Redpoll species, Warwickshire, UK (1 Viewer)

[Matt Griffiths]

Hi all,

I received the following photos taken earlier this month (on 14th) of a pale redpoll, and wonder if it could be a Mealy. I think it looks good for one but am cautious about the ID given that there are many faded Lessers around at this time of year, and none of the shots fully show the rump. What do people think?

Photos have been sharpened a little and cropped by the observer, but otherwise there has been no colour adjustment.

Kind regards,
Matt

 

[Iceberg slim]

We had Mealies on the deck at Brandon so had an easy comparison,The cold tones suggest mealy, but no other species for comparison, so not 100%..

 

[JoeRawles]

The latter two images, presuming they're of the same bird, suggest Lesser to me.

 

[JHDraytonbassettpits]

Worth reading this http://redpolls-worcestershireredpo.../09/worcestershire-redpolls-and-guide-to.html

 

[Matt Griffiths]

Thanks all. Doesn't look like a definite ID is possible on these photos alone then.
Matt