Pleased to see this thread resurrected for I too am an “orntholibraholic” and, thankfully, there’s no cure. Back in 1960 I had, I think, three bird books – the Observer’s Book of Birds (naturally) which I’d purloined from my big sister, Fisher’s Bird Recognition (but only Vol 1 which was on an extended loan from my dad) and Collin’s Pocket Guide to British Birds. I then saw a reprint of Kirkman & Jourdain’s “British Birds” which was chokablock with beautiful plates by Seaby, Lodge, Austen et al. It was vastly expensive - six guineas, 63/- or in decimal currency (which hadn’t been invented then) £3:15, but I persuaded my mum that this was going to be the last bird book I’d ever want. Of course, I believed it then, but over the next 45 years or so, as more and more juicy tomes were published, a bird book gradually appeared on every Christmas and birthday list. Getting married helped too because that meant not only my parents got me a bird book, but so too did my wife and, as they learnt nothing else measured up, so did my in-laws. Mind you that didn’t stop me buying a few on my own account so here I am with 400 odd bird books. (As my wife also likes books I guess there’s well over a thousand lurking about the house).
I have what I regard as the four great seminal books on birds in English. The oldest book, a bit of a cheat this as it is a facsimile reprint, is Ray’s ‘The Ornithology of Francis Willughby’ (1678) which was I think one of the first, if not the first, book published in English. This is full of wonderful stuff since it was written when scientific ornithology was beginning to supplant superstition and folktales. A process that wasn’t quite complete since every now and again there’s a bit which seems to say “I-don’t-believe-this-but-I’m-leaving-it-in-just-in-case”! The second has to be a nice clean 1934 copy (sadly no dust jacket and not the first printing) of Peterson’s “A Field Guide to the Birds” which I picked up for £3. Frankly it’s pretty feeble effort by today’s standards, but, although it was not, arguably, the first field guide, this was the book that defined and established the genre. The third book is the ‘Handbook of British Birds’ (1938-1941) which, like Peterson, established the genre. In fact, it did it so well that nearly 70 years on I still refer to it regularly. The final mould breaking book is ‘The Atlas of Breeding British Birds in Britain and Ireland’ (Sharrock 1976); another new genre and a reflection of what organised amateur birders can achieve.
Not in the same class in terms of influence, but still great books come following. Harrison’s “Seabirds’ as it created a whole new market in the Helm/Pica press style. Then there is James Fisher’s ‘Shell Guide’ which didn’t set any trends, but stands alone as a monument to the great man’s erudition and width of knowledge – and not least a reminder of what a shame it was he never completed his ‘Bird Recognition’ books. The only book that deserves to stand alongside this work is Ian Wallace’s provocative and eccentric “Beguiled by Birds” – great read. Amongst the myriad of picture books I’d single out ‘The Guardian of the East Bank’ – a fascinating read strewn with RAR’s un-showy, but wonderful artwork. And finally the two books which I regard as the best on identification yet published. No, despite clearly currently being the best field guide to birds ever written, I don’t mean the ‘Collins Bird Guide’ since this is evolutionary, not revolutionary. I refer to the two MacMillan guides which present a series of superb short papers on all the hard stuff. They should have spawned a new genre, but perhaps there just aren’t enough brilliant writers & artists to sustain such a development.
With apologies for the gross anglocentric bias,
John