I have done this test, same converters and 300/2.8. There was not a lot in it but the 2x just shaded it. One advantage to having a 2x as well as a 1.4x is that you can stack them with the 300/2.8 and get reasonable results in good light (assuming the 2x is not a Canon mkIII).I know this has been covered to some extent in the past but has anyone done any tests with stacked 1.4 ( 1 canon and 1 kenko) over a canon 2x tc.
This would be on a 300 f/2.8
With two 1.4 x tc you do not add them together, you multiply 1.4 x 1.4 = 1.96 (actually it is 2 as a 1.4x tc is not exactly 1.4x)How does the maths work out on stacking TC's ?
EG 1.4xTC + 1.4xTC = 2.8x
300mm x 2.8x = 840mm
or....
1.4xTC X 1.4xTC = 1.96x
300mm x 1.96x = 588mm
Steve, you can stack a Canon 1.4x tc with a Canon 2x tc providing the 2x is a MKII (2x MkI or the new 2x MkIII will not stack). As already indicated you can stack a non Canon like the Kenko with your 1.4x Canon. There is a way of stacking two Canon 1.4x tc's by putting a 12mm extension tube between them but you would lose focus at infinity.I have a question about stacking of converters, looking at my Canon 1.4x would I stack this with another as the elements within the converter seem to prevent such as action. For instance the glass at both ends extend beyond the housing.
Is the stacking only possible using non Canon with a Canon?
many thanks
As my 2x is currently KIA I have been using two stacked 1.4s lately (Canon and Kenko PRO) and the results have been very good, as has been said on a par with the 2x really and generally the AF has been very good too but not quite as reliable as using the 2x. Check out the close-up of the willow warbler on my flickr page for a heavy crop using the two 1.4's. It's been sharpened a little as we all do but that doesn't detract from the fact that the original is still top notch IQ.
Basically if you were in a position where you had a 300mmf2.8 and you couldn't afford a Canon 2x and 1.4x for it or if you had an f4 lens and wanted a lot more reach but a 2x would stop the AF working then two 1.4s, be it a Canon and kenko or two kenko's then they are a very viable alternative IMO.
Excellent shots of the Willow Warbler with great detail. Can you just confirm the body/lens combination you used as the EXIF data has gone walkabout. Thanks. :t:
Yeah I have my flickr account set to withhold the exif data, perhaps you can do me a return favour BTW. Can you at least see what date it was taken? My aim was to include the EXIF when I saved the image so people could see when it was taken rather than me having to manually alter it for every image I upload which is the case if I use save for web.
At any rate it was a 1DMKIII with a 300mmf2.8 IS with Canon and Kenko 1.4's as I said. Really need to get my 2x seen to though! |^|