• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Kenya's Carbofuran Killing Fields -please Read! (1 Viewer)

Steve G

RAINBIRDER
Hi everyone,
Apologies for the length of this post but please scroll down to the images at the foot of the page to see why this needs your attention (these are our Wood Sandpipers, Ruff, etc that are being poisoned!).

I have friends in Kenya who are struggling to gain support in their campaign to persuade the Kenyan government to ban Carbofuran (Furadan). This is why they need your help:

Carbofuran (branded as Furadan) is a cholinesterase inhibitor produced in the USA by the Philadelphia-based FMC Corporation as an agricultural insecticide/nematicide. In May 2009 the U.S Enviromental Protection Agency (EPA) cancelled all food tolerances for carbofuran, an action which amounts to a de facto ban on its use on all crops grown for human consumption, this being brought about due to human toxicity issues and mass bird poisonings. Here is a link to the EPA website which justifies their stance: http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/reregistration/carbofuran/carbofuran_noic.htm
If the name carbofuran sounds familiar to UK birders that’s because it is the favoured substance used in baits to poison our raptors (check how many times the chemical is mentioned in table 1 of this link): http://docs.google.com/gview?a=v&q=...FNbKoY&sig=AFQjCNERquylYi5hCgrZAmA6MG6X0HNIAQ

Unfortunately Furadan is widely available in most African countries including Kenya where it is offloaded cheaply & where it has, to date, escaped safety restrictions or limitations of use (in no small part due to unofficial “political donations”!). Furadan is available very cheaply in Kenya and can even be purchased in small local stores. Though promoted as a crop insecticide/nematicide it is now frequently used to kill birds.
Furadan has been used by herdsmen to lace poison baits specifically to kill lions but it has also caused the death of hundreds of vultures. It is now also being used by subsistence hunters to "hunt" birds for the bushmeat trade. It is this latter use which has become especially worrying as birds are being killed in their thousands (this includes large numbers of storks and palearctic waders). The carcases are sold on as bushmeat in markets without due care taken to ensure the chemical is purged from the meat raising the very strong possibility of poisoning in the consumer.

As an example of how Furadan is now being used to “hunt” birds here is a short article written by Martin Odino for Nature Kenya’s online magazine called “Where Furadan Kills all Birds”:

“Bunyala Rice Scheme is situated in western Kenya North West of Lake Victoria near the Kenya-Uganda border. Like many irrigation schemes, it throbs with bird life whose numbers swell even more during the migration period. In fact this area is on the flyway that is used by Palearctic migrants. So rich is the avifauna that virtually all birds from various habitats are represented; Terns, Herons, Storks, Nightjars, Eagles, Starlings, Crows, Pipits and Sunbirds, occur in their various species.
But death lurks behind these beautiful creatures all year round and thousands are poisoned every week. Bird meat is a delicacy amongst the locals of Bunyala. The method used to capture the birds is however crude and brutal. It involves use of the pesticide Furadan which is a carbamate nematicide and therefore an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor. The poison pesticide is locally available in granular form; it is these granules that are laced on the various birds’ baits which are then laid out where birds forage in and around the irrigation scheme.
A modification of the baiting involves employing live decoys alongside the poison laced baits. This is particularly so for the African Open-billed Stork. Mildly intoxicated storks are captured and given plenty of water to revive them. These are then kept captive which involves the pulling off of their flight feathers and tying their legs together with a loose string to limit their free movement. These decoys are usually set out on an open field with the poison bait scattered about. Acting as attractants to conspecific members, the others fly in as the poachers (the people that poison the birds) disturb any nearby foraging birds so that they take to flight. Once airborne, they will notice the captives and deceived that they are other free birds settled where there is food settle down as well to feed on the poison bait.
Once intoxicated the birds are disoriented and walk in staggering gait. The poachers then batter them with sticks and pack them in sacks and load them on bicycles taking them to homesteads and markets where they will sell them for human consumption.”


