From what I've read longevity is believed to be up to 15 years, although that seems to be speculative.
I'm not a big believer in wariness as a novel evolutionary trait. There are reports of wariness in the literature, and overall I'm inclined to think scarcity/low population density and the tendency to fly high for long distances after being flushed (see Tanner, p. 58) are sufficient to account for the difficulty in obtaining a photograph.
At the same time, I think the idea that the IBWO is not a widespread, adaptive, generalist species is based more on mythology than fact. While Pileateds are clearly more widespread, generalist and adaptive, the available evidence about IBWO diet indicates more of a generalist than is commonly believed. And the historic range was from South Florida to Ohio and from the Eastern Seaboard to the Missouri-Kansas border and North-Central Oklahoma (the last from memory, but if I'm correct, it's not in the cypress swamp region of OK, which is in the extreme Southeast corner of the state.) That's a substantial range, from temperate (with very cold winters) to subtropical, that includes quite a variety of habitats, even as between coastal and inland swamps.
I'm not a big believer in wariness as a novel evolutionary trait. There are reports of wariness in the literature, and overall I'm inclined to think scarcity/low population density and the tendency to fly high for long distances after being flushed (see Tanner, p. 58) are sufficient to account for the difficulty in obtaining a photograph.
At the same time, I think the idea that the IBWO is not a widespread, adaptive, generalist species is based more on mythology than fact. While Pileateds are clearly more widespread, generalist and adaptive, the available evidence about IBWO diet indicates more of a generalist than is commonly believed. And the historic range was from South Florida to Ohio and from the Eastern Seaboard to the Missouri-Kansas border and North-Central Oklahoma (the last from memory, but if I'm correct, it's not in the cypress swamp region of OK, which is in the extreme Southeast corner of the state.) That's a substantial range, from temperate (with very cold winters) to subtropical, that includes quite a variety of habitats, even as between coastal and inland swamps.
Ilya Maclean said:I've read through five pages on both forums, and although there are lots of differences of opinion, like Mike, I can't see any examples of intellectual dishonesty.
On wariness, does anyone know the average longevity of an Ivory-billed (or of other Campephilus)? It seems a little unlikely to have evolved to become wary in such a short space of time. I stand to be corrected on this if someone can find a relevant analogous species. Learned behaviour is another matter, but would IBWOs possess the phenotypic plasticity to modify their behaviour in such a way? Touche’s post about woodpigeons is interesting, but in my view not directly comparable. If the behavioural changes are due to evolutionary processes, these are much more likely to manifest themselves in a large population (with greater genetic diversity) with a relatively short life cycle. If it is phenotypic, then species must posses a high degree of phenotypic plasticity. Such plasticity is generally exhibited by widespread generalist species that can adapt readily to changing conditions. What little we know about the Ivory-billed woodpecker suggests that it isn’t really a widespread, adaptive, generalist species.