During the time I have been birdwatching, I have become aware of a phenomena I am calling "observer bias" in which the birder, when he sees a bird of unknown species, or when he only gets a glimpse or a brief view, in his enthusiasm, becomes affected by undue leaning towards identifying it as a relatively rare or more sought-after bird, when in all likelihood the bird he actually saw, is very very much more likely to be a commonplace bird.
I have been guilty of this myself in the past, so am not belittling the observer here.