London Birder
Well-known member
Tim, are you simply about point-scoring mate?
You maintain what you want, you were pretty damn forthright yourself about the Kessie being a Peregrine where you not?
Sorry if I still see a Hobby in the first photograph, you and I and many others will have to disagree ... I made my ID on the sole pic of the bird perched in a conifer and to me it doesn't quite look right even compared to the new pics, to you it does, hurrah for you!
and no I don't think the Kes pic was all that shocking, not great I grant you yet still identifiably a Kestrel as opposed to a Peregrine and a bunch of leaves.... as for the Mistle Thrush ID I've explained why I thought it was a Fieldfare, what more do you want me to say ... and what relevence does it have to the current debate?
Unless of course your implying somehow that I'm a s**t birder ...
well, that I ain't, but neither am I Charlie Big Potatoes ...
You maintain what you want, you were pretty damn forthright yourself about the Kessie being a Peregrine where you not?
Sorry if I still see a Hobby in the first photograph, you and I and many others will have to disagree ... I made my ID on the sole pic of the bird perched in a conifer and to me it doesn't quite look right even compared to the new pics, to you it does, hurrah for you!
and no I don't think the Kes pic was all that shocking, not great I grant you yet still identifiably a Kestrel as opposed to a Peregrine and a bunch of leaves.... as for the Mistle Thrush ID I've explained why I thought it was a Fieldfare, what more do you want me to say ... and what relevence does it have to the current debate?
Unless of course your implying somehow that I'm a s**t birder ...
well, that I ain't, but neither am I Charlie Big Potatoes ...
Last edited: