what has caused the decline in insects ? pesticides ? climate change ?
Without doubt pesticides and climate change have played their parts, but habitat decline is the main volume reduction factor. There are two inter-related mechanisms that are key.
First, the extent of habitat reduction, especially for specialist species that cannot adapt quickly, is evident, but second, the simplified plant communities that remain in the reduced areas of habitat cannot support either the variety of insects and arthropods that depended upon them, or the numbers.
A couple of examples will serve: the Red-backed Shrike disappeared because a vital plant community became simplified; because the bird primarily uses perches to scan for large insects/arthropods and insect/arthropod larvae on the ground, the persistence of short-sward grasses is essential for sightlines and for successful hunting. However, modern industrial agricultural techniques mitigate against short-sward grasses, as do non-persistent herbicides. Consequently, coarse long-grass species become dominant, large insect/arthropods diminish, which means low density of prey and these are more difficult to find.
The second example is that suitable habitats for specialist plants or for exploitation by birds no longer exist in many parts of UK in non-fragmented form. Fragmentation of habitat usually (but not always) means that the highest occupation density by birds is never achieved on the scale that continuous habitat generally meets. Edge effects (
eg on nuthatches in small woods) result in occupancy of perhaps 50% of that expected.
Pesticides perhaps nowadays are less the villain of the piece that once they were, but non-persistent molluscicides are highly effective in virtually emiminating slugs and snails and so Song Thrushes (specialists) suffer more than Blackbirds (generalists).
Modern pesticides have indirect effects, but rarely poison birds directly - the problem lies with the huge stocks of purchased persticides from before that era (although uneducated farm workers across the world make a nonsense of sensible advice by doubling or trebling the dose 'to make it work better', rather like people taken to casualty with Paracetamol poisoning because they took 20 tablets instead of two to make their headache go away more quickly).
MJB