Bird ID - Georgia, near Atlanta, about two months ago. (1 Viewer)

[ignicapilla]

Hello everyone, can someone please help me ID these warblers? I asked about these before but now re-edited the images with better software to make them brighter and more clear.

 

[qwerty5]

1. Northern Parula
3. Could be Tennessee, but nothing certain

 

[Butty]

I asked about these before

It would help if you gave a link to that previous thread (or, better still, if you had posted this in that thread).

 

[ignicapilla]

Thanks! They weren't really discussed in the previous thread because the photos weren't bright enough.

 

[tom baxter]

1. Northern Parula
3. Could be Tennessee, but nothing certain

My thoughts as well. 2 appears to be a vireo shaped bill, but it is weird that a supercilium is not more noticeable.

 

[tom baxter]

I wonder if 2 is Bell's Vireo... If it is, that would be quite rare, but its the best I can come up with and it fits pretty well... any other pictures? Is there any chance you saw it on Sept. 17 at Murphy Candler Park near Atlanta?

 

[ignicapilla]

I wonder if 2 is Bell's Vireo... If it is, that would be quite rare, but its the best I can come up with and it fits pretty well... any other pictures? Is there any chance you saw it on Sept. 17 at Murphy Candler Park near Atlanta?

I don't know the exact spot for the 2nd, I was there with someone else, I believe that was N Georgia, further from Atlanta than the other ones. I'll look for other photos and return if I find anything.

 

[Indobirder]

I think #2 looks okay for American Redstart.
Bill looks fine for a warbler

 

[tom baxter]

I think #2 looks okay for American Redstart.
Bill looks fine for a warbler

I concede. I think you’re right. It is a pretty big coincidence that I checked ebird to see if there were any Bell’s Vireo’s around Atlanta around the time frame of the original post, and sure enough there was. That was after I gandered that guess. Still, I think it is probably a coincidence because another look at the bill, and it strikes me as odd for a warbler, but admittedly it doesn’t look like an obvious Vireo bill either. Then when you mentioned American Redstart, I have to agree because they do have a rather blunt-tipped, short and stout bill for a warbler. It all lines up pretty well.

 

[dantheman]

It would help if you gave a link to that previous thread (or, better still, if you had posted this in that thread).

ID - Georgia, N of Atlanta, about a month ago.

Last one I believe is a magnolia warbler, for them rest of them I don't have any good ideas.

www.birdforum.net

(I recognise the last pic and recall commenting possibly REV, but wondered about the bill)