• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Fuji S-X1? (1 Viewer)

flossiepip

Well-known member
Anyone using this camera. Tempted to go for one as the price seems good at this time, new or s/h!
Had the HS30 for a short time and liked it a lot but had noticeable shutter lag so gave it up. Guess the HS50 would be a logical choice but the larger sensor rather tempting, though one wonders if Fuji can be far away from a HS60!
 
I was just looking into this situation today, and I'm still confused about it. it seems to be a close race between the two. They both have their own merits and drawbacks. Maybe the thing to do is Google "HS50EXR vs X-S1" and see what you can glean from the various information there. It would be nice to hear from someone that has used both cameras.
 
Presumeably you mean the X-S1?

I have a pair, one of the first and one of the last (incorporating the modified sensor).

Certainly when it came out the quality of its images, its handling, viewfinder and general toughness made it my standard winter walkabout camera.

I only ever had HS-10 and an HS20 in the past and they differ greatly from the X-S1 in weight and were more family friendly.

You can look at the images from various reviewers when it came out to get some idea of what the X-S1 can do. It also conveniently used the same batteries as the X100 which was useful to me.

It is big and heavy for a bridge camera, bigger than say an Olympus E-450 slr body, however the comparison is invalid as there is no lens of comparable range of zoom for 4/3 and should such a beast exist it would be significantly bigger, heavier and expensive than the Fuji. It is definitely chunkier than the HS30 you owned.

I havn't had 'globes', lens droop or any of the other ills that some people felt were endemic in this camera. When it first came out I think I contributed to a thread on birdforum where I stated that it was difficult to see the market that Fuji was aiming at - considering its then price. If they had waited and put the X20 sensor in it, it would have been absolutely superb and sold by the bucketload.

For me it fills a useful niche in my armoury, its good (for this type of camera) images, its EXR capabilities etc., make it a unique photographic tool complementing an old Oly C8080 I use.

Unfortunately I don't use it for birds. I am a photographer who takes images of many things including birds and for that the HS50 (and its equivalents from Canon etc) with its longer reach is the walkabout low cost way to go and an slr/csc with a longer lens is the more expensive way to go for quality and performance. I tend to video birds as I like life in my birds - just a personal thing - and use dedicated video cameras.

In fine weather I tend to use an slr or Oly OMD for stills.

So - at its remaindered price it is good value and I think it is a great camera and I am aware that it has a dedicated band of supporters for good reason. However - if I wanted a go anywhere - relatively lightweight superzoom type camera for birding it is too heavy and doesn't have as good a reach as say the HS-50.

My feeling is that it is often a mistake to be lured by price alone. If I were a dedicated bird photographer I would probably buy a modern superzoom. As I am not, I don't currently own a modern superzoom and the XS-1 makes more sense for my type of photography, its a bit horses for courses. On the other hand you may go on and prove me wrong...
 
Last edited:
Warning! This thread is more than 9 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top