• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

stephani (1 Viewer)

Last edited:

It's a separate work, and not by Reichenbach himself :

Meyer AB. 1879. Index zu L. Reichenbach's ornithologischen Werken. R Friedländer & Sohn, Berlin.
 

No, sorry -- I'm not used to call anything else than Meyer's work an 'index' in the context of Reichenbach.

Reichenbach's publication process is a bit of a nightmare.

The two pages reproduced by Bruce et al. (which they indeed call, 'index pages', so I'll have to live with it, I guess; to my mind, an index is organized alphabetically, which is not the case here) list the contents of a set of pigeon plates that was published in 1851 -- the "Novitiae: Columbariae" in Meyer's Index, where novitiae means 'novelties'. A first set of pigeon plates (Meyer's "Columbariae") and a list of its contents (Meyer's "Synopsis: Columbariae") had been published (fide Meyer) in 1847/48; the novitiae were intended to be interspersed among the plates of the initial set. Significantly later, in 1861/62, Reichenbach published a textbook about pigeons, which appeared in two parts (Meyer's "Vollständige Naturgeschichte der Tauben (erste Hälfte), Text." and "Neuentdeckte Taubenvögel und Nachtrag"; BHL's copy only has the first part, a complete copy can be seen on the Teyler's Museum website), and also an additional 9 plates (which appeared with the second part, and which BHL does not have either).

Several of the groups covered in Reichenbach's publications have had a similar history (an initial set of plates with a "synopsis" listing its contents, a set of plates showing novelties with its own list of contents, a separate main text volume). In some cases, the lists of contents appear to have been bound with the plates (e.g., Meyer's "Novitiae: Grallatores et Rasores" in this volume on the Teyler's Museum website); this was not the case in any of the volumes scanned by BHL, however. In other cases, lists of contents have been bound together and separately from the plates (e.g., Meyer's "Novitiae: Natatores", "Novitiae: Grallatores et Rasores", and "Synopsis: Natatores, Grallatores et Rasores" in this Google Books volume).

For pigeons, I have never seen the initial "synopsis" (if anyone finds it, I'd be more than interested), and the only place I'm aware of, where the list of contents of the novitiae can be seen, is in Bruce et al's paper. The plates are on BHL (lacking 9 the final ones), and on the Teyler's Museum website (with the 9 final ones included -- most of them at the end of the volume). Note that the Teyler's Museum plates have no names on them; the names on the BHL plate are assumed to have been added by hand, presumably being copied from the lists of contents, which may then simply have been discarded.
 
Last edited:
list the contents of a set of pigeon plates that was published in 1851
And where to find this list?

Interessting that number 259 (and 260) are not mentioned in "Neuentdeckte Taubenvögel und Nachtrag" p.181


Apart are the dates of Voyage au Pôle Sud et dans l'Océanie, sur les corvettes "l'Astrolabe" et "la Zélée" of the plates and the text proper analysed? I mean was the text really published Pucheran, 1853 or as written in Bruce et al. 1854?
 
And where to find this list?
This list is the two pages reproduced by Bruce et al. in their Fig. 3 and 4 -- vol.136:no.2(Jun 2016) - Bulletin of the British Ornithologists' Club - Biodiversity Heritage Library and vol.136:no.2(Jun 2016) - Bulletin of the British Ornithologists' Club - Biodiversity Heritage Library .
There is nothing more than this -- one sheet of paper, dated "1. October 1851.", printed recto-verso by Carl Ramming in Dresden.

Interessting that number 259 (and 260) are not mentioned in "Neuentdeckte Taubenvögel und Nachtrag" p.181
The birds on the 1851 novitiae plates had long ceased to be neuentdeckte Taubenvögel when the text was published a decade later. These plates are mentioned in the first (main) part of the Tauben text (Meyer's "Vollständige Naturgeschichte der Tauben (erste Hälfte), Text."). E.g. : Abt.2:Bd.1;Abt.3:Bd.4:pt.1 (1836-1847) [Text] - Die vollständigste Naturgeschichte der Vögel - Biodiversity Heritage Library

Apart are the dates of Voyage au Pôle Sud et dans l'Océanie, sur les corvettes "l'Astrolabe" et "la Zélée" of the plates and the text proper analysed? I mean was the text really published Pucheran, 1853 or as written in Bruce et al. 1854?
I have argued that it was not here : Columbiformes

There are other problems with the argumentation presented in this paper.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top