Carbofuran is toxic to humans and indeed the three year old son of a Kenyan teacher recently died as a result of accidental poisoning. His father, an educated man, was not aware of the dangers of Furadan (he had bought it to use on the family's vegetable plot) as the packaging does not bear the skull & cross bones warning sign -which is the universal international sign of a poison!

Furadan is now both cheap and widely available in many African countries where it is supplied in granular form. Should its use become more frequent across the numerous small agricultural plots of Africa then less of our summer migrants such as redstarts, whinchat, wheatears and nightingales will make the journey north each spring!!!
In short we need a worldwide ban of carbofuran!
When I suggested to friends in Kenya that we raise a petition on this issue the reply was: “A petition has little clout in Kenya where high government officials are under Ocampo's gun for impunity and the massacre of over 1000 people. Here cause and effect are difficult to link.”
The best way to help this cause is to publicise it and to support the work of Wildlife Direct by visiting their blog to read about the problems created by Carbofuran at first hand (it smacks of John le Carré’s The Constant Gardener!) and, if you are able, donate to the cause. Please visit the blog at: http://stopwildlifepoisoning.wildlifedirect.org/

Many thanks for reading this.
Best wishes,
Steve
 

Attachments

  • 1.Aquatic snails laced with Furadan.JPG
    1.Aquatic snails laced with Furadan.JPG
    51.9 KB · Views: 83
  • 2.Poisoned Openbill Storks.JPG
    2.Poisoned Openbill Storks.JPG
    48.1 KB · Views: 87
  • 3. Poisoned Wood Sandpipers.JPG
    3. Poisoned Wood Sandpipers.JPG
    52.3 KB · Views: 84
  • 4. Loading up the kills for market.JPG
    4. Loading up the kills for market.JPG
    48.5 KB · Views: 59
  • 5. Bunyala -the killing fields.JPG
    5. Bunyala -the killing fields.JPG
    52.2 KB · Views: 64
Thanks for bringing this horrendous news to our attention Steve.

There may be a glimmer of hope for a total ban when people in the U.S. realise that it's still being used in products they buy;

The Worldwide implications of carbofuran ban in USA

“The revocation of all food tolerances has international implications, as imports of rice, coffee, bananas and sugarcane were previously allowed to contain residues of carbofuran,” said Dr. Fry “After this revocation, countries wishing to export these foods to the US must stop using carbofuran on these four major crops.”
 
.........

There may be a glimmer of hope for a total ban when people in the U.S. realise that it's still being used in products they buy;

The Worldwide implications of carbofuran ban in USA

“The revocation of all food tolerances has international implications, as imports of rice, coffee, bananas and sugarcane were previously allowed to contain residues of carbofuran,” said Dr. Fry “After this revocation, countries wishing to export these foods to the US must stop using carbofuran on these four major crops.”

Hopefully you are right Dave as Kenya is one of the major suppliers of coffee to the USA.

The problem is that there is so much Furadan currently available in Kenya that it will take a long time & a lot of dead birds before it is "used up".

Carbofuran is officially "banned" in Tanzania but there are supplies on the Agrovet shelves which have clearly come from Kenya.

I gather that Carbofuran was banned in the UK in 2001 but illegally held stockpiles are still being used to poison our raptors.


Make no mistake, this substance has the ability to poison large numbers of insectivorous migrant palearctic birds -it may already be a major player in the decline of birds like Spotted Flycatcher!
 
:-C:-C:-C

It's a rather sad indictment of modern values when the content of this thread receives less interest than threads such as "Poached gulls eggs in Masterchef" and "Pissing in a nestbox"!

Are we all now really so cynical & uncaring?
 
I'm just reading 'Living on the wind' and they had a chapter on a similar situation in Argentina where thousands of wintering Swainson's Hawks were being killed off from an insecticide. That story had a positive turn around as the manufacturer, Ceiba-Geigy, Argentinian Government, Farmers, and Biologists all worked together for a solution.

From reading on the website you linked it looks like there is a lot of work and commitment needed yet by the manufacturer, FMC, and the government. Someone has got to figure out how to get them really onboard or there won't be a solution.
 
Possibly yes. Human nature again.

Mind, it's a lot easier to post a 'witty' comment on a random thread than think deeply about real issues, I'll admit I tend to shy away from the latter myself.

If governments and multinationals caused the problems in the first place (I have a feeling policies and their actions are at the root of many of the problems in the 3rd world, along with that human nature thing again and corruption), maybe they should do something about the problems they cause. Not sure if the pesticides were made in the west or not, but certainly invented by/originally distributed by them.

Maybe the RSPB/responsible organizations in the west could look to encouraging above governments etc in purchasing the leftover stocks of these chemicals to take them off the market??

Cheers for posting the above.
 
Nah, I'm with you Steve. I am amazed at the amount of Carbofuran (or worse) still used in the US. Of course, the manufacturer (from website)says deliberate misuse is the cause of most bird deaths. (Uh, yeah...right.). Since around where I live has been cotton fields for decades, the pesticide issues are usually only addressed when a new subdivision is built and the dirt is 'strange'....everything runs downhill, you know.
Good luck with the campaign.
 
Send our poisons to Sub-Saharan Africa as who cares anyway?

The U.S Enviromental Protection Agency (EPA) has announced a complete ban of the pesticide Furadan -effective from the end of 2009 (see: http://www.treehugger.com/files/2009/11/epa-bans-pesticide-insecticide-carbofuran-by-2010.php ).

So if Furadan is too toxic for the U.S market why is it acceptable to continue producing it in Philadelphia for export to third world nations where it is poisoning kids, wildlife and birds?

What's a few lions, vultures or wee African bairns when Pennsylvanian pay-cheques are at stake!!!
 

Attachments

  • Wildlife + birds + Furadan = death.jpg
    Wildlife + birds + Furadan = death.jpg
    157.3 KB · Views: 42
It's a rather sad indictment of modern values when the content of this thread receives less interest than threads such as "Poached gulls eggs in Masterchef" and "Pissing in a nestbox"!

Are we all now really so cynical & uncaring?

Perhaps not uncaring, but at a loss to see how this can be tackled. As said, when the government is basically unfussed by mass killings of its own people, it is going to take quite a lot to dissuade them from killing 'a few birds'. Agreed, the pressure needs to be put on foreign companies to try to add pressure - be they tourism or agricultural imports. As Kenya struggles to see its tourist sector recover, if the country were to see this as a potential hindrance, and so resulting in a financial price, then maybe we might see movements to act.
 
I totally agree with you Jos . We have had the issue in front of at Nature Kenya for some time and it is getting much more publicity and attention worldwide through Richard Leakey's wildlife direct forum . But when you get such corruption as we have here in govt ,it is hard to see an end to it all .
Apparantly one of the senior govt officials who should stop this owns the importing company of the poison


Mike D in Nairobi


Perhaps not uncaring, but at a loss to see how this can be tackled. As said, when the government is basically unfussed by mass killings of its own people, it is going to take quite a lot to dissuade them from killing 'a few birds'. Agreed, the pressure needs to be put on foreign companies to try to add pressure - be they tourism or agricultural imports. As Kenya struggles to see its tourist sector recover, if the country were to see this as a potential hindrance, and so resulting in a financial price, then maybe we might see movements to act.
 
I totally agree with you Jos . We have had the issue in front of at Nature Kenya for some time and it is getting much more publicity and attention worldwide through Richard Leakey's wildlife direct forum . But when you get such corruption as we have here in govt ,it is hard to see an end to it all .
Apparantly one of the senior govt officials who should stop this owns the importing company of the poison


Mike D in Nairobi

:eek!::eek!::eek!: Sadly I can think of no solution to this!!!
 
Hi everyone,
Apologies for the length of this post but please scroll down to the images at the foot of the page to see why this needs your attention (these are our Wood Sandpipers, Ruff, etc that are being poisoned!).

