First, thanks for the encouragement...and in a way there is a cheat here....these are the 4th or 5th try at the same place at the same time of day....the only way I could figure out to practice....the last one is the best, because I finally got the" simplify" thing right and left out a bunch of stuff that is in the previous one which is exactly the same spot! ...Also by now I've done abut 40 trees( working on 100) and they are starting to come a bit.
I always thought if I learned to paint I could paint anything...what I find is each sub genre, birds, landscsape, figure, even each animal takes separate study, and each has it's own kind of special knowledge needed. Most of this is not taught anymore, so that's why I keep going back to the last of the great skilled teachers of the eras past.
The first and the last are the winners here.
The first one, of the cedars, is simple and direct, without unnecessary detail, just concentrates on the shape and form of the trees
right, so many binned on those trees until this one...they are in a line across the back of the pasture, planted the same time, and all the same size, standing like soldiers next to each other.
The second, the pastel one, I think is probably the weakest of the four.
I will have to really try on the pastel, it is harder because you have to have the right color and can't mix like oils or acrylic....I dont, have a big box with me in the field so it's even worse. Also this is a strange scene, that red weed is really that red at sunset, but no one would believe it....learning to stay away from the really different things right now.. I think the pastel will work for quick sketches, but watercolor is just as good and easier to take...Probably after I learn from painting I'll be able to apply to pastel, and I will need a "landscape" set.
The third one falls somewhere between the two stools.To me there's not enough detail to be a detailed piece but too much to be a simplified piece. It's always tempting to put in a bit more detail if you have the time and real estate but it looks like you've fallen into the same trap that I do somethimes and used one size brush for the whole thing and where you've gone for individual leaves or grass it hasn't quite hit the mark. Also the trees feel as though they're lacking a bit of authenticity? Could be a case of painting more of what you think and less of what you see?
An earlier work, like all beginners thinking I have to paint what's in front of me, so too much stuff, earlier in my tree work too, stiff and havent' figured out sky holes and edges. Yes one brush, so I'll take two next time.
The fourth, 'golden' one is the best of the bunch. It's got colour, depth and, most importantly, atmosphere. You've caught the light by realising that the shadows are not too strong in the diffuse light but they are still darker in the foreground and the distance is knocked back a tone or three. I really like this one and I suspect you feel it's the strongest too.
yes, this one is after my reading Carlson Landscape book, and being at that spot 4-5 times and watching the light....I think this is a key for me...I don't seem to really "see" until I've been there a few times....guess that will leave me out of the current trend for Paint Out competitions. The other element in this is my study of the Tonalist painters....and to achieve this I premixed one pile of paint that was the color of the light, and used that color in every part, making it cooler or warmer lighter or darker as needed....that way there is instant harmony, and I could just really concentrate on value, the key to it all
What size are you working with? I deliberately use smaller sized boards (6"x4")
6x8 and 8x10 1/2"brush
I'll bet you're like me in that you get really frustrated with the whole process and wonder how other artists get the results they do but then once in a while you see a brush stroke or an effect in your own stuff and think 'that's what I wanted'.
exactly right! Thanks Mike that's a help
after another 75 bad paintings I should have a handle on this, even if I'm never a total plein air person, my backgrounds should work better, and capturing something on site will add loads to my studio work...esp to see the amazing light effects that no camera can capture. Not to mention it's just nice to be out there...