James Walker said:
David, Sorry to drag you back to the start of this thread, but I am a beginner and trying hard to catch up. In my earlier thread I asked for advise on using a D70, Nikon FSA-L1 and a suitable Nikon 'scope. As the FSA plugs directly into the 'scope (i.e. no eyepeice) and bayonets directly into the body of the D70, is this not prime lens working? I agreed the adapter is not cheap, there is a commitment to use a Nikon ED 'scope and a support for the camera is probably required, but would it match Fernando results?
OK James no prob. Yes, it is what we call prime focus - ie, no eyepiece between the scope and camera sensor. I didnt realise that the adaptor was a prime adaptor. Most digiscoping uses an eyepiece between the scope and the cammera and thats what I thought you were asking about. I use prime a lot now, but it has it's disadvantages in that the system is totally manual, focus and exposure. Fernando has a Skywatcher 80ED which has, I believe, about 650mm focal length. His technique is one I will be investigating over the next few weeks as a better solution to using my own scope in manual mode.
The biggie here with say a Nikon spotting scope is the focal length and focal ratio of the scope, as it is taking the place of the lens. My scope is a 500mm f6.2 with an 80mm objective lens. If the Nikon is an 82mm, check its overall length - that may give you an idea of the focal ratio. I think the smaller spotting scopes must have a much shorter focal length, therefore, not *that* much better at prime focus than say my 28-300mm zoom lens.
example of the sums :
diameter x focal ratio = focal length
80mm x f6.2 = 496mm focal length
Fernando does take some damn fine images
but he has a lot of experience and has the advantage of metering with his special modded lens adaptor, so he does NOT have to guess his exposure times as I do. However, if you can gain that experience with a bigger scope, then there is no reason why you too could not achive similar results.
To summarise (sorry, Ive just been thinking out loud here) -
How much can you afford ? (my scope and T2 mount adaptor was about £250)
What level of convenience do you want ? (my setup is fully manual only)
What weight are you prepared to lug about ? (mine weighs in with camera and scope & tripod at over 10KGs, NOT really portable if out walking !)
Feel free to contact me by PM or email and we can arrange a chat on the phone if you like, I'm always happy to try and help. Bear in mind my background is astronomical photography, so my knowledge of scopes is slightly different to most in here (not meaning to sound big headed guys !)
Still confused ?? Hope not
===========
Fernando, thanks for the last message. I assumed that the AF system would need to be disabled.