NY ID help - USA (1 Viewer)

[sea sluggers]

Hello! I'm still learning my birds and would love some ID help with several recent ones I saw in Brooklyn in mid April. Some good pics, others not so much.

Is this one a House Sparrow?

 

[sea sluggers]

And I'm not sure about this one

 

[sea sluggers]

I think these two are the same kind of bird?

 

[sea sluggers]

And I think these two are the same

 

[sea sluggers]

And the last two

 

[sea sluggers]

Thanks in advance for your help.

 

[Butty]

Is this one a House Sparrow?

I think these two are the same kind of bird?

All them are house sparrows.

 

[Butty]

And I'm not sure about this one

Hermit thrush

 

[Butty]

And the last two

Song sparrow with a deformed bill and half a tail, and a yellow-rumped warbler.

 

[Butty]

Song sparrow with...

Or is that a savannah sparrow?! Somebody help me...

 

[nartreb]

Butty, which one are you unsure about? There's one (no, two) with yellow lores and a clean white crest line, but it's not the one with the missing tail feather(s).

 

[Earnest lad]

I think A1 to A4 are all House Sparrows

 

[Butty]

which one are you unsure about?

The one with the missing tail-feathers. Is the underpart-streaking too fine for song sparrow? I don't do American sparrows - as you can tell.

 

[nartreb]

A1 and A2 are male house sparrows.

B is a hermit thrush.

C1 and C2 are female house sparrows.

E1 and E2 are savannah sparrows.

F is a song sparrow, G is a yellow-rumped warbler ("myrtle" type if I recall correctly)

 

[Microtus]

Two male House Sparrows
Hermit Thrush
Two female House Sparrows
Two Savannah Sparrows
Song Sparrow (l), male Yellow-rumped Warbler (r)

 

[Butty]

A1 to A4

Now you have got us confused...

 

[foresttwitcher]

Now you have got us confused...

No, only you - letters/numbers are on the photos & nartrebs is the clearest reply.

 

[Butty]

No, only you - letters/numbers are on the photos & nartrebs is the clearest reply.

You've ignored whose comment I was replying to: there is an A1 and an A2, but not an A3 or an A4. If you read my comment and the one I replied to, it will be clear to you.

 

[Earnest lad]

I confused myself thinking there was an A1 to A4

You've ignored whose comment I was replying to: there is an A1 and an A2, but not an A3 or an A4. If you read my comment and the one I replied to, it will be clear to you.

I confused myself erroneously thinking there was A1-a4