I have friends in Kenya who are struggling to gain support in their campaign to persuade the Kenyan government to ban Carbofuran (Furadan). This is why they need your help:

Carbofuran (branded as Furadan) is a cholinesterase inhibitor produced in the USA by the Philadelphia-based FMC Corporation as an agricultural insecticide/nematicide. In May 2009 the U.S Enviromental Protection Agency (EPA) cancelled all food tolerances for carbofuran, an action which amounts to a de facto ban on its use on all crops grown for human consumption, this being brought about due to human toxicity issues and mass bird poisonings. Here is a link to the EPA website which justifies their stance: http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/reregistration/carbofuran/carbofuran_noic.htm
If the name carbofuran sounds familiar to UK birders that’s because it is the favoured substance used in baits to poison our raptors (check how many times the chemical is mentioned in table 1 of this link): http://docs.google.com/gview?a=v&q=...FNbKoY&sig=AFQjCNERquylYi5hCgrZAmA6MG6X0HNIAQ

Unfortunately Furadan is widely available in most African countries including Kenya where it is offloaded cheaply & where it has, to date, escaped safety restrictions or limitations of use (in no small part due to unofficial “political donations”!). Furadan is available very cheaply in Kenya and can even be purchased in small local stores. Though promoted as a crop insecticide/nematicide it is now frequently used to kill birds.
Furadan has been used by herdsmen to lace poison baits specifically to kill lions but it has also caused the death of hundreds of vultures. It is now also being used by subsistence hunters to "hunt" birds for the bushmeat trade. It is this latter use which has become especially worrying as birds are being killed in their thousands (this includes large numbers of storks and palearctic waders). The carcases are sold on as bushmeat in markets without due care taken to ensure the chemical is purged from the meat raising the very strong possibility of poisoning in the consumer.

As an example of how Furadan is now being used to “hunt” birds here is a short article written by Martin Odino for Nature Kenya’s online magazine called “Where Furadan Kills all Birds”:

“Bunyala Rice Scheme is situated in western Kenya North West of Lake Victoria near the Kenya-Uganda border. Like many irrigation schemes, it throbs with bird life whose numbers swell even more during the migration period. In fact this area is on the flyway that is used by Palearctic migrants. So rich is the avifauna that virtually all birds from various habitats are represented; Terns, Herons, Storks, Nightjars, Eagles, Starlings, Crows, Pipits and Sunbirds, occur in their various species.
But death lurks behind these beautiful creatures all year round and thousands are poisoned every week. Bird meat is a delicacy amongst the locals of Bunyala. The method used to capture the birds is however crude and brutal. It involves use of the pesticide Furadan which is a carbamate nematicide and therefore an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor. The poison pesticide is locally available in granular form; it is these granules that are laced on the various birds’ baits which are then laid out where birds forage in and around the irrigation scheme.
A modification of the baiting involves employing live decoys alongside the poison laced baits. This is particularly so for the African Open-billed Stork. Mildly intoxicated storks are captured and given plenty of water to revive them. These are then kept captive which involves the pulling off of their flight feathers and tying their legs together with a loose string to limit their free movement. These decoys are usually set out on an open field with the poison bait scattered about. Acting as attractants to conspecific members, the others fly in as the poachers (the people that poison the birds) disturb any nearby foraging birds so that they take to flight. Once airborne, they will notice the captives and deceived that they are other free birds settled where there is food settle down as well to feed on the poison bait.
Once intoxicated the birds are disoriented and walk in staggering gait. The poachers then batter them with sticks and pack them in sacks and load them on bicycles taking them to homesteads and markets where they will sell them for human consumption.”


Carbofuran is toxic to humans and indeed the three year old son of a Kenyan teacher recently died as a result of accidental poisoning. His father, an educated man, was not aware of the dangers of Furadan (he had bought it to use on the family's vegetable plot) as the packaging does not bear the skull & cross bones warning sign -which is the universal international sign of a poison!

