• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Accipiters (1 Viewer)

You mean trivirgatus and griseiceps ...
I should sleep more, it seems... :smoke:

trivirgatus admittedly ends up very far from where it would be expected (to the extent that it can be difficult to spot it in the tree). This could raise concerns about the sequences, but the cox1 (from BOLD) and the cytb (deposited in GenBank in 2002 by Taiwanese researchers) sequences convey exactly the same signal (compare the two non-bootstrapped trees in attachment), which would seem hard to explain if they are not genuine...
 

Attachments

  • cytb_Accipiter-trivirgatus.non-bootstrapped.pdf
    6.3 KB · Views: 202
  • cox1_Accipiter-trivirgatus.non-bootstrapped.pdf
    6.5 KB · Views: 192
Last edited:
L. Raty wrote: "Tachyspiza minulla": OS minullus. Jobling gives: "minula / minulla / minullum / minullus Med. L. minulus very small (dim. from L. minus less)." I'd be most interested if anybody could show me a Latin dictionary that actually includes this word--it is certainly absent from classical Latin dictionaries, but also, eg., Niermeyer's Medieval Latin-French/English Dictionary seems to ignore it. Does it really exist?.

In a Seebohm article about Sylvia in an old Ibis the editors note for Sylvia minula Hume a Lesser Whitethroat "Probably a misprint for minuta there being no such Latin word "minula". Edd. (Ibis V. III (1879) p.315)
 
L. Raty wrote: "Tachyspiza minulla": OS minullus. Jobling gives: "minula / minulla / minullum / minullus Med. L. minulus very small (dim. from L. minus less)." I'd be most interested if anybody could show me a Latin dictionary that actually includes this word--it is certainly absent from classical Latin dictionaries, but also, eg., Niermeyer's Medieval Latin-French/English Dictionary seems to ignore it. Does it really exist?.

In a Seebohm article about Sylvia in an old Ibis the editors note for Sylvia minula Hume a Lesser Whitethroat "Probably a misprint for minuta there being no such Latin word "minula". Edd. (Ibis V. III (1879) p.315)

Thanks Mark. At least I'm not the only one who fails to find this word. ;)

minutus, -a, -um does exist.
parvulus, -a, -um, the diminutive form of parvus, -a, -um = small, is the classical word to mean very small.

Stricly speaking, Jobling's interpretation, "dim. from L. minus less", sounds incorrect to me (sorry, James, if you're out there): "minus less" is not an adjective, it's an adverb--an invariable word, and not one that would normally be used as a name. When a species has 'minus' as its specific name, this is the neuter of minor, -or, -us = smaller, the comparative form of parvus. Of course one might imagine to add a diminutive suffix to minor (although I'm not fully clear what the meaning of the resulting word would be), but this would then produce 'minorulus' (the genitive of minor is minoris), not minulus.

Falco minullus Daudin, 1800 seems to be the earliest "minula / minulla / minullum / minullus" in ornithology. But this name was not actually formed from a Latin word: it is the latinization of a French vernacular coined by Levaillant, "Le Minul(l)e" (two 'l's in the text, one only on the plate), a name that Levaillant used as a masculine noun in French. 'Minulle' is not a standard French word, but this is no real surprise as it was quite usual for Lavaillant to forge names by modifying/combining existing words (one well known example being 'Oricou', his name for the Lappet-faced Vulture, which is a portmanteau involving 'oreille' = ear, and 'cou' = neck). In the case of "Le Minulle", his intent was clearly to convey the fact that the bird was very small, but it's hard to be sure how he formed the word exactly. (Contraction of the French word 'minuscule' = tiny? I don't think it too likely that the process involved Latin.)
 
Last edited:
Certainly Falco minullus Daudin, 1800, was based on "Le Minulle" of Levaillant 1798, Hist. Nat. Oiseaux d'Afrique, I, pp. 92-94, pl. 34.
Med. L. minulus occurs in R. E. Latham, "Revised Medieval Latin Word-List from British and Irish Sources with Supplement" published by OUP 1980, where it is considered a possible error or variant of minusculus = rather less.
 
It seems this older paper is not mentioned here:
Louette, M., M. Herremans, Z.T. Nagy. L.-A.R. de Roland, K. Jordaens, J. Van Houdt, G. Sonet, and F.C. Breman. 2011. Frances's Sparrowhawk Accipiter francesiae (Aves: Accipitridae) radiation on the Comoro Islands. Pp. 133-143 in K.-L. Schuchmann (ed.). Tropical vertebrates in a changing world. Bonner Zoologische Monographien no. 57.
PDF here
 
Besra

Xuhao Song, Jie Huang, Chaochao Yan, Gaowei Xu, Xiuyue Zhang, Bisong Yue. The complete mitochondrial genome of Accipiter virgatus and evolutionary history of the pseudo-control regions in Falconiformes. Biochemical Systematics and Ecology, Volume 58, February 2015, Pages 75-84.

[Abstract]

Highlights:

• A close relationship between Cathartidae and Ciconiidae (storks) was confirmed...
 
Japanese Sparrowhawk

Gang Liu, Chao Li, Youwen Du, Xiaoying Liu. The complete mitochondrial genome of Japanese sparrowhawk (Accipiter gularis) and the phylogenetic relationships among some predatory birds. Biochemical Systematics and Ecology. Volume 70, February 2017, Pages 116–125.

[abstract]
 
Warning! This thread is more than 8 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top