• Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.

    Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
ZEISS DTI thermal imaging cameras. For more discoveries at night, and during the day.

Nomenclature changes (5 Viewers)

All Turtle Doves to Turtle-Doves and all Collared Doves to Collared-Doves. Almost everyone writes them with hyphen (although H&M doesn't).
Same with the Cuckoo-Doves. There even H&M agree on the hyphen.

André
 
Last edited:
Page "Black and White Tanager" moved to "Black-and-White Tanager".
Page "Black and White Becard" moved to "Black-and-white Becard".

as per all authorities.

Niels
 
Last edited:
Niels, do you have an authority for the capital W in "Black-and-White Tanager"? Avibase shows all lowercase.

As you suspected, I had made an error, which is now corrected. Looking into Opus, the same must have been the case for Black-and-White Owl which I have also corrected (I cannot remember if I did this one originally).

Cheers
Niels
 
I continue with the rest of the B&W birds. The only iffy one is
Page "Black and White Shrike Flycatcher" moved to "Black-and-white Shrike-Flycatcher".
The form I chose is only used by H&M while Clements and S&M use lower case "f" in flycatcher. As this species belongs to a group which in the linear sequence is between "old world flycatchers" and "fantails" and the group itself has several members named "Flycatcher" (e.g., Ward's Flycatcher), I concluded that the H&M form is more likely to be correct. If anyone knows better, I am ready to change again.

Cheers
Niels
 
Page "Yellow-whiskered Bush Tanager" moved to "Short-billed Bush Tanager".

Clements and H&M agree on Short-billed; even if they disagree on a hyphen after Bush, which I have chosen to leave alone for now but just make redirects for the hyphenated form.

Niels
 
Page "Grey-hooded Bush Tanager" moved to "Gray-hooded Bush Tanager".

American spelling of American birds

Niels
 
Page "Black and Yellow Tanager" moved to "Black-and-yellow Tanager".
Page "Scarlet and White Tanager" moved to "Scarlet-and-white Tanager".
Page "Blue and Black Tanager" moved to "Blue-and-black Tanager".
Page "Black and Gold Tanager" moved to "Black-and-gold Tanager".
Page "Blue and Gold Tanager" moved to "Blue-and-gold Tanager".
Page "Blue and Yellow Tanager" moved to "Blue-and-yellow Tanager".
Page "Grey and Gold Tanager" moved to "Gray-and-gold Tanager".
Page "Green and Gold Tanager" moved to "Green-and-gold Tanager".
Page "Rust and Yellow Tanager" moved to "Rust-and-yellow Tanager".

consensus of all checklists

Niels
 
Page "Black-crowned Palm Tanager" moved to "Black-crowned Palm-Tanager".
Page "Grey-crowned Palm Tanager" moved to "Gray-crowned Palm-Tanager".

Consensus Clements and S&M (and American spelling for one of them)
Niels
 
Page "Tucuman Pygmy Owl" moved to "Tucuman Pygmy-Owl".
Page "Ferruginous Pygmy Owl" moved to "Ferruginous Pygmy-Owl".
Page "Peruvian Pygmy Owl" moved to "Peruvian Pygmy-Owl".

I will continue with the Pygmy-Owls at a later time.

Consensus S&M with Clements. H&M either disagrees or has not recognized the species.

Niels

Edit: and that should be the rest of the pygmy-owls.
 
Last edited:
Eastern and Western Chat Tanagers hyphenated. Everybody, even including both H&M and Gill & Wright uses the hyphen!

Niels

Edit: same thing with Rosy Thrush-Tanager
 
Last edited:
Page "Grey-headed Tanager" moved to "Gray-headed Tanager".

American spelling of American birds

Page "Black-throated Shrike Tanager" moved to "Black-throated Shrike-Tanager".
and the other shrike tanagers of genus Lanio as well: Consensus including H&M and Gill & Wright!


Niels
 
All Myiophonus Whistling Thrushes moved to Myophonus Whistling-Thrushes. According to consensus.

Aztec Thrush from Zoothera to Ridgwayia (like everyone execpt S&M)
Varied Thrush from Zoothera to Ixoreus (like everyone execpt S&M)

André
 
Last edited:
Sooty Owls -> Sooty-Owls
Masked Owls -> Masked-Owls
Grass Owls -> Grass-Owls
Bay Owls -> Bay-Owls
...per consensus

Bismarck Masked-Owl -> Golden Masked-Owl
...per discussion
 
Scops Owls -> Scops-Owls (SOOOOOO MANY!!!)
Grand Comoro Scops-Owl -> Comoro Scops-Owl
Rainforest Scops-Owl -> Malagasy Scops-Owl
...by consensus.

Common Scops-Owl -> Eurasian Scops-Owl
...by discussion.
 
Eagle Owls -> Eagle-Owls
Fish Owls -> Fish-Owls
Fishing Owls -> Fishing-Owls
Wood Owls -> Wood-Owls
...per Clements and S&M base

Sichuan Wood-Owl -> Pere David's Owl
...per Clements and IOC 2nd tiebreaker
 
Warning! This thread is more than 14 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top