Taphrospilus
Well-known member
Ornismya atala Lesson 1833 OD here (I need to checck Priority for the exact date but not availble for me today)
The Eponym Dictionary of Birds
The Key to Scientific Names
Atala’s Emerald Gould 1860 here and text. Publishing date is 1860 and not 1861 here as part of delivery 20 (XX). And possibly, as a follow-on to Lesson is a clearly no. Not possibly as Gould clearly referenced to Lesson. So why possibly (not read the description)?
The question remains if Lesson really named two birds after his daughter under different names. Maybe the solution is to find in the environment of Florent Prevost?
If synonym to Chlorostilbon mellisugus caribaeus Lawrence, 1871 I ask myself why has Lesson no priority?
The Eponym Dictionary of Birds
Atala's Emerald Chlorostilbon atala Gould, c.1861 NCR [JS Chlorostilbon mellisugus]
Probably not an eponym; i.e. it should be the Atala Emerald rather than Atala's Emerald, and may be derived from the Greek atalos, meaning delicate. Possibly, as a follow-on to Lesson's naming of Ornismya atala (1832), which could be after the heroine of a novel by Chateaubriand Atala ou Les Amours de Deux Savages dans le Desert (1801) or even after his daughter: see Cecilia (Gautrau).
The Key to Scientific Names
Cécile Estelle Atala Lesson (1819-1845) first daughter of French naturalist René P. Lesson (“Atala’s Emerald” of Gould 1861) (cf. Atala, daughter of a Muscogee chieftain and heroine of de Chateaubriand’s romantic novel (1801) Atala, ou Les Amours de deux sauvages dans le désert) (syn. Chlorostilbon canivetii caribaeus).
Atala’s Emerald Gould 1860 here and text. Publishing date is 1860 and not 1861 here as part of delivery 20 (XX). And possibly, as a follow-on to Lesson is a clearly no. Not possibly as Gould clearly referenced to Lesson. So why possibly (not read the description)?
The question remains if Lesson really named two birds after his daughter under different names. Maybe the solution is to find in the environment of Florent Prevost?
If synonym to Chlorostilbon mellisugus caribaeus Lawrence, 1871 I ask myself why has Lesson no priority?
Last edited: