• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

For the same model of roof binoculars which one is less prone for CA 8x32 or 8x42? (2 Viewers)

Exactly, and many astronomers stop down their binocular objectives for exactly that reason. That is a good idea, and it would be interesting to see how it would work. That is exactly Henry did when he stopped down his Zeiss FL 8x56 to reduce CA
Then why binoculars companies don’t include inside of binoculars fancy apertures like the ones we see in camera lenses?
I mean like central focus adjusts the focus for both lenses, a similar central aperture control knob should adjust the aperture for both lenses.
 
Last edited:
That would be a very complicated, costly and vulnerable solution to an essentially non-existent problem.
Get over yourself and save up for a decent pair of upper mid-range binoculars, then you won't have to worry about all the bells and whistles. A Zeiss Conquest HD 8x32, for example, offers everything necessary even for demanding users and has recently been available for 600 euros.
You buy something like that once and then have peace of mind. Or buy some cheap glass and learn to live with its disadvantages instead of complaining. It's as simple as that.
 
Get over yourself and save up for a decent pair of upper mid-range binoculars, then you won't have to worry about all the bells and whistles. A Zeiss Conquest HD 8x32, for example, offers everything necessary even for demanding users and has recently been available for 600 euros.
Is €900 not €600 Zeiss Conquest HD Binoculars. - Optics Trade
In my country are even more expensive, over €1000.
I did not find any good optics store in Europe with decent prices, except those from Britain but for those will have to pay custom taxes because they are not anymore in EU after the brexit.

You buy something like that once and then have peace of mind.
I told you that I need one for using when visiting Brazil. For me peace of mind is not to be mugged or killed there.

Or buy some cheap glass and learn to live with its disadvantages instead of complaining. It's as simple as that.
I bought that cheap one for science, for research not for using it. Nobody should buy a €1000 for dissecting them unless sponsored with a large research grant, because that kind of research would cost too much.

Why do you mind about me dissecting binoculars for advancing the optic science? I dissect objects for study not living humans or animals.

And I didn’t complained, I just reviewed how easy is to stabilize a 7x reverse porro to get fine details and how easy to is follow birds in flight with that magnification despite some chromatic aberrations. And I figured out that I like that form factor when I will buy another reverse porro like Nikon Travelite EX because it fits easily in a medium winter jacket pocket and is single hinge.
 
Last edited:
Allright, good luck.
BTW, in Germany
You are German, tell me please some good stores in Germany or Austria where I can test and buy binoculars. I wanted to take a flight to Slovenia to Optics Trade (their employees are speaking English) but they usually have higher prices for the same binoculars.

Also in Eastern Europe we don’t have Birdfairs or anything similar where optic companies promote their binoculars. Do you have such things in Germany or there are birdfairs only in Britain and US as shown in the sticky post of this forum.
 
Last edited:
There may well be some bird fairs in Germany, but I don't know any because I'm not interested in such events.

I am by no means an expert on the market, but these large and reputable German dealers come to mind:
(same as Binoculars & Optics | OPTICS-PRO)

I'm sure there are many more recommended addresses, but these are the ones I can think of off the top of my head.
 
An Achromat lens system compensates the wavelength differences of two colors to diminish chromatic aberration.
For observation the two colors usually compensated are blue and red, and for photography, purple and red.
An achromat diminishes chromatic aberration so that only a little remains.
* Apochromat
An Apochromat lens system compensates the wavelength differences of three colors or more. For example, an apochromat system is designed to make purple, green and red focus at the same point so that chromatic aberration is significantly reduced.

The extensive edit in post #2 is still valid but completely out of date. Slow focal ratio achromatic doublets are hardly made anymore and with modern optical glass it is posible to make a 100 mm f/8 apochromatic doublet.

Even if might be seen outdated because there exist apochromatic lenses not only achromatic lenses, that post is still relevant for our day because the majority of producers can’t afford to include apochromatic lens elements because of their very high cost.
Most of binoculars advertised as ED pretending as reducing chromatic aberrations are achromat in order to maintain the price low.

You cat see from that quote:
"Although APO lenses are more effective against chromatic aberration, achromatic doublets are more common as they are cheaper, lighter and more compact (Best Binocular Reviews, n.d.)."

Ed glass doesn’t mean apochromat because ED refers to a range of glasses with varying levels of Fluorite content. Nearly all apochromatic refractors use one or more elements of ED glass so both terms correctly apply to many telescopes. Some use ED glass but fail to achieve apochromatic performance - to those, only the ED term applies.

Most ED binoculars are just with achromat lenses which mean compensate for only 2 Colors from the 3 that should be compensated. I mean they have chromatic aberations from they 3rd color that is not compensated, but those chromatic aberrations from the uncompensated 3rd color are just reduced by the use of ED glass.
In this case the binoculars with achromat instead of apochromat do not compensate to solve the problem, they just reduce the problem when they reduce the CA by use of ED glass. And like this are the majority of binoculars advertised as ED.

Is explained here

Lenspire

and here (see the section Achromatic Doublet Lens Correcting for Primary Longitudinal Chromatic Aberration but not correcting for the second one because the achromat doublet can correct only for 2 chromatic aberations, the secondary chromatic aberations represents the third color which is not corrected, only reduced with ED glass):

https://www.edmundoptics.com/knowledge-center/application-notes/optics/chromatic-and-monochromatic-optical-aberrations/
 
Last edited:
That quote of mine was in response to Dennis, who brought up the subject of CA in astronomical telescopes.
No binocular has a focal ratio of f/8 let alone f/15.
You seem to be confusing focal instruments (cameras) with afocal instruments (telescopes, binoculars).
Though binoculars are sometimes stopped down for test purposes, there is no benefit in doing so in practice because your own pupils accomplish this in bright light.
No problem with naive questions as in your original post, but it's rather presumptuous trying to explain optics to those with a better understanding than your own.

John
 
...but it's rather presumptuous trying to explain optics to those with a better understanding than your own.
Oddly enough also characteristic of Denco, with whom the OP seems to get along better.

The use of the word "dissection" in this context is interesting though. Dorubird uses it too. What is the word in Romanian (or French?) that suggests this?
 
...
The use of the word "dissection" in this context is interesting though. Dorubird uses it too. What is the word in Romanian (or French?) that suggests this?
I borrowed the medical term "dissection" with the meaning of presentation of my binoculars in the smallest hidden details and aspects, like a detailed medical report. I know, "dissection" it sounds macabre in any language, but that's not my intention, it's just a figure of speech 😁. Binolover, I supose, uses "dissection" with this meaning also.
 
Last edited:
I borrowed the medical term "dissection" with the meaning of presentation of my binoculars in the smallest hidden details and aspects, like a detailed medical report. I know, "dissection" it sounds macabre in any language, but that's not my intention, it's just a figure of speech 😁. Binolover, I supose, uses "dissection" with this meaning also.
I expected to see the pieces and sub assemblies of a binocular, spread out on a nice clean sheet of white paper, when I saw the word "dissection".

Imagine my surprise.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top