them.Seems to me that there is still a few birders who like to keep birds quiet.Hi Martin,
Any reason why they weren't happy about news being put out? And any reason to single out a DBC member as being at fault?
I'm not having a dig at you Martin, just wanting to know the facts. There have been several cases in the last 2-3 weeks of birders/photographers (and the public) deliberately disturbing Schedule 1 species which are potentially/definitely breeding in the county. All these instances have been totally out of order (eg constant use of tapes) and the people concerned are actually committing a criminal offence. These recent events will definitely determine what bird news is held on the DBC website in the future or how news is passed on between county birders (ie not at all).
The welfare of the birds always has to come first, but with the case of the Hurworth Burn Osprey, I don't know what potential damage has been caused by people knowing.
Cheers,
Mark
Hi Martin,
There have been several cases in the last 2-3 weeks of birders/photographers (and the public) deliberately disturbing Schedule 1 species which are potentially/definitely breeding in the county. All these instances have been totally out of order (eg constant use of tapes) and the people concerned are actually committing a criminal offence. These recent events will definitely determine what bird news is held on the DBC website in the future or how news is passed on between county birders (ie not at all).
Very disturbing news:eek!:. Also dissapointing that good news will not be reported on the DBC site. Yet again the minority spoil it for the majority ( I do hope that's the right way round).
Without going into the detail that would get you into trouble, can you elaborate on some of these events please for those not on the grape vine.
If these people are known then they should be reported :C.
Recent events include:
Peregrine killings - well publicised and obviously done by those with a grudge against the species. But hard to keep certain nest sites safe and quiet when the species is high profile.
Marsh Warblers on territory recently - several paths trampled through areas where they shouldn't be.
Corncrake - by far the worst. A bird recently on territory was continuously taped lured ("alledgedly") just so that it could be videoed. The bird has now left the area. The RSPB are aware and further action may be taken.
I don't mean that the DBC website will no longer put good bird news out, I just mean that everyone should be much more careful over what news is made public when it concerns rare potentially breeding species. The bird and the potential damage to the site need to be considered and sometimes, it may be necessary to keep quiet. It's obviously up to individual people whether they pass news on, but I wouldn't like to see the DBC website pointing people to birds and there being a resulting negative impact. I just hate to see birds driven off territory by idiots overusing tape play back etc.
Hurworth Burn Res - all the recent habitat management work has been done to make it better for birds and visiting birders. The site already attracts many non-birding walkers/cyclists. A bit of a strange attitude it seems.
Corncrake - by far the worst. A bird recently on territory was continuously taped lured ("alledgedly") just so that it could be videoed. The bird has now left the area. The RSPB are aware and further action may be taken.
Can you tell me if the noisy warbler trying to copy everyone elses calls is a Sedge Warbler or a Chiff chaff or a Whitethroat please?
Good evening new member Wilsonz here. Can you tell me if the noisy warbler trying to copy everyone elses calls is a Sedge Warbler or a Chiff chaff or a Whitethroat please? I also think we saw a Hobby, but I cannot tell.