• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Difference between revisions of "Spectacled Thrush" - BirdForum Opus

(Deleted text replaced. Photo captions)
(edit misc)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
[[Image:Yellow-eyed_Thrush.jpg|thumb|550px|right|Photo by {{user|Graham+Osborne|Graham Osborne}}<br />Arima, [[Trinidad]], December 2005]]
 
[[Image:Yellow-eyed_Thrush.jpg|thumb|550px|right|Photo by {{user|Graham+Osborne|Graham Osborne}}<br />Arima, [[Trinidad]], December 2005]]
 
'''Alternative names: Bare-eyed Robin; Bare-eyed Thrush; Spectacled Thrush''' <br />
 
'''Alternative names: Bare-eyed Robin; Bare-eyed Thrush; Spectacled Thrush''' <br />
''See section on Naming below for alternate names.''
+
'''Includes: Ecuadorian Thrush'''
 
;[[:Category:Turdus|Turdus]] nudigenis
 
;[[:Category:Turdus|Turdus]] nudigenis
  
'''Includes: Ecuadorian Thrush'''
+
 
 
==Identification==
 
==Identification==
 
Upperparts are plain brown, with underside lighter. Throat is striped with white and brown, but a much more obvious field mark is the large yellow eyering that consists of bare facial skin. The bill is yellow. The color of the brown parts can vary quite a bit, some of the variation might be dependent on light quality, but some may also depend on geographic variation.
 
Upperparts are plain brown, with underside lighter. Throat is striped with white and brown, but a much more obvious field mark is the large yellow eyering that consists of bare facial skin. The bill is yellow. The color of the brown parts can vary quite a bit, some of the variation might be dependent on light quality, but some may also depend on geographic variation.
Line 11: Line 11:
 
[[Image:Ecuadorian Thrush.jpg|thumb|550px|right|''maculirostris'', Ecuadorian Thrush<br />Photo by {{user|Michael+W|Michael W}}<br />Rio Silanche (PVM), NW [[Ecuador]], March 2007]]
 
[[Image:Ecuadorian Thrush.jpg|thumb|550px|right|''maculirostris'', Ecuadorian Thrush<br />Photo by {{user|Michael+W|Michael W}}<br />Rio Silanche (PVM), NW [[Ecuador]], March 2007]]
 
==Naming==
 
==Naming==
This species is also known as Bare-eyed Robin (AOU checklist) or Bare-eyed Thrush (Clements checklist). One of these names is used in all the local field guides that I have looked at (for West Indies, and for Trinidad; I am 99% sure that the field guide for Venezuela also uses one of these two names). Yellow-eyed Thrush is from Sibley and Monroe, but it is not a good name: as you can see, it is not the eye but naked skin around that is yellow.
+
This species has in  the Americas traditionally been known as Bare-eyed Robin or Bare-eyed Thrush, and those are the names mostly used in local field guides. However, [[Bare-eyed Thrush]] on a world wide basis refer to the African species ''Turdus tephronotus''. Therefore, the South American Classification Committee and IOC have changed to Spectacled Thrush, which seems to be the name of the future for this species (Yellow-eyed Thrush is a misnomer as the eye is not yellow).  
 
 
Originally posted by njlarsen
 
 
 
I agree with Niels that the Sibley-Monroe made an unhappy choice for the English Common Name of this bird. The principle reason is that they preoccupied the Common Name Bare-eyed Thrush for the African - Turdus tephronotus.
 
 
 
Originally posted by cuckooroller
 
 
 
Turns out that the international committee that have recommended names for Birds of the World http://www.worldbirdnames.org/ have recommended American Bare-eyed Thrush for Turdus nudigenis and African Bare-eyed Thrush for Turdus tephronotus.
 
 
 
Originally posted by njlarsen
 
 
==Distribution==
 
==Distribution==
 
Western [[Ecuador]], North-western [[Peru]], Northern [[Brazil]] to [[Colombia]], [[Trinidad]] and [[Tobago]], and the [[Lesser Antilles]] reaching at least to [[Guadeloupe]]. This bird has been spreading north through the Lesser Antilles for example arriving in [[Martinique]] in 1951.  
 
Western [[Ecuador]], North-western [[Peru]], Northern [[Brazil]] to [[Colombia]], [[Trinidad]] and [[Tobago]], and the [[Lesser Antilles]] reaching at least to [[Guadeloupe]]. This bird has been spreading north through the Lesser Antilles for example arriving in [[Martinique]] in 1951.  
 
==Taxonomy==
 
==Taxonomy==
 
Three subspecies:
 
Three subspecies:
* ''T. n. nudigens'' in the [[Lesser Antilles]]
+
* ''T. n. nudigens'' in the [[Lesser Antilles]], [[Trinidad]] and [[Tobago]], and northern [[South America]] to the Amazon river from [[Colombia]] to the [[Guianas]]
* ''T. n. extimus'' in [[Brazil]]
+
* ''T. n. extimus'' in [[Brazil]] south of the Amazon
 
* ''T. n. maculirostris'' in [[Ecuador]] and [[Peru]]
 
* ''T. n. maculirostris'' in [[Ecuador]] and [[Peru]]
''Maculirostris'' has been split as '''Ecuadorian Thrush''', but recently there is a trend to lump the two forms.
+
''Maculirostris'' has sometimes been split as '''Ecuadorian Thrush''', and a recent decision by SACC indicates that this is the trend again.
 
==Habitat==
 
==Habitat==
 
It seems mainly to occur in cultivated areas and open dry forest in [[Dominica]], while the [[Forest Thrush]] is found in old growth rainforest.  
 
It seems mainly to occur in cultivated areas and open dry forest in [[Dominica]], while the [[Forest Thrush]] is found in old growth rainforest.  
 
==Behaviour==
 
==Behaviour==
 
This thrush is agressive towards other similar birds and has been suspected as a culprit in the near extinction of [[Forest Thrush]] from [[St. Lucia]].   
 
This thrush is agressive towards other similar birds and has been suspected as a culprit in the near extinction of [[Forest Thrush]] from [[St. Lucia]].   
 +
==References==
 +
# Clements, James F. 2007. ''The Clements Checklist of Birds of the World''. 6th ed., with updates to October 2007. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. ISBN 9780801445019
 +
#[http://www.museum.lsu.edu/~Remsen/SACCprop295x.html SACC proposal] to change name from Yellow-eyed Thrush to Spectacled Thrush
 +
#[http://www.museum.lsu.edu/~Remsen/SACCprop385.html SACC proposal] to split Ecuadorian Thrush from the current species
 +
{{ref}}
 
==External Links==
 
==External Links==
 
{{GSearch|Turdus+nudigenis}}
 
{{GSearch|Turdus+nudigenis}}
 
[[Category:Birds]] [[Category:Turdus]]
 
[[Category:Birds]] [[Category:Turdus]]

Revision as of 01:04, 1 September 2009

Photo by Graham Osborne
Arima, Trinidad, December 2005

Alternative names: Bare-eyed Robin; Bare-eyed Thrush; Spectacled Thrush
Includes: Ecuadorian Thrush

Turdus nudigenis


Identification

Upperparts are plain brown, with underside lighter. Throat is striped with white and brown, but a much more obvious field mark is the large yellow eyering that consists of bare facial skin. The bill is yellow. The color of the brown parts can vary quite a bit, some of the variation might be dependent on light quality, but some may also depend on geographic variation.

Similar Species

The yellow eyering is shared with Forest Thrush, but the latter species has underside scaled in brown and white.

maculirostris, Ecuadorian Thrush
Photo by Michael W
Rio Silanche (PVM), NW Ecuador, March 2007

Naming

This species has in the Americas traditionally been known as Bare-eyed Robin or Bare-eyed Thrush, and those are the names mostly used in local field guides. However, Bare-eyed Thrush on a world wide basis refer to the African species Turdus tephronotus. Therefore, the South American Classification Committee and IOC have changed to Spectacled Thrush, which seems to be the name of the future for this species (Yellow-eyed Thrush is a misnomer as the eye is not yellow).

Distribution

Western Ecuador, North-western Peru, Northern Brazil to Colombia, Trinidad and Tobago, and the Lesser Antilles reaching at least to Guadeloupe. This bird has been spreading north through the Lesser Antilles for example arriving in Martinique in 1951.

Taxonomy

Three subspecies:

Maculirostris has sometimes been split as Ecuadorian Thrush, and a recent decision by SACC indicates that this is the trend again.

Habitat

It seems mainly to occur in cultivated areas and open dry forest in Dominica, while the Forest Thrush is found in old growth rainforest.

Behaviour

This thrush is agressive towards other similar birds and has been suspected as a culprit in the near extinction of Forest Thrush from St. Lucia.

References

  1. Clements, James F. 2007. The Clements Checklist of Birds of the World. 6th ed., with updates to October 2007. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. ISBN 9780801445019
  2. SACC proposal to change name from Yellow-eyed Thrush to Spectacled Thrush
  3. SACC proposal to split Ecuadorian Thrush from the current species

Recommended Citation

External Links

Back
Top