• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Birding on EastEnders (1 Viewer)

Euan Buchan

The Edinburgh Birdwatcher
Supporter
Scotland
I know this might seem a very bizarre topic but if you have watched EastEnders recently Birding has been the main hobby to two of the characters Freddie & Anna. They only just got into it a few months ago and it is mentioned a lot and they do mention certain bird names and go out with a recorder to record bird calls. I don’t think I’ve watched a soap and Birding ever gets mentioned so I’m happy it’s getting used here. I do find it funny obviously itvwas filmed ages ago and during outdoor scenes you can hear Swifts screaming and the two new Birders don’t notice.
 
Birding has featured in the Archers. Two of the characters, Robert Snell and Jim Lloyd, are both portrayed as keen birders. There have been plot points about stringing, there was a whole episode where various other characters were roped into the County bird race. There was even a Robert v Jim year list competition , but alas the producers must have lost interest and we never got to know the result.
 
Be careful about the background bird sounds you hear in movies or TV shows, the background sounds are added later and they could be recordings from anywhere.

When watching the Irish Open golf tournament in Kildare a few years ago I was amazed to hear a Mockingbird in the background - but of course they had simply added the background in from some standard effects recording.
 
Be careful about the background bird sounds you hear in movies or TV shows, the background sounds are added later and they could be recordings from anywhere.

When watching the Irish Open golf tournament in Kildare a few years ago I was amazed to hear a Mockingbird in the background - but of course they had simply added the background in from some standard effects recording.
European Bee-eaters on Postman Pat was one of my fave out-of-place background recordings. There are at least epsiodes where bee-eaters can clearly be heard. Not your typical day to day Welsh bird. Common Swifts have even featured on films set in a snowy landscape (they coudl be genuine, maybe it they filmed in summer and used artificial snow?). SW
 
European Bee-eaters on Postman Pat was one of my fave out-of-place background recordings. There are at least epsiodes where bee-eaters can clearly be heard. Not your typical day to day Welsh bird. Common Swifts have even featured on films set in a snowy landscape (they coudl be genuine, maybe it they filmed in summer and used artificial snow?). SW

Are there not other aspects of Postman Pat that are unrealistic? Our postal deliveries are terrible these days. :)

All the best

Paul
 
The BBC's First World War drama 'Birdsong' had Collared Doves played in the background, during scenes which took place in England, before the war. Somehow all the more amusing to find a birdsong related historical inaccuracy, considering the title of the thing!
 
I’m sure the Archers featured breeding Montague’s Harriers, many years ago.

Dr. Strangelove is partly set in a US airbase in the U.S. as soon as I heard Chiffchaffs I got suspicious. Sure enough, filmed in Germany. Strangely Mrs BH was not impressed with this bit of information.
 
The BBC's First World War drama 'Birdsong' had Collared Doves played in the background, during scenes which took place in England, before the war. Somehow all the more amusing to find a birdsong related historical inaccuracy, considering the title of the thing!
Practically every scene in The Crown that's set at Balmoral in the 70s and 80s features a cutaway to a Red Kite. Unless there was some kind of top secret re-introduction programme that predates the 1989 one, this is also an example of historically inaccurate birds. I'd audibly scoff every time I saw this, much to the annoyance of my partner.

Nightingales in America is a particular bugbear in TV. Also, the first episode of The Last Kingdom shows a falconer handling a Harris Hawk in early-medieval Northumbria. Of course, the misplaced calls of Great Northern Divers is the most prolific example in TV and cinema. Hearing it over the crater-scarred battlefield of the Somme in the film 1917 is a stand-out for me.

Obviously none of this really matters, but it can take you out of it for a moment (and annoy me, in particular).

I have to say though, it does increase my respect for production teams when they include geographically correct bird calls. For example, in Queen's Gambit. Lots of Yellow Warblers in the scenes set in the United States and Coal Tits for the scenes in Russia. Lots of kudos from me for that kind of attention to detail!

Even wildlife documentaries have been known to get this wrong. The Attenborough series Seven Worlds, One Planet was called-out for featuring the call of the Red-legged Seriema for a bit in a forest 1,000 miles from where the species actually occurs. Tut, tut!

For an example from "reality" TV, how about the Great Crested Grebes and Eurasian Black Vulture shown in the last series of the BBC's Race Across the World while the contestants travelled across the mountains of Chile?

As you can tell, I've dedicated way too much attention to all this (and also am possibly watching too much TV...).
 
Not sure if Chaffinches were supposed to be present in Middle Earth...but they're certainly all over New Zealand!
Finches are mentioned a number of times in Tolkien's writings set in Middle Earth, but I don't think it's ever said as specifically as at a species level.
 
Practically every scene in The Crown that's set at Balmoral in the 70s and 80s features a cutaway to a Red Kite. Unless there was some kind of top secret re-introduction programme that predates the 1989 one, this is also an example of historically inaccurate birds.
It could be remedied by depicting said bird being blasted out of the sky a few seconds after it appears, in a nod to contemporary attitudes amongst "game preservers"...

NB. apropos of the RF and raptors - alas that The Crown, ending where it does, will not (or not yet, anyway...) feature The Sandringham Incident...
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top