• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Lynx released in the Highlands (1 Viewer)

Someone got a Lynx Christmas set & regifted them?

All the best

Paul
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20250108_231456_Google~2.jpg
    Screenshot_20250108_231456_Google~2.jpg
    45.5 KB · Views: 16
Last edited:
--------
From the article, analysis by Kevin Keane:

''They are convinced these two animals have been illegally released by someone who has grown tired of that process and taken the law into their own hands.

(...) Farmers hate the idea of wild lynx because of concerns they might target their lambs for food.

If that happens in the coming days, campaigners fear it would end their ambitions of a reintroduction for decades.''

---------

TheBlackGrouse:

Another possibility, lynx-haters have released them. They hope that the lynx will kill livestock and that would end the ambitions of a reintroduction.

It is very unlikely that you capture lynx in the wild and bring them to Scotland unseen. Finding them in Europe is difficult, you have to be an expert with knowledge of the terrain, you have to work with cars and cages in nature reserves.

Probably these lynx are born in captivity and/or raised by humans. Then they are not very good hunters and especially in this time of year they may attack sheep. If the lynx approach humans for food we can imagine what the media will do...

Nature lovers know it's a recipe for disaster.
 
Last edited:
And given that two were 'seen' - how likely would that be if they were 'wild' or already established? ... ;-)

(Assuming not a hoax or mis id)
 
Presumably keeping a Lynx in captivity would require a license but do individual animals need to be registered?

A lot of holdings on Zootierliste with the northern subspecies.


All the best

Paul
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20250109_003543_Chrome~2.jpg
    Screenshot_20250109_003543_Chrome~2.jpg
    199.6 KB · Views: 12
There was a case years ago in which the RSPCA (or Scottish SPCA, I forget) found two Lynx being held in captivity in Scotland for release to be hunted, so lets not be narrow-minded in assessing reasons why this could have happened.

I would be interested to hear our Finnish members' opinions of the seriousness of Lynx being in the Highlands. I am aware that in recent winters they have been seen in even suburban areas of Finland. I suspect a "police warning" is typically uninformed (uniformed? no forget it) British hysteria.

John
 
I would be interested to hear our Finnish members' opinions of the seriousness of Lynx being in the Highlands. I am aware that in recent winters they have been seen in even suburban areas of Finland. I suspect a "police warning" is typically uninformed (uniformed? no forget it) British hysteria.
Their opinions in what regard? Danger to humans?
 
Maybe recapturing is for the best because who knows how well they could have been rewilded if they have been bred in captivity - legally or otherwise. Free 'The Killiehuntly Two' might sound clever and pro-animal, but in the long term may not be in the beasts best interests.
 
Maybe recapturing is for the best because who knows how well they could have been rewilded if they have been bred in captivity - legally or otherwise. Free 'The Killiehuntly Two' might sound clever and pro-animal, but in the long term may not be in the beasts best interests.
Quite likely but I seem to remember there was a sighting in the area some months ago which suggests they were actually doing all right.

John
 
Looking at the pictures these lynx were not wild. It is impossible to get a photo like this of two lynx close together, watching the photographer, during the day.

In fact, there was a photo contest (wildlife) years ago and the winner was a picture of a lynx in the sun on a rock. Well, a few weeks earlier I was in a German Wildgehege (small animal park with local species living in large enclosures) and I made a picture of a lynx on a rock in a field. Exactly the same rock as on the winning photo. It was quite easy to get rid of the fence with a tele at 20 meter. I contacted the organization that the winning photo was a fake, but they didn't care. This has nothing to do with wildlife photography. For me zoo pictures are fun because you have a chance to work with rare animals without disturbing them in nature. Of course, they are in captivity, for me the educational aspect is very important but that's a different discussion.

Wild lynx are almost invisible, if you are persistent you might find some tracks. We have a few lynx in the south-east of the Netherlands, there is a population nearby by in the German Eifel (low mountains, Mittelgebirge).

Sheep attacks are rare, only a few percent of the diet. Lynx are not killing sheep due to shortages of alternative prey or in response to an increased need for food when rearing young.

Only a few individual lynx seem to attack sheep. This is more or less the same as with our wolves and makes it possible to target the culprits. In many cases the individuals don't have to be killed, it is a matter of conditioning. This is Western-Europe, small nature reserves and large predators are extremely rare, we try to 'help' them first.
 
Last edited:
Looking at the pictures these lynx were not wild. It is impossible to get a photo like this of two lynx close together, watching the photographer, during the day.
I've only ever seen a lynx a couple of times, both of them incredibly fleeting. Absolutely yes, any lynx hanging around like that is most certainly not wild.
 
I've only ever seen a lynx a couple of times, both of them incredibly fleeting. Absolutely yes, any lynx hanging around like that is most certainly not wild.
Lynx are becoming relatively common in the Baltic States and there are plenty of instances of very showy individuals being photographed sitting in the open looking at casual photographers, indeed there was one a year back relaxing on a veranda of a ice cream shop or something similar, the animal lying between the (unoccupied) tables. I recall another photo of one in an apple tree in a garden and several of Lynx sauntering along meadow edges etc. Of course, these are the absolute exceptions, by and large Lynx are difficult to find and sightings are rare.

As for risk to people, basically nonexistent - as said, the population in the Baltic States is healthy (especially in Estonia) and fairly rapidly increasing, yet there are no reported attacks on people that I know of, nor are people afraid of venturing into forests. It is a national pastime of folk in all the Baltic countries to wander the forests for berries and mushrooms - almost certainly there will be Lynx in the general area. Folk will neither see nor realise they are in Lynx country, the threat is simply absent.
 
At a personal level, Lynx are now regular in my land - at least two individuals several times since autumn. I worry not about walking in my forests and would love to bump into them more often - have only done so once so far, all other records are on my cameras (or via tracks in the snow).
 
As for killing of sheep, not an issue in the Baltic States because sheep are very rarely kept, so can't really comment, but they certainly do take them in other areas I believe. Here they are taking Roe Deer.
 
Lynx are becoming relatively common in the Baltic States and there are plenty of instances of very showy individuals being photographed sitting in the open looking at casual photographers, indeed there was one a year back relaxing on a veranda of a ice cream shop or something similar, the animal lying between the (unoccupied) tables. I recall another photo of one in an apple tree in a garden and several of Lynx sauntering along meadow edges etc. Of course, these are the absolute exceptions, by and large Lynx are difficult to find and sightings are rare.
You've seen a lot more of them than I have then! They're very hard to spot for the most part in Alaska and it seems they've got a different psychological makeup over there. Post some pics if you've taken any!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top