Furadan is now both cheap and widely available in many African countries where it is supplied in granular form. Should its use become more frequent across the numerous small agricultural plots of Africa then less of our summer migrants such as redstarts, whinchat, wheatears and nightingales will make the journey north each spring!!!
In short we need a worldwide ban of carbofuran!
When I suggested to friends in Kenya that we raise a petition on this issue the reply was: “A petition has little clout in Kenya where high government officials are under Ocampo's gun for impunity and the massacre of over 1000 people. Here cause and effect are difficult to link.”
The best way to help this cause is to publicise it and to support the work of Wildlife Direct by visiting their blog to read about the problems created by Carbofuran at first hand (it smacks of John le Carré’s The Constant Gardener!) and, if you are able, donate to the cause. Please visit the blog at: http://stopwildlifepoisoning.wildlifedirect.org/

Many thanks for reading this.
Best wishes,
Steve

"Carbofuran is toxic to humans and indeed the three year old son of a Kenyan teacher recently died as a result of accidental poisoning."

Steve the fact that a child dies from starvation in Africa every 5 seconds kinda makes your post null and void dont ya think ?
 
"Carbofuran is toxic to humans and indeed the three year old son of a Kenyan teacher recently died as a result of accidental poisoning."

Steve the fact that a child dies from starvation in Africa every 5 seconds kinda makes your post null and void dont ya think ?

So dumping toxic pesticides on third world nations (which have been banned in the west 'cos their deemed far too risky when entering the agricultural food chain) is your solution to tackling starvation in African children?

African poverty with profound malnutrition is a very different topic and one which Western protectionism in the form of agricultural/trade policy contributes to greatly ......but of course you will know that being a Gentleman Farmer!
 
Steve the fact that a child dies from starvation in Africa every 5 seconds kinda makes your post null and void dont ya think ?

So, just one more African child dying doesn't matter, poisoning or starvation or whatever, is that what you're saying?

And the fact that it kills birds, animals and humans in a Nation use to death shouldn't matter either?

Sorry, I can't get what you're saying unless it's in support of a banned pesticide. Vested interest perhaps?
 
Sorry to hearing than the organophosphates are showing its power over the african wildlife. Having been grown in a farmers family where every year a bit more of one hundred kilos of carbofuran were used in the sugar beets, this branch of chemicals is almost a relative. When I was a teenager I witnesed how lark-likes, alaudidae members, were missing in the villages whith sugar beet fields. The answer was obvious. Larks returned came back when the seed producers introduced the imidopropid, and the yields are higher than ever. In the nineties, in Spain started the fashion to use organophosphates aimed for "vermins" by hunters. Although illegal, it was improbable than somebody ended in jail. Three years ago I lived closely an episode of poisoning with organophosphates. More than forty grifonns, Gyps fulvus, died. Most of them where incubators so the loss was even bigger. Luckily round 20 were saved by atropine injection. The poisoning of the birds were unintentional, they had eaten in the corpse of a poisoned dog. The vagabond dog had been poisoned because some villagers were afraid of him. It was a kind of dog used in wildboard hunting, a cross between mastiff and local sigthounds "podencos". Although their apearence is terrible, with their cut ears, they are used to work with people they don't know. It would have been easy to get in contact with the owner, its phone numbers was in the collar, as I did.
So, forget us the demagogical flags. We were speaking about poachers or something worse. Mixing matters doesn't help.
On the other hand, documentaries filmed in Ngorongoro, and even safaris Dysney way, usually give a poor idea of the real situation of wildlife. In part, the cost of the trip make one selection towards the foreigners, usually western people, with least contact with the ground. In Arusha National Park, in Tanzania, I found a lot of snares aimed for klipspringers at round 3700m. It didn't look reasonable than the villagers were interested in go up 2000m for poaching, when there were much more "meat" close their houses. Cause of this I had a discussion with the ranger supervisor. And Arusha isn't the worst managed National Park by far.
It's time to end but I'd like to tell than the image of "people" sticking the intoxicated birds makes me remember a traditional, although illegal, way to collect grain eaters, usually pigeons. Wheat grain wich has been submerged in wine is the poisoning agent.

Fernando
 
Warning! This thread is more than 15 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top