• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Ebird moved my checklists? (1 Viewer)

Georgebirds

Well-known member
United Kingdom
This is a bit of an odd one, I just noticed that Ebird's moved some of my checklists to a different but nearby location.

Full backstory on this (not interesting, but to explain the situation)

I originally filled in two checklists using an existing hotspot which was a bit vague in title - the village name Gedney, then 'arable fields and shore'. I didn't start out at that village, but walked towards it, and did end up going through the farm-building outskirts before looping back to my start point.

On Friday, I went to the same start point, but walked a slightly different shorter loop, which didn't include reaching the edge of Gedney village. It felt incorrect to then use that hotspot to record my sightings, so I decided to make a new one, dropping the pin much nearer to where I set off from each time. My starting point is a small layby carpark used quite a bit by dog-walkers and birders, the grassy banks all have public access and Public Footpath signs, and when walking you pass a big official sign about The Wash National Nature Reserve. So I thought this all qualified it to be suggested as a hotspot in it's own right, incase anyone else wanted to use it for recording their sightings too, and ticked the 'suggest as hotspot' option.
Then I went back and edited my previous two checklists, to switch them to the new location I'd just created. I called it The Wash NNR -- Guy's Head after the lighthouse beside the carpark and the road name - seemed relevant and informative enough to get approved by whoever checks them.

Today, I happened to notice the little section showing my most recent checklists now included a place I hadn't been to! Wait, what?
I clicked on it, and my checklist from the other day AND the two previous ones, have been re-allocated to a different hotspot. The Wash Viewpoint. Fair enough, in miles as the crow flies, it's not far away at all - but it's the other side of a wide river. It requires driving through a different town and over a big fancy bridge to get to a totally different carpark. I didn't go there, so I don't want my checklists to say I did, that's not being unreasonable at all, is it?

I'm wondering if whoever looked at the hotspot I'd created, looked at the map and thought 'but there's already one about half a mile away' and deleted mine, merging my checklists into a nearby place. The one I created isn't even on the drop-down list of locations to choose from when submitting a checklist now, so it's definitely gone even as a personal one. I'd have preferred if they just left it and turned down the suggestion as a hotspot, to deleting it and moving me somewhere I haven't been, hah!

Has anyone else ever had their checklists moved to a wrong location like this? I think what I'll do is re-create the location where I want it, edit my checklists back there again, and just not suggest it as a hotspot this time round - so it gets to exist to me, even if no-one else is able to use the same one!
 
This would have been done by a local reviewer. Nothing stopping you from moving them back. Annoyingly there's no way to find out who the local reviewer that did that is to contact them and/or lodge a complaint if you feel it's unwarranted.
 
Yeah, moving them back would satisfy me for having them in the right place at least, just a shame cos I was trying to be helpful and get what's a locally fairly popular place onto the map for other users too.

It wouldn't be worth a complaint, just a explanation much like I wrote here to show why I really wanted it to be in the correct place, probably with a map screenshot to clarify why these two locations ought to be separate, they're close geographically but a fifteen-minute drive apart thanks to the river.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top