• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Sea eagle spreads its wings to head east in Scotland (1 Viewer)

Chris Monk

Well-known member
Scotland on Sunday http://news.scotsman.com/scotland.cfm?id=1833552006

Sun 10 Dec 2006

Sea eagle spreads its wings to head east

JEREMY WATSON ([email protected])

THE iconic white-tailed sea eagle will once again fly over the east coast of Scotland under an ambitious plan to reintroduce one of the world's biggest birds of prey to its former range.

Up to 100 of the birds - with 8ft wingspans - will be released in the Forth/Tay estuary area over a five-year period.

The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds has already applied to the Scottish Executive for a licence to release sea eagle chicks imported from Norway. The Executive's adviser, Scottish Natural Heritage, have now agreed to pay half the costs of the £250,000 project.

But landowners and farmers fear the eagles, bigger than golden eagles, will prey on livestock along the rich east coast farmlands. Lambs have been taken by the giant birds of prey during a similar successful reintroduction on the west coast of Scotland and the National Farmers' Union Scotland claims releases close to towns and cities could have "unpredictable" consequences.

The Executive will launch a public consultation once a site, most likely to be close to a fish-rich estuary, has been selected.

Sea eagles were abundant along both the west and east coasts, but were hunted to extinction by Victorian and Edwardian gamekeepers, with the last bird shot on Shetland in 1918.

Reintroduction to the west coast began in 1975, with releases on the remote island of Rum, and later on the Letterewe Estate in the north-west Highlands.

The birds have spread to west coast islands, including Mull and Skye, and are successfully breeding in the wild.

But although at least 30 pairs are now established, the bird's long-term future still remains uncertain.

Andrew Douse, an SNH scientist involved in the project, said: "These dramatic and unmistakable birds have a huge wingspan and are a very impressive sight."

Duncan Orr-Ewing, head of species and land management at RSPB Scotland, said: "This project will extend the range of this magnificent and awe inspiring species to the east coast of Scotland, bringing it far closer to people and opening up the very considerable economic benefits from tourism that have been reaped by places where sea eagles can be seen, like Mull.

"Their natural habitat is lowland wetland, coastal and estuarine areas. These are much richer feeding grounds for sea eagles, where their diet comprises both fish and water birds that are often scavenged or taken alive."

Sea eagle-related tourism is now estimated to bring around £1.7m a year into Mull. But, as SNH points out in a report on the reintroduction programme, extending the range to eastern Scotland brings both "opportunities" and "risks".

"The presence of sea eagles has had a number of unforeseen consequences, in particular localised but problematic predation on livestock (especially lambs)," the report says.

However, it adds that the problem has largely been overcome by persuading farmers to look after eagle sites because of the economic benefits the birds bring.

NFU Scotland states it is not opposed, in principle, to the reintroduction of species, but wants a thorough examination of the potential risks.

For example, a spokeswoman said, sea eagles reintroduced on the west coast had found a "plentiful and readily available supply of lamb", changing their eating habits from the historically preferred diet of fish and birds, "causing damage and concern to the local farming community".
 
Last edited:
hi Chris

do you know anything about reintroduction plans in England ?
when birding on Mull this year someone told me that the RSPB were planning
a reintroduction in England.


Markus
 
Interesting article on the Sea eagle. I have always loved reading about this bird because it so resembles the Bald Eagle of N. America, which is my favorite bird of prey.
 
"The Executive will launch a public consultation once a site, most likely to be close to a fish-rich estuary, has been selected."

Is there such a thing nowadays?
Esturine and costal fishing (beach and rock) on the East coast has died a death over the last 10 years. Far too many Seals, and the odd Dolphin!! take their share, of what there is, which is not a lot.

Small snipit :- Sea-eagle from a well known old East Coast nest site was reportedly shot on the Ythan estuary in 1910. It's mate had been shot 2 years earlier, further up the coast.

Regards

Malky
 
alcedo.atthis <snip> Far too many Seals <snip> Malky[/QUOTE said:
Have we any right to judge? Nature has a history of finding a natural balance when left alone. Unfortunately, humans don't have the best track record when it comes to 'management'.

It might be argued there are too many humans on the planet but doubt there's a majority in favour of culling our own species.
 
"Have we any right to judge? Nature has a history of finding a natural balance when left alone."


Martin, without getting into some long spurious debate about management -v- left alone, we as humans are part of nature. Evolution has given us the will to destroy or not as the case may be. We as humans, trying to "manage??" the environment, more often than not, do more damage, than if we left it alone to the constraints of natural balance, of which, we, as a natural entity, are part of the influencing factors.
What we do, think and act on, is part of nature, no matter how bad, good or indifferent it is.
Some say too many Seals. Some say too many fishermen. Some say too many Dolphins. Others say too many Whales.
Who is actually correct, and why??

Regards

Malky
 
I agree wholeheartedly that we are an integral part of the natural world. As someone involved directly in the conservation of the UK's most persecuted bird of prey I am very aware of the conflict between different land users.

Thanks for appreciating I wasn't intending to open an inflamatory debate!

Let's hope in this instance there is well reasoned scientific argument in reaching the right decision regarding any reintroduction. Sadly, the majority of ex-situ programmes around the globe end in failure so any intent must not be based on sentiment.

The golden eagle reintroduction project (www.goldeneagle.ie) in the ROI is a shining example of what can be achieved in overcoming many prejudices and meeting the challenges of reintroducing a predator at the top of the trophic cascade. The success of any project can only be measured in the long term but I sincerely hope other projects use this project as an excellent model for reintroduction.

Cheers


Martin
p.s. Any bets on when sea eagles and/or red kites will re-colonise Cumbria?
 
Warning! This thread is more than 17 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top