• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
Where premium quality meets exceptional value. ZEISS Conquest HDX.

Differences between book editions? (1 Viewer)

m1997

New member
Netherlands
Hi,

I have a question regarding two books in the Helm Identification Guides series.

Could you perhaps tell me what the differences are between these two versions:

A Guide to the Owls of the World by Claus König, Friedhelm Weick & Jan-Hendrik Becking (1999) ; ISBN 9781873403747

Owls of the World by Claus König & Friedhelm Weick (2008) ; ISBN 9780300142273

Thankyou^^

Mitchel
 
The changes will be mainly taxonomic e'g ' twelve new species that have been discovered over the last decade' but, there must be differences for each to be referred to as 'edition' otherwise they are simply reprints.
 
The changes will be mainly taxonomic e'g ' twelve new species that have been discovered over the last decade' but, there must be differences for each to be referred to as 'edition' otherwise they are simply reprints.
The later work has been described as "a thoroughly updated edition of the authors’ previous volume".

Jan-Hendrik Becking's name was dropped from the cover of the second edition:

1723910291098.png1723910246779.png
 
Reading through some reviews of the 2nd edition it seems that only changes were the taxonomic ones Andy mentioned along with extra plates and text describing the new spilts.
 
Reading through some reviews of the 2nd edition it seems that only changes were the taxonomic ones Andy mentioned along with extra plates and text describing the new spilts.
Nice, that would make it more accurate than the first edition. Thanks for the help :)

Are there more books like these?
 
Probably not the answer that was looked for but, as we are in the taxonomy forum :
In 1999, the phylogenies in the "Molecular phylogeny and evolution of Owls (Strigiformes)" chapter were based on mitochondrial cytochrome b sequences only; in 2008 they also made use of nuclear RAG-1 sequences. This chapter was very significantly edited.
(I have not seen the rest of the 1999 edition, so cannot comment on it.)
;)
 
Nice, that would make it more accurate than the first edition. Thanks for the help :)

Are there more books like these?
Claus König & Friedhelm Weick say in Owls of the World (2008): “The first (1999) edition of this book was well received and is now out of print, which has encouraged the publishers to ask us to prepare this revised and enlarged second edition. The text and bibliography have been brought up to date and new colour plates have been added, to reflect changes in the taxonomic literature and a number of species entirely new to science. Moreover, all 64 of the original colour plates have been revised and corrected where necessary, and eight new plates added. The chapter on DNA evidence has been updated by Michael Wink and colleagues … We owe many thanks to our colleague Dr Jan-Hendrik Becking for his highly appreciated contributions to the first edition of 1999, which have been incorporated into this new edition.”

A similar comprehensive work is Owls of the World - A Photographic Guide by Heimo Mikkola (second edition 2013).
 
Claus König & Friedhelm Weick say in Owls of the World (2008): “The first (1999) edition of this book was well received and is now out of print, which has encouraged the publishers to ask us to prepare this revised and enlarged second edition. The text and bibliography have been brought up to date and new colour plates have been added, to reflect changes in the taxonomic literature and a number of species entirely new to science. Moreover, all 64 of the original colour plates have been revised and corrected where necessary, and eight new plates added. The chapter on DNA evidence has been updated by Michael Wink and colleagues … We owe many thanks to our colleague Dr Jan-Hendrik Becking for his highly appreciated contributions to the first edition of 1999, which have been incorporated into this new edition.”

A similar comprehensive work is Owls of the World - A Photographic Guide by Heimo Mikkola (second edition 2013).
I just found that same quote so it seems to be the definitive version for now :)
 
Nice, that would make it more accurate than the first edition. Thanks for the help :)

Are there more books like these?
For all the owls of the world not that I know of, but more limited in scope the book Neotropical Owls is also pretty good.
 
Hi,

I have a question regarding two books in the Helm Identification Guides series.

Could you perhaps tell me what the differences are between these two versions:

A Guide to the Owls of the World by Claus König, Friedhelm Weick & Jan-Hendrik Becking (1999) ; ISBN 9781873403747

Owls of the World by Claus König & Friedhelm Weick (2008) ; ISBN 9780300142273

Thankyou^^

Mitchel
It's just the old version and the updated new version.
 
Claus König & Friedhelm Weick say in Owls of the World (2008): “The first (1999) edition of this book was well received and is now out of print, which has encouraged the publishers to ask us to prepare this revised and enlarged second edition. The text and bibliography have been brought up to date and new colour plates have been added, to reflect changes in the taxonomic literature and a number of species entirely new to science. Moreover, all 64 of the original colour plates have been revised and corrected where necessary, and eight new plates added. The chapter on DNA evidence has been updated by Michael Wink and colleagues … We owe many thanks to our colleague Dr Jan-Hendrik Becking for his highly appreciated contributions to the first edition of 1999, which have been incorporated into this new edition.”

A similar comprehensive work is Owls of the World - A Photographic Guide by Heimo Mikkola (second edition 2013).

It's all really simple here. "A Guide to the Owls of the World" (1999): This version was the first in the series and contains detailed descriptions of all known owl species at the time of publication. "Owls of the World" (2008): This is an updated and expanded edition. It includes new data obtained over almost a decade of research, as well as updated taxonomy and distribution information for owls. I have even found a newer version and started reading it. For this I even found a writing service for college I used https://ca.papersowl.com/admission-essay-writing-service so that nothing distracts me. In the new version, everything is completely different. When I finish reading, I will report this book to the forum. I can only say that the new version is from 2010.
Everything is described very accurately. But a new version of the book for 2010 has already been published